How do your bisexuality and your religion have an impact on each other? In the first of a series of articles, Steve C examines Christianity.
Annie
Christian, Queer Tart and Proud
‘I was brought up in somewhat of a hybrid of religions, and would now, on the whole, call myself generally Christian. And so my beloved and I have chosen, much to the amazement of our friends, to have a Christian-ish wedding. We met a wonderful Minister from the Metropolitan Community Church whose first question to my beloved was “I’m sorry if this is a silly question, but is it a man or a woman you are marrying?”
‘During our “pre-wedding talk” he went further and, very much interspersed with our mutual Christianity and belief, recommended a bible reading where the immortal words “My lover is hung like a donkey” allegedly appear. He also dealt extremely well with the fact that our wedding service will not include the promise “to forsake all others” – because we have no intention of doing so (let’s be realistic here…) and explained in graphic detail why one should not wear gloves when one is getting married – “the resultant swelling of the fingers necessitates Liquid Silk to get the wedding ring on…”
‘All in all, the stronger my Christian belief – and that is the way I am rapidly moving – the more positive experiences I am finding. One can indeed be a queer tart, fucking a different person with a different bit of dangly bits every night – and beat the hide off them every day – whilst being a very committed Christian. The two are not mutually exclusive.
‘For me Christianity has always been a positive experience – if one that until recently I felt shy talking about. Now it is one of the most enhancing and affirming parts of my life. It, at least in the form of the Metropolitan Community Church, is accepting (what other Church can you think of who wouldn’t be remotely phased by marrying a person with AIDS), amusing and… FUN. It makes me feel good about my sexuality and my life choices… it is OK to be queer and at the same time to want to marry a man and to believe in a God who many people believe to be the excuse and the rationale for homophobia.’
Robert
Closeted Fundamentalist (as told by Steve C)
Annie has found Christianity positive and life-enhancing. That is not the experience of a great many bisexuals. I have several friends utterly estranged from their families in part because of religion, others who have painfully discarded their faith in order to win self-acceptance. One friend went through ‘Christian’ reprogramming to try to change his sexuality – he’s now happy, still Christian, and thoroughly gay, but not everyone gets through as happy or well-adjusted. Others have had long difficult journeys to some new, safer spiritual home.
Only a couple of my friends remain in the religious tradition of their childhood. Their experience is usually one of hostility and rejection. And yet spiritual needs are still felt, however they are expressed.
Take Robert. I’ve changed the name but you couldn’t invent this man. Robert is a self-closeted fundamentalist.
Every word in the Bible is true and there are no contradictions. All sex outside marriage is wrong. Even though Robert admits his sexual preference for men. In these circumstances he’s decided to remain celibate, waiting for the Holy Spirit to make him straight.
Robert is a little knot of contention. He is in everyone’s face about everything, but particularly sexuality. In his case the old cliche about queer bashers being frustrated queers is clearly true, not that he will admit it. People are sick of having the Bible rammed down their throats. But if we step back from it the person most oppressed by Robert, and least able to escape him, is Robert himself.
Hannah
Giving all for God
Why do people have spiritual needs? What experience leads them to adopt or change their beliefs? Hannah’s search began as a child.
‘Through friends I joined the Girl Crusaders Union, an evangelical organisation taught almost exclusively by Good Women of the old fashioned spinster variety. Warm but stern Victorian values… “Giving all for God” was the highest ideal, particularly unsuitable men. Very close intimate friendships were formed and I did, eventually go to bed with one of the girls I had been on summer camp with. We both had the same good memories of it all. I don’t know where she is but going to bed with her was the best thing I ever did.’
After some searching, Hannah became a Catholic as a teenager (‘partly to annoy my parents who were non-practising Unitarians’).
‘My first Mass remains an abiding memory of a powerful spiritual experience. I still can’t speak of it. It convinced me by experience of the truth of transubstantiation.
‘Now I know this next bit will leave you amazed but in all this religious wandering, no-one had told me that loving women was a sin. When the subject came up at university, the people who disapproved were not the Christians but the scientific rationalists, mostly those whose opinions I didn’t respect anyway.’
blessed by the church? Hannah began to visit a large Benedictine monastery for women, and spent five years growing closer and closer to the women there. (In that time she still never really grasped where the Church stood!) Hannah was not sexually attracted to the nuns, although she did fall for the senior novice, ironically the one who had to talk to her about virginity.
‘It reminded me of one long Girl Crusaders Camp – the rest of my life with no worries about food, fashion or philosophy, and the head-lifting sacrament every day. One of my brother’s girlfriends called it a lesbian collective without the sex.
‘So I went through the training process and applied for membership and had deeper and deeper spiritual comfort from it all, and became really close friends with some of the sisters. Part of the entry included psychological testing with the Priest Psychiatrist attached to the Diocese of Birmingham. I was shocked to find they used the same character assessment questionnaire as the Scientologists. I answered all the questions honestly (“Have you ever wished you were a man?” – yes. “Have you ever wished you had a penis?” – yes. “Have you ever fantasised about sex with a woman?” – yes)
‘Of course now I realise the result was inevitable. There was a Label for people like me and it was an unnatural act condemned by the Church.
‘I spent several weeks in shock. I found the level of homophobia in my own family. I wasn’t formally turned down for membership: it was just made very clear that the community were deeply divided over me. This was very upsetting, partly as I loved them all as a group. They were funny, wise and kind women and I was sorry that I had become a problem for them.
‘I now think I would have been accepted by the community if I could have assured them of my celibacy. The presence there of Sister A showed me the truth about myself early enough to avoid such a disaster. The ironic thing was that I don’t think I ever really wanted to go to bed with her.’
Hannah currently attends a Quaker Meeting, which accepts her bisexuality.
Paul
Church and Community
‘People try to make sense out of a painful universe. The philosophical arguments aren’t much good – what underpins a real faith is your own experience.
‘There is a sort of similarity between a church and the bisexual community: a single local church has lots in common with your local bi group – people brought together with all their faults and disagreements and virtues and special talents: often not really agreeing about why they stay together. Churches can be more a community – a group which cares – than the bi one is. But of course both can also practice exclusion and hierarchy and fail to do what they’re supposed to.
‘I couldn’t understand the need to belong to a group, to adopt a discipline of attendance, I thought I could do it all on my own. It is another one of those things I was shown, not told. Your spiritual journey needs supporters, a tradition even if only to kick against, people to share with and get angry with and learn from.’
Resources
Metropolitan Community Church – a mostly gay and lesbian denomination founded in America. BM MCC, London WC1N 3XX.
Lesbian and Gay Christian Movement – Oxford House, Derbyshire St, London E2 6HG. Book-list, local groups, sane Christian counselling on sexuality, etc.
There are a great many books on what the Bible really says about homosexuality, varying in approach, readability, common sense, etc. The LGCM book list is full of them. I don’t want to rehash all this salted with my own opinions and prejudices. I’d recommend John Shelby Spong’s Living in sin – a Bishop rethinks human sexuality (Harper Collins) as the best I’ve read. Spong is excellent on deflating fundamentalists, and doesn’t try to excuse the nasty bits away.
I hope other people will contribute stories from other religious traditions, or indeed broaden the picture. I have only dealt with Christian(ish) faith because the subject was already too big and diverse!
Steve C
