The summer saw a backlash against bisexuality from parts of wider LGBT+ society.

Three queer women in the public eye — JoJo Siwa, Betty Who and the mononymous singer Fletcher — all began dating men. In straight culture, three famous women doing the same thing barely registers as a TikTok trend. In queer culture, with far fewer visible sapphic figures, it was easy to frame this as a “moment”.

Previously identifying publicly as lesbian, JoJo Siwa appeared on Celebrity Big Brother, where while tackling homophobia in the house she plainly fell for a male contestant. Shortly after leaving the house she ended her relationship with her non-binary partner to be with him. Watching your girlfriend fall out of love with you and into it with someone else live on reality TV must be an especially peculiar pain.

Betty Who, who had long identified as bi, stumbled into controversy when she explained that revealing her new straight-reading relationship was about “holding space” for lesbians who unexpectedly fall for men. “It shouldn’t be illegal for you to fall in love,” she said. Some commenters seized on this as if a literal claim rather than a rhetorical shorthand for the social codes of queer spaces. There is nowhere in the world where falling in love with someone of the ‘opposite’ sex is illegal. It is as hard to believe she was unaware of that as it is to believe the social media commenters feigning outrage as if that was what she meant. Yet they help silence bi experience.

Fletcher, another musical icon for young sapphic women, came out via an entire album. Would You Still Love Me If You Really Knew Me? launched alongside the song Boy, about falling for someone you didn’t expect. Notably, she also seemed to shift from calling herself bi to calling herself queer. Is this a reflection of how bisexuality still functions as a “weak” or expendable label within the ever-growing acronym?

None of this is new. As a previous generation’s bi icons put it: ever fallen in love with someone you weren’t supposed to fall in love with? Social media has simply made the backlash biphobia louder and more public. And there’s the underlying question: is it fair to expect queer people in the public eye to maintain an identity that is always “legible” as queer through only dating those of the same sex or the ‘right kind’ of non binary beau?

It is a thorny issue. Same-sex relationships are rarer and more readily erased. Homophobes will still look at someone they once understood as gay who is now in a mixed-gender relationship and use it to argue that other queer people should simply try harder to ‘find the right one’ of a socially approved gender. Even though on things that aren’t gender and sexuality difference seems more acceptable – no one tells people with big feet they should wear small shoes as ‘smaller people are fine with them, why aren’t you?”

But if bisexuals are respected as whole queer people in their own right, rather than imagined as a crude splicing together of straight and gay in a B-movie scientist’s laboratory, then every relationship a bi person has is queer. Each one carries the potential to disrupt assumed roles, expectations and narratives, regardless of the genders involved. (The same indeed goes for relationships built entirely of heterosexuals, but bis perhaps more often have the motivation to question the ‘natural order’ of relationships that society handed down.) Liberation from the shackles of compulsory heterosexuality was supposed to let us be more honest, not tie us to a different set of restrictions.

The backlash – on social media and in corners of the queer press – is partly about defending gay visibility and legitimacy. But it is also about pressuring people to misrepresent themselves, to date in ways that reassure an audience, and to perform an “acceptable” queerness. In that sense, it mirrors the very logic long used by straight society to police lesbians and gay men. Yet more prejudice repackaged as ‘reasonable concern’.