RePresenting Bisexualities: Subjects and Cultures of Fluid Desire
Edited by Donald E. Hall and Maria Pramaggiore (New York University Press, 1996)
After last year’s disappointments in bisexual theory, Vice Versa and Bisexuality: the Psychology and Politics of an Invisible Minority, this book could make ideal summer reading for you or the bi intellectual in your life.
After a badly misjudged introduction (lots of dashes and clever puns, and indented paragraphs: bisexuality is just so… so… transgressive, isn’t it?) this collection of twelve essays on bisexuality is state-of-the-art stuff.
There are some fine illustrations of the complexity – and the real history – of bisexual representations in writing, and a thorough investigation of the reasons why bisexuality finds itself avoided, denied and rewritten in queer politics.
Mariam Fraser offers what remains in my mind the definitive account of Simone de Beauvoir’s sexuality; Chris Cagle looks at the much-neglected issue of straight-identified bisexual men (declared completely unwelcome by some sections of the activist community); Donald Hall gives bisexual pornography the serious academic attention it deserves; and Marcy Jane Knopf is spot-on in looking at how bisexuality can be used to prop up existing forms of oppression (the middle-class white bisexual who eyes up her socially disempowered prey).
Bisexuality is treated as a legitimate and complicated subject, whose different forms (the `bisexualities’ of the title) are seen as distinct, historically specific, and not to be lumped into some imaginary `bisexual essence’ awaiting release from us all.
Where the collection falls down is its exclusive commitment to textual studies, semiotics, and discourse analysis: that is, these essays look at how bisexuality is talked about, and not at other aspects of how it is lived. They find that bisexuality gets talked about as difficult, challenging, hard to pin down and threatening. From this, they conclude that bisexuality really is about to bring society crashing down around our ears. Although there are some token justifications of this narrow focus (along the lines of: language affects how we think, and how we think effects how we behave) the question of how this apparent fluidity might translate into life-choices, political struggles, or types of community – that is, into behaviour – is missing.
So, excellent examples of discourse analysis though they are, most of the contributors fail to consider how these instabilities might be accommodated by material power structures. The general claim is that because it refuses to fit dominant thinking about sexuality, bisexuality undermines dominant social forms. That’s true up to a point: but such an argument fails to consider how ideological or discursive instabilities get ordered, controlled, and organised by such power structures as businesses or religions, families or trade unions.
Telling queer-bashers that you don’t fit their notions of a hetero/homo structure doesn’t make them stop; telling lesbians and gay men in UNISON that you challenge the logic of their identity doesn’t make them less likely to leave you politically disenfranchised – indeed, arguably it makes this more likely.
A system under threat doesn’t simply give in – it may well intensify its practices. After all, the UK’s own Section 28 was driven by the claim that teachers were turning pupils gay. The idea that heterosexuality and homosexuality are not so far apart, and the barriers between them are being eroded – which the contributors to this collection imagine is a challenge to heterosexual power structures – can actually be used as a repressive political ploy to justify state homophobia. If they had looked at the altogether more complicated relationship between the challenge of bisexuality as an idea and the way it gets worked into existing structures in practice, this would be an altogether less bright and breezy collection, and would have more bite because of it.
Jo Eadie
