An Index On Censorship report in March shared news from a Greater Manchester school for 11-18s which has banned a whole heap of books as inappropriate – including the hit Alice Oseman Heartstopper graphic novels.
A school head picked up that the book Men Who Hate Women which explores the growth of incel and misogynist online was in the school library. They demanded to know what else was on the shelves. This led to dozens of books being pulled from the library – things like mixed-race gay teen novel Black Flamingo, the Heartstopper comic books, and perhaps inevitably given the context, George Orwell’s 1984.
Books were to be removed if they were not written for children, had themes that might upset children, or that could be construed as a safeguarding risk. That meant World War II biographies, as they weren’t written with a youth audience in mind, or Twilight on account of there being violence involving vampires and werewolves. Michelle Obama’s autobiography was denounced as racist, educational books about being a queer teenager expunged; even a Terry Pratchett novel got pulled.
With the government in retreat in the face of ‘culture war’ populism, there are no national lists of what books are or are not acceptable in schools – and due to devolution they would be different lists in Scotland, Wales, England and Northern Ireland.
It is not as clear-cut as in even the days of Section 28, when fewer books aimed at a teen audience dared reflect the range of adolescent experience. Individual schools make their own decisions based on the strength of prejudiced parental complaints versus the willingness of school heads to stand up for the safety and education of the pupils in their care.
Comment from the School Librarians Association and previous IOC reports suggest many librarians are self-censoring for fear of reprisals.
In the Greater Manchester case, the school librarian was labeled a safeguarding risk, threatened with police involvement, and quit for her own health.
