Bi George! Guardian, 9 April 1998
Inevitably, someone had to describe George Michael as ‘bisexual’ following his recent appearance before a crowd of one in a now notorious toilet. Clare Lonrigg in her background piece on the singer points out that his sexuality was ‘always ambivalent’; ‘he never denied he was bisexual’. Otherwise the descriptions ‘gay’ or ‘homosexual’ seem to have been used throughout the media. Most amusingly with a number of tabloids (in an attempt to remain ‘tasteful’ next to the photo of the topless woman) referred to George being observed indulging in a homosexual act on his own; my, someone went back for seconds when the sex organs were being handed out.
Watching you, watching me
Terry Sanderson’s Mediawatch
Gay Times , May 1998
For years Terry Sanderson has been responsible for bringing us pithy and often shocking analysis of what the media have been saying about queers. He must have been responsible for stirring many apathetic gays, lesbians and bi’s into action against the worst excesses of the media bigots. In the process he has become somewhat of an icon; indeed our own BiWatch feature pays a certain homage to his work.
I therefore found his most recent column extremely troubling. Half of the two page feature in the latest Gay Times was devoted to a searing attack on those who would dilute the purity of ‘gay’. Terry reviewed the same articles on ‘flexi-sex’ that I reviewed in this feature in BCN27 – in particular David Northmore’s piece in The Pink Paper. As you may have guessed, we reached very different conclusions.
Mr Sanderson’s angle is in criticising the authors for touting the idea that, ‘at heart, we’re all bisexual’. Had this been written, I would have been right behind him; unfortunately it is a gross misrepresentation of the articles in question. Mr Northmore wrote how it was no longer necessary to cling to the rocks of an absolute gay identity, and how in reality a significant proportion of people were recognising their more fluid sexuality. At no stage did he say, or imply, that this should be compulsory; at no stage did he claim that gays or straights do not exist.
Had the criticism come from almost anyone else, I could have believed the error was due to ignorance or being out of step with the progress of the overall debate; it is hard to believe this of Terry. He has clearly set out with an agenda to protect the highground of the ‘perfect Kinsey 6’ against the marauders. The easy way to do this? – wheel out the old ‘everyone’s bisexual really’ allegation. Unfortunately when someone in such a respected position plays this kind of game, he tends to be believed. Only those who read the original articles will recognise the distortion applied.
The feature then went on to examine Tom Robinson’s piece in the Independent about his own sexual orientation. No direct criticism this time, just a rather unworthy ‘sneaking suspicion’ about the views of women. Following on the heels of the previous broadside, the conclusion we are supposed to draw was pretty clear.
I was left feeling very let down by a man who has done as much as anyone for political awareness in the gay community. Terry Sanderson seems to be more interested in seeking enemies than allies.
Steve Pointer
Coming out or not?
Channel Four’s much-heralded Coming Out weekend, based around the episode of the sitcom Ellen where Ellen DeGeneres’s character announces that she is a lesbian, was surprisingly entertaining, and with a few mentions of the B word thrown in should have given those at this traumatic stage of their lives a good deal of encouragement.
Mind you, if like us they’re still waiting for a copy of the advice booklet A beginner’s guide to coming out, they’ve probably changed their minds by now!
Dana International wins it for Israel!
On 9 May the Eurovision Song Contest, held in Birmingham, was won by Dana International from Israel. The country hasn’t won the competition since 1979, but the main public interest was in the fact that Dana International is an out transsexual. Wearing a dress by Jean Paul Gaultier, singing a song called Diva, Dana won the contest only on the final vote, but was seen by many as by far the most glamourous entrant. With the new voting system, where viewers in most of the member countries could phone in their votes, the fact that Eurovision has a massive gay following can’t have hurt her chances.
Dana, 26, has now recorded three albums, all of which have gained massive sales in Israel and abroad. Two years ago she came second in Israel’s pre-Eurovision contest, and she consoled herself with the thought that it would ‘probably have caused a major scandal to have Israel represented in Eurovision by a transsexual’. Now that she does represent them, this has proved to be the case.
The orthodox religious leaders in Israel have condemned her. Shas, the religious radical party which led the anti-Dana campaign, said that the only reason sex changes weren’t proscribed by the ancient rabbinical sages was because they never conceived of such ‘an abomination’. Rabbi Shlomo Benizri said: ‘God is against this phenomenon. It’s a sickness you must cure and not give legitimacy.’
Secular Israelis have seen it as a public victory for freedom against the right-wing religious community. After the competition, Dana said: ‘People have judged my song and my performance and not my sexuality, and I am glad for that. I want to send a message to the Jewish community and say to them ‘try to accept me, my kind of life and the choice I have made.’
Dana has now been invited to perform at the opening of the Gay Games, held this summer in Amsterdam.
