‘For my money a confident, articulate “restrained” heterosexual or gay man has a much better chance of happiness than an “unrestrained” bisexual who may fancy twice as many people but doesn’t have the social skills to start up a conversation with any of them.’
Jo Eadie
That was a letter that ran in The Pink Paper on 18th October – and yes, I did write it.
Now you might be sitting there thinking ‘that doesn’t sound like Jo Eadie to me’ – or, if you’re one of those people who writes to BCN to say ‘I’m planning to cancel my subscription because of Jo Eadie’s increasingly anti-bisexual comments’ then maybe you’re thinking ‘that sounds just like Jo Eadie to me’. But, contrary to popular opinion, I don’t in fact think that bisexuals are any sadder than the rest of the world – although I do agree with Lisa Power’s recent description of the bisexual community as having ‘a high proportion of unrealistic optimism and energy and a big ration of total loonies’ (in Mark Simpson’s book ‘Anti-gay’).
What, then, am I doing writing to The Pink Paper saying things like that? Well, The Pink Paper is a funny old thing – and Steve C of BCN has done much to convince me that we don’t always understand how it (and the rest of the gay, and even straight, press) works.
In Steve’s model (see BCN Issue 6) there is a scale of things journalists think about bisexuality. At one end there’s the ‘I’m-really-supportive-but-I-never-find-out-what’s-going-on’ journalists, who would love to cover bi events, except that we don’t ever send them press releases, invites or photographs, and then we sit around wondering why they don’t talk more about bisexuality. At the other end?
Well, at the other end there’s whoever cut, modified and re-edited a letter of mine to The Pink Paper so that it read as a piece of blatant biphobia. This, then, is the story of that letter.
The Pink has been running a serious of ‘exposes’ (if one can dignify them with that word) on co-counselling, a form of therapy that The Pink tells us is homophobic in its claims that it can ‘cure’ homosexuality.
Adherents of co-counselling have been writing in to say that no, no, they’re not homophobic, they just believe that homosexuality is a limited sexuality, which arises when we are unable to express our ‘full bisexual potential’, the expression of which would make us joyful, spontaneous, and happy.
Now, I don’t know about you, but I think this argument is a pile of patronising shit. It reminds me of those white folk who go up to black people and say ‘I really envy your sense of rhythm’, or the men who go up to women and say ‘I really envy the fact that you can give birth’.
This kind of creeping envy is ignorant of the realities of other people’s lives – and it’s arrogant in its assumption that you can guess at how someone else experiences their body. It’s a pitiful apology by those who have social privilege but pretend that they’re worse off. It’s the wishful projection of the idea that somehow, somewhere, there’s something that will make your life better, and someone else has it and is having all the fun.
When it comes to that line about ‘I’m losing out because I’m repressing my innate bisexuality – but I’m having counselling to help me recover it’, I think there are two major mistakes these people make. And you’ll know what they are if you’ve ever been to a party and not got off with anyone – and in my book, there are two sorts of parties where that happens.
The first is that one where you don’t fancy anyone: there’s that very cute boy in the corner, but he really pissed me off by defending the Gulf War; there’s three women all dressed like Tiffany from ‘EastEnders’; there’s the man with a beard… but that’s quite enough about BiCon for now. Where is that bisexual polymorphous perversity? Has it just gone on holiday? No – it was never there. Bis don’t have ‘more’ desire than anyone else – they just desire different things.
Ask the bi top who only enjoys tying his lovers to the bedposts; ask the bi femme who only likes her women to be butch and boyish; ask the bi bigot who never has sex with anyone old, fat, black, or disabled. Best of all, ask those people who say ‘I’m not attracted to bodies, just people’ why they always mysteriously seem to have lovers who look so similar. Yes folks – bisexuals have preferences (i.e. limitations) too.
As for the second sort of party – well that’s the one where you fancy everyone. Everyone is just drop-dead gorgeous, just your type – and you want to shag them all senseless. Can you strike up a conversation? No you can’t. Can you think of a witty opening line? No you can’t. Can you catch anyone’s eye? Nope.
You sit there feeling shy and awkward, you pretend to look at your watch, you drink lots, and eventually you go home early. What’s the benefit of being into men and women, SM and vanilla, casual and committed relationships, if you can’t manage a good chat-up line (and God knows, I can’t).
So even if Freud’s polymorphous pervert did exist, if he doesn’t know how to get the sort of sex he’s after then basically he’s fucked – or rather, he isn’t fucked.
So as I see it, hankering after your repressed bisexual potential is unlikely to bring you much happiness one way or another. You’d be better off working at developing the skills that will get you what you want, instead of trying to turn yourself into the sort of person who you somehow imagine is getting all the sex that you aren’t.
Well, I was just so pleased with all these ruminations that I banged them all down and sent them off to the paper, and concluded it all with the fairly sensible claim that you’ll see at the top of this page: that ‘a confident, articulate “restrained” heterosexual or gay man has a much better chance of happiness than an “unrestrained” bisexual who may fancy twice as many people but doesn’t have the social skills to start up a conversation with any of them’.
But for some strange reason The Pink don’t seem to have been interested in the arguments (or the jokes) – they just seem to be interested in printing that one line. I guess they must have mistaken me for one of their regular readers.
Jo Eadie
