Ian Watters and Kevin Lano from BASH respond

Ian Watters provides some background.

– — — — –

Although the Peer Education Project (PEP) was almost completely independent from Bisexuals’ Action on Sexual Health (BASH), the project’s money from Red Hot AIDS was given to BASH, henceforth named as ‘BASH-main’. At the start of the PEP in July 1995 it had not set up its own bank accounts and it took until October or November to do so. Even then the sum was not shifted straight over to the PEP, for a variety of reasons which now seem somewhat silly. So various sums were moved bit by bit from BASH-main to or on behalf of the PEP. This unnecessarily complicates the BASH-main accounts and was a mistake.

Another complication is that at one point Kevin was facing a trial and possible imprisonment over his past involvement with a green anarchist group and lent BASH-main about a thousand quid. He did this in part to reduce his visible assets but also to enable BASH-main to continue – his financial mini-reports to BASH-main (about two lines in the minutes) were showing it had almost zero money. This money was later repaid, as charges against him were dropped.

– — — — –

1. What’s going to happen to the remaining money – £1,722.63?

Kevin Lano There is £736 left in the BASH accounts – we paid another £738 to PEP to pay for the printing of the report, and paid other outstanding expenses since the accounts presented.

Ian Watters These accounts were, as far as I remember, the only ones that Kevin, treasurer throughout BASH’s history, ever did. It came as a great surprise to me and the others present how much was, in fact, remaining in the BASH-main account. At previous meetings, he had given a very short ‘state of the account’ comment that, at the end, was under £100 (again, as far as I can recall).

The remaining money was agreed to be held in trust for bi sexual health projects. One suggestion was to use some of it to facilitate holding a weekend mini-conference for people interested in the subject.

– — — — –

2. What £7,702.05 cash withdrawals were for?

Ian Watters To my memory, for payments relating to the PEP that had to be in someone else’s bank account ‘now’. Examples include the payments to Body Positive North East (BPNE), where the PEP worker was based.

BPNE took some time to sign the contract between themselves and the PEP and, until that was done, the PEP did not pay BPNE’s invoices. These included the money BPNE was paying the PEP worker as salary (BPNE handled her salary and National Insurance details). When BPNE did sign, several months late, the PEP owed several thousand and BPNE wanted it ‘now’. The quickest and cheapest way of transferring the money was to take PEP money out of the BASH-main account, and pay it into the London branch of BPNE’s bank. (See background for some of the details behind the mixing of the two accounts.)

Kevin Lano Transfers of money to PEP were a rather murky area – it’s clear that too much money was paid but the details were handled by the PEP treasurer, not me.

– — — — –

3. What did ‘???(Ian)’ mean? There were £1,739.05 of them.

Ian Watters As I understand it, it is Kevin’s shorthand for ‘Ian, do you know more about this?’ All my records relating to the BASH account have been given to him.

– — — — –

4. Why were Hugh’s expenses so large (the largest BASH withdrawals) at £2,007.27? And why did his expenses drop from around £100 a journey to £60 later on in the accounts?

Ian Watters Some history is needed here. BASH evolved out of the Health Education Authority (HEA)’s Bisexual Development Group, which it set up following Bicon ’91 in London. The HEA being a quango with more money than sense paid both attendance fees (£35, I am told) and travelling expenses to people it invited.

I was not there at the time, but I believe that Hugh negotiated with the HEA that, as he lived at the far end of Cornwall, his expenses in travelling to meetings were higher than the second class rail fare everyone else was claiming. It has recently been pointed out to me that he may in fact have been claiming a (presumably generous) mileage allowance, as he did drive to meetings.

I joined right at the end of the Bisexual Development Group, at a point when the HEA stopped even pretending to listen to its advisory groups, but was willing to give some money for people to travel to meetings of a successor group. The decision was taken to form what was soon named Bisexuals’ Action on Sexual Health.

The agreement was that we’d fund second class rail fare for people out of London. A ‘mileage allowance’ option for drivers was never discussed, and I believe it would not have passed if it had been, certainly not at HEA rates.

Not long afterwards, it came to my attention that Hugh’s claim was for £100, which seemed to me to be larger than the relevant second class rail fare. I asked the then chair privately what was happening here, and was told that this was what had been agreed (presumably during the Development Group days).

I was left with the belief that everyone else then a member knew and had agreed, so following that conversation, I did not raise it at a BASH meeting.

This was a mistake and I regret not doing so. One of the reasons was that Hugh was doing something – the job of secretary – that no-one else wanted or was willing to do and I did not wish to piss him off sufficiently to stop doing it. (Similarly Kevin was the only one willing to do the treasurer job which is one of the reasons that the situation with the non-production of proper accounts was allowed to continue. This was a mistake and I regret that it happened.) Over the next couple of years, both the money and personnel of BASH changed. The money kept on going down, and the people kept changing. It took several heated discussions to get people to agree to a cut in the percentage of the travelling expenses was needed. Hugh’s claim would then have dropped, along with that of the other out-of-London attendee.

When, at the end, I did finally raise the issue of Hugh’s expenses, which was then the biggest item of expenditure, he was not present as far as I remember. A letter was written to him asking him to explain the claims, and his only reaction to my memory was to send a letter of resignation.

– — — — –

5. Why was £1,900 transferred to the bi helpline? Was it to help them? If so, on what mandate was it done?

Ian Watters I assume this is the money for the period at the start of 1994, when the HEA funded the helpline to run six days a week, Friday to Wednesday, for several weeks (Edinburgh on Thursdays is outside the England and Wales remit of the HEA) to tie in with a run of their ghastly ‘hands’ ad (close up photo of two middle aged male hands together, one with a wedding ring, both wearing suits, tag-line something like: if a married man has an affair, it may not be with a woman) which mentioned the helpline.

For some reason I forget – I think the helpline didn’t at that time have a bank account – the HEA wanted to pay the money through BASH, so that’s what happened.

Ian Watters and Kevin Lano
(compiled from separate responses)