Dear BCN,
How shall I love thee? When and how shall I show my appreciation? When and how shall I criticise? How will I temper one with the other?
Why have I not taken the plunge and thought about offering my time and efforts to work towards a conference this year? Do you know it’s just because I can’t bear the tedious criticisms and lack of appreciation. When Norwich had an excellent conference with un-repeated crash facilities, the criticism was that there should have been more showers. When Nottingham gave an un-repeated range of entertainment the criticism was that the music at the disco was not right and the band were awful.
What about the cost? The Nottingham group went from twenty people at group meetings, to three. Who’s seen the Birmingham people and just what were the London people ‘on’ to look so good all the way through.
I understood the deliberations the group who withdrew their offer for this year went through before they withdrew their offer. So I was upset to see this process undermined in BCN by the comments that all that was needed was for someone to ‘pull their finger out’, and it only took their ‘guts and time’ to create a conference. What made this worse was that it was under the headline ‘SOS from BAG’. These were not BAG’s words. I saw, on behalf of BAG, what was submitted – as I am part of BAG. And what was submitted was not what was printed.
So do I not appreciate BCN and/or the editor. How about ‘I know someone who says that she won’t write for BCN because you edit material. I do hope that the community is grown up enough to accept that contributions must sometimes be edited’. Well I’m one of three people who has said at one time, ‘I won’t submit any more due to the editing of pieces’. Maybe I’m not grown up enough. Maybe I just thought I didn’t need my jokes edited out.
Does this sort of comment show appreciation for contributors? Have I ever shown in the past my appreciation of BCN? Well at least now we know that BCN should be brighter bolder and better, as it said on the last front cover, so no need for me to think the old BCN was any good – I’ll just wait and keep my appreciation for the new, bigger, brighter, more critical BCN.
Judy & Rick
Si M comments:
I’m the one who put in the comments about Bicon ’97. These comments were not intended to be offensive to the Plymouth Group for withdrawing their offer (and apologies if they did cause offence). I think it took ‘guts’ for them to realise that the time was not right for them to host the conference. It also takes ‘guts’ to put one on. And you, Judy, should know that as well as I do.
As to the words not being from BAG: BAG sent us a press release on the situation and we wrote a news piece on it. We weren’t intending to imply that the words on the page were directly from BAG and I don’t think we did imply that.
– — — — –
Dear BCN,
I’m writing on behalf of myself and the London Women’s Bi Group, in response to the from ‘Anon’ (BCN Issue 14). For those of you who don’t remember the letter, ‘Anon’ attends the London mixed bi group on a Friday and was questioning why more women from the Thursday Bi Women group do not attend her Friday group.
The thing that upset me about the letter was the obvious animosity it expressed, to quote: ‘from the sneers of the bi women who wouldn’t march with us at Pride…’ I was at Pride and I don’t remember anyone sneering! I do remember that another group ended up marching between us and the mixed group, but this was not any deliberate intention on our part, it certainly wasn’t a snub. Pride feels a long time ago to me and I had no idea that this was being held against us as a grudge!
‘Anon’s basic premise seems to be that we should attend the mixed group out of a feeling of moral duty to make it better for women who want to attend a mixed group (e.g. because they have husbands/boyfriends there). Personally, I disagree with this premise. When I first came out on the scene most of the mixed clubs were 90% male so I went to women’s clubs. Most women I’ve spoken to don’t feel it was my duty to go along to the mainly male clubs where I felt uncomfortable (and had very little chance of getting off with a woman which was my main reason for going at the time!) in the hope that it might make it easier for other women – why should groups be any different? When a club came along that managed to attract both sexes (Popstarz) I went along.
I believe the basic function of a group is a social one. It is something you choose to do with your free time so people should come along because they enjoy it. And if people come along because they enjoy it, it can grow and will provide other functions by default (e.g. a stepping stone for newcomers, a place to educate people through discussion etc.) The Women’s Bi Group is successful. People come along to it to have fun, meet new people, make friends, maybe get off with someone. People don’t come along out of a sense of moral duty. It is the friendliest, happiest group with the least in-fighting that I have ever come across.
We’ve turned our group from the rather serious small gathering it used to be to a growing vibrant group which gives people what they want. What we have in our group is something special and worth preserving.
To sum up: the Bi Women’s group bears the rest of the bi community no animosity. We just love our own group and don’t want to give up another evening a week to attend a group just because they’re trying to make us feel guilty.
In response to ‘Anon’: we don’t have the answers regarding what you should do about your group. Maybe there are ways you could attract more women, or maybe the situation is OK as it is with the vast majority of bi women catered for by the Thursday group? If you feel like you’re carrying too much of a burden on your own then perhaps you should give up, go down the pub with your friends on Friday and come along to Bi Women on Thursday instead?
