Have you heard of the bisexual party line? No, it’s not a great new 0898 service – it’s the assumption that there’s only one way of seeing bisexuality, and all other views are just plain wrong.

Speaking on Kilroy, transgendered photographer Del (formerly Della) Grace explained why s/he didn’t use the word ‘bisexual’: because, as Suzanne pointed out in January’s letters page, ‘bisexual’ means attracted to both men and women (hence the ‘bi’ prefix), but Grace has partners who may identify as neither or both of those things, making the word inapplicable. A very straightforward account of why ‘bisexual’ is not the perfect word for everyone

Not so. Suzanne was told in the letters page ‘you may not have felt this was an anti-bi comment, but other bisexuals at the Kilroy show did’. Excuse me? ‘Other bisexuals’? Well, I imagine that other bisexuals feel it’s anti-bi to bring our community into disrepute by joining in at SM Pride, and yet more other bisexuals think it’s anti-bi to call yourself ‘queer’ instead of bi. I’m sorry ‘other bisexuals’, but in my book personal offence is just not going to do as a substitute for listening to what people are trying to say. There is no one right way of being bisexual, or one right attitude to the word, and it sounded to me as if Suzanne was being told that her point was invalid, just because ‘other bisexuals’ had some real (if not very well thought out) hurt feelings.

This might just have been an annoying one-off: but in the same issue Charlotte Cooper reviewed Sue Wilkinson’s essay ‘Bisexuality as Backlash’ which is also, apparently, anti-bi. Maybe Charlotte didn’t have time to read the essay carefully, but Wilkinson’s point is absolutely not that bisexuality is wrong, bad, or undesirable: rather it is that the media – gay and straight – is currently using bisexuality in ways that maintain and promote sexist and homophobic assumptions.

But apparently, because this doesn’t amount to the sort of happy-clappy, bisexuals-can-do-no-wrong approach, this is ‘the worst piece of bi-hating shite I’ve ever read’. In fact Wilkinson analyses, with some care, the ways in which lesbians are told that bisexuality means they should all go out and fuck men (which makes straight boys feel very happy: there are no women who are not legitimate targets, and lesbians need it more because they are so uptight) and that they should also conform to a look which straight boys will find more appealing: thin, long-haired, shaved legs, and in dresses. Do we not want to criticise, as bisexuals, the way that bisexuality is being used? Shouldn’t we be learning from this account of the ways that bisexuality is used to ridicule and marginalise other queers?

Wilkinson also looks at how straight women are told that they can now have occasional sex with women without reflecting on their identity (i.e. without challenging heterosexual power structures, without thinking about sexual politics) and that sex with women carries no HIV risk. The media depictions of bisexuality, says Wilkinson ensure that straight women ‘remain certain that they are “heterosexual really”, returning securely to the arms of their men after a little lesbian “fun”.’ Right again. Is this biphobia on Wilkinson’s part? I don’t think so. It may be an indictment of the way that the straight press reports our lives, and of the ignorant sound-bites that a lot of bisexuals are happy to offer journalists from Cosmo and Elle – but that’s hardly a reason to shoot the messenger.

I’m not happy with everything that Wilkinson says, and in the context of the book as a whole I can see why it should provoke a strong reaction, but I don’t think that all her points can be rejected simply because they aren’t an enthusiastic endorsement of all things bisexual. Bisexuality doesn’t only come in one form (great all the time; politically perfect; radical and pleasurable; what everyone who isn’t gay or straight should call themselves), but in a range of forms: oppressive images in the press, a confirmation of homophobic thinking, a way that people in power can enjoy themselves.

Bisexuality is not a useful label for everyone, and bisexuality can be used to confirm rigid notions of gender (‘I am attracted to both men and women, therefore everyone in the world is either a man or a woman’). When it gets used in these ways, I think there should be room to critique it (which, I should add, isn’t the same as wanting to silence those views). The role of a bisexual politics should be to open up the number of ways that bisexuality is being talked about, not to decry everything that disturbs our misguided dream of bisexuality’s inherent wonderfulness.

Jo Eadie