If you only sleep with other bisexuals, what are you missing?
I remember my disastrous first relationship with a heterosexual. ‘I could never find someone of my own sex attractive,’ she told me; ‘what about you?’
There was enough pointed disapproval in her voice to put me off giving her an honest answer, but it placed a clear barrier between us.
It’s true that since then I’ve had relationships with people who didn’t call themselves bisexual – although most of them do now! – but my most enduring relationships have been with other bisexuals. And it’s certainly not uncommon to hear other bisexuals telling the same story: greater understanding, no need to explain, seeing the world in the same way.
On the other hand, this is a very limited list of what you can get out of a relationship. What about having to explain who you are, and in doing so finding out more about yourself?
What about spending years never understanding why the other person does that one weird thing and then one day it makes perfect sense? What about someone who has a completely different explanation from you for everything about your life together? What about the delirious pleasures of difference?
The idea that you get on best with people who are ‘like’ you is partly a reaction to heterosexism: after thousands of years of being told that ‘opposites (i.e. men and women) attract’, part of the radical counter-attack has been to say: ‘no, it’s people who are like each other who are most suited’. But perhaps the rhetoric which has fuelled the last twenty years of identity politics and gay ghettos is starting to sound just as banal.
I was neither surprised, nor impressed, to be told by a lesbian acquaintance that a woman could only ever find her ‘soul-mate’ in another woman. Why? Because, apparently, a woman can only ever really be happy with someone who knows what it feels like when she’s having her period.
Well, if only it were true. I’d love it if all I needed for the perfect relationship was someone who knew what it felt like to be failed vegan. But then they might not know what it’s like when I feel suicidal. And I’d love it if I could be happy with someone who knew what that felt like. But then maybe they won’t understand it when I want to stay up all night reading Foucault.
And then, there are the people who think they do understand me because they are suicidal Foucault-reading ex-vegans – but who experience those states in completely different ways. If you’re one of those, I’d appreciate it if you didn’t write to tell me how much we have in common.
What’s so misleading is the idea that any two bisexuals have access to a special kind of sameness, and that’s the best basis for a relationship. It’s time to start thinking about bisexualities. I’m bisexual because, in spite of a series of life-defining, male-female relationships, I’ve never gotten over falling in love with my best male friend, and I often feel that whatever form my desire takes, that’s the body I’m trying to find my way back to. I don’t think this gives me anything in common with, for instance, someone who’s bisexual because s/he is ‘not attracted to bodies, only people’. I just don’t see that we interpret, experience, or live out our sexualities in similar ways.
So going back to my first lover, what built the wall between us was not our different sexualities, but our different ideas about what goes into a relationship.
If her question ‘what about you’ had been warm and open, we could have bridged that gap of enjoyable difference. Instead, it opened up a chasm between us.
And if an ardent bisexual says: ‘I could never find someone who wasn’t bisexual attractive, how about you’ in that same tone, that same chasm would open up again.
Jo Eadie
Case Study: Rachael and Jo
Jo and I have been together for about 7 years so it’s hard for me to say what is so special about bisexual partners as opposed to lesbian or straight partners. I’m very happy having a bi partner and I wouldn’t want it any different.
There is a perception that bis are more willing to talk about things such as sex and emotions but I think that maybe is a queer thing rather than an exclusively bi thing. We do talk about things a heterosexual couple don’t usually talk about, our relationship wouldn’t have lasted if we hadn’t been able to talk through issues. We have a shared politics as well as a shared sexuality, and that’s important for me too.
I’d like to say that gender of partner is unimportant but that isn’t true. Other people certainly see us differently than if I were in a relationship with a woman. I find that I’m not as physical in public with Jo as I am with female lovers. I rarely walk hand in hand down the street with Jo, whereas I would with female lovers – maybe something to do with countering prejudice.
When Jo and I got together, people assumed that Jo was gay and I was his ‘fag hag’ (disgusting phrase!). That was annoying. Now, we don’t get that sort of attitude, people don’t even assume that we are hetero – something has changed, it could be that we go to queer places rather than gay ones. Either that or I don’t notice people assuming what our relationship is.
I’m proud of our relationship, wouldn’t want it any other way.
Interview by Kevin Saunders
Case Study: Lucy and Sarah – Living with a Lesbian
I’ve known Lucy for three years. At first we had an on-off relationship but for the past year we’ve had a pretty solid partnership. Lucy identifies as a lesbian, in fact she’s quite a political lesbian, and I am a bisexual.
I had a relationship with a bi woman before I met Lucy and there are differences between the two relationships. Of course, most of the differences are down to the fact that people are different. But I am aware that I temper things I do sometimes because Lucy and I have different identities.
With a bi woman there’s a feeling of being in exactly the same club. It was easier to make jokes at the expense of men, with bi women, because deep down we both knew that politically and emotionally we hadn’t written men off. With Lucy, although she is not a man-hater, I feel I need to stand up for the men of the world.
Although we do talk about the people we fancy I probably edit my thoughts about men more than I would with a bi woman – I don’t talk about the men I fancy as much as I would. This false censorship is I’m sure unnecessary as I know that Lucy doesn’t disapprove of my feelings.
I think that my effect on Lucy is that she is more comfortable about talking about men and how she feels about them than when I first met her. We do talk about our sexual fantasies. But I think it would be easier for me to do it when it’s about men with a bi woman partner.
I’ve had a relationship with a lesbian separatist before. She gave me a really hard time for ‘giving my energies to men’ (she’s now living with a bloke and has a kid). At the time it was an impossible situation to maintain. Even though we tried to understand each other we were both having to constantly justify our lifestyles.
My colleagues at work know about my relationship with Lucy. Those who don’t know me well have assumed that I’m a lesbian.
I’m not always able to challenge that. The assumptions are sometimes conveyed in such a subtle way that I’d feel stupid challenging them. If I started a discussion about being bi rather than lesbian I think I’d feel I’d have to go into a whole political and personal discussion (which knowing many of them could easily be misinterpreted) and I’d end up feeling disloyal to Lucy.
It’s hard enough being out in the real world without having to constantly point out to people who false their suppositions can be.
But it’s not just work-mates that make assumptions. Lucy and I have been to bi events together in the past. I sometimes feel that there’s an assumption that everyone that comes to a bi event is bisexual. Maybe there should be more awareness, a bigger welcome for straight or gay people who are joining in.
Interview by Kevin Saunders
Emma and Steve – when your partner’s straight but not narrow
Steve and I have known each other for about 12 years, we’re now married with a child. Steve is straight. He did have a relationship with a man before I knew him, on the basis of ‘Don’t knock it ’til you’ve tried it.’ It didn’t really work for him, he’s definitely straight.
I suppose the main difference between having a straight partner to having a bi partner is that Steve is monogamous. I’m not and I have bi partners at the moment. That side of the relationship can be tricky to negotiate.
Steve is friendly with my bi friends but he generally stays away from bi events. He didn’t go to Pride this year for example. The other side of that is I have a life outside the bi world rather than being in the bi/queer world all the time.
The other difference is that we were introduced to each other’s families within a year. That’s quite a hetero kind of thing.
I’ve been trying to come out to my family for ages but they don’t seem interested. I introduced my first female lover to them when I was at college, but they didn’t really recognise she was my lover.
People assume that I’m straight, especially when they find out I have a son. I do come out in some situations to counter that assumption but I often think long and hard before taking the risk.
Interview by Kevin Saunders