Hugs and kisses,
Mary and the rest of Bi Women
– — — — –
Dear ‘Anon’,
Nobody has any ‘moral duty’ to do anything that doesn’t feel quite right to them, if people don’t want to go to the London Bi Group they don’t have to!
If the women feel too intimidated by the lecherous men in your mixed group, or the fact that the group meetings are situated in a red-light district, then don’t blame us or our group. That’s your group’s problem, and if you want to attract more women to your Friday meetings you may well have to make some alterations to the way your group is run and where it is situated.
How dare you tell women to ‘grow up’ as a response to complaints about the men’s advances? When women go to a group for the first time they want to be in a safe and comfortable atmosphere. If this isn’t provided by your group maybe it’s the men you should tell to grow up.
Lastly, if you are going to voice such strong opinions at least have the guts to sign your name at the bottom of the letter.
Gemma Edwin
(A proud member of the London Women’s Bi Group)
– — — — –
Dear BCN,
I am writing to let you know how much I enjoyed Issue 14! I particularly liked Charlotte Cooper’s articles. (I actually face three prejudices: being fat, bisexual and Jewish.) Now I feel better about my body! I’m not overweight any more; I’m fat now.
Congratulations, BCN!
Anthony
– — — — –
Dear BCN,
Last Friday at Friend a writer for BCN asked me what I thought of St. Valentine’s Day and if I thought that bi people could be, or were, as ‘romantic’ as others.
At first I thought this was a joke. I know that we all know the modern meaning of Valentine’s Day is a creature of advertising and the media. It provides revenue for the makers of greeting cards and the personal pages of the press. It gives imbeciles on the radio and early morning TV something to natter about. It provides another trashy bauble to divert our minds from the shit and lies that surround us. Another fake focus of ‘community’ in a world that is shattered by fractures of class, ethnicity, culture, aspiration, knowledge and life-chances.
From some points of view it is a good thing to attempt to paper over these cracks; this is the function of mass sport, the obsession with ‘personalities’, the Royal Family industry, and so on. But why should BCN go along with this nonsense? Is the reason for this that the sensibility which informs BCN doesn’t know what it wants or what it is? It’s as if this sensibility wants to act out the caricature of bisexuals as persons who don’t know what they want and can’t make up their minds.
On the one hand BCN presents bisexuality as being in some undefined sense subversive, alternative, different. Yet on the other hand it pleads for acceptance: yes, really we’re just like you. Well, this is one thing that bis can’t have both ways.
The incident on Friday triggered something I’ve increasingly been feeling about BCN. The way that it drivels on and on about whether some character in a soap is or isn’t bi. Who shagging well cares? They’re not real, they’re FICTIONS. Ah, but I hear ‘role models’. Bollocks! If people choose to model their behaviour on the gobshite that the media spray out then that’s their lookout. All that this obsession of BCN does is replicate the servile mentality that is cultivated by the likes of the Sun and the ‘personality’ pages of what were once called the ‘qualities’.
As someone once said: it’s not what they say that matters, it’s what we do. If what we do is merely to ape straight culture then it’s pathetic and does nothing to cultivate a spirit which will be able to resist future attacks on us. Is there anyone out there who feels as I do about this?
David Murray
Si M comments:
BCN exists as a forum for the entire community. And I, for one, am very glad that you’ve added your thoughts to that forum. But are those thoughts any more relevant than those that believe in ‘romance’, ‘role models’ or even aping straight culture?
We publish (largely) all the articles we receive, so if people write about soap TV characters then that’s what we print. Partly because that’s all we have to print and partly because some people are interested in the media representations bisexuals get.
Elsewhere in this issue Jo Eadie (‘Join the Bisexual party line’) attacks others in the community for a stifling understanding of bisexuality as being just one thing. If bisexuality is really bisexualities, then I see no problem with putting a ‘serious’ political article next to a ‘lightweight’ piece about soap stars next to a set of vox pops about Valentine’s Day – a day with particular meaning (good or bad) for bisexuals and queers in general. Thoughts?
– — — — –
Dear BCN,
I’ve just finished reading your ‘starter pack’ and found it interesting. It was intriguing to see how you broke down the definition of ‘bi’. It was also interesting to see a caption from TransXPress: ‘When is a dyke not a dyke?’ And in a nutshell that is me, but in a slightly different context. Being a pre-op TS who is mainly into women but hasn’t ruled out a relationship with a man in the future, after the op, if and when I get over my own hang-up about men.
The question is, would you count me as a bi woman? Or does the fact I’m transgendered change the definition again? And if so, when do we stop using labels to describe ourselves when our own definition is all that should be required? Any other views or information would be most appreciated.
Cherrie Button
