Trump’s second term shock and awe

Ahead of the 1990s Iraq war the term “shock and awe” was coined for launching a massive assault in as many ways as possible. The opening hours of that invasion saw many targets hit hard and simultaneously – so if as a defender you radio’ed for help from your colleagues, they were too busy radio’ing you for the same thing. Thus your enemy would become overwhelmed and lose the will to fight, deluged in bad news from every direction.

Donald Trump’s team thought about this ahead of their election victory last year and were ready with their own shock and awe campaign from the moment he was sworn in as President. The comparative lack of protests on the streets in the first weeks compared to 2017 reflect its success along with that of efforts to curtail protests by students which have centred on Gaza but can now be seen to have wider application.

Trans and wider LGBT rights are among many areas targeted for the opening salvo of assaults of institutions and freedom, along with areas like healthcare that disproportionately impact bi/LGBT people. Sometimes it’s petty: removing references to the trans people who were involved in the Stonewall riot from its memorial webpage will fool no-one as to the story. Sometimes it’s just plain stupid: censoring research on ecological diversity because it’s got the word diversity in, or the defence department deciding to delete a photo of the plane that dropped the first atomic bomb because it’s called the ‘Enola Gay’ and that might give kids ideas.

The impact is felt here too – UK Stonewall had been receiving about £200,000 a year in funding from US sources via the Global Equality Fund.

Some of it may not be legal: there are a host of court challenges in process, with some measures stayed by judges while the legality or otherwise of Presidential edicts is considered. But while this will slow some things and perhaps stop some, with the White House, Supreme Court, House and Senate all under the grip of the Donald most of it seems bound to happen. At least for the two years from here to the mid-terms.

Now the bulk of the impact is on daily lives of thousands of Americans who are fired today, living in fear tomorrow, or likely to suffer from reduced healthcare and opportunity to get on in life or to travel. But it also likely affects the research we report on each issue in BCN. In recent years national US government-run surveys have asked about sexual orientation and gender identity, and creative ways of examining the large data sets the US government has produced on things like youth health has given insights into how things are different for bi people in the USA.

Those data sets suddenly vanished from view in January, with notes explaining that they were now deemed ideologically unsound. It’s hard to see how Elon Musk’s plans to maximise the value of every taxpayer dollar can be reconciled with throwing away data that those dollars were spent collecting, but the new puritanism is what is really at stake.

A month on, some data has reappeared – purged of elements relating to diversity. Some of that has been saved by keen academics and geeks who logged in quickly enough – it’s not clear how much.

But the sharp switch in policies and staffing seems to mean that in the next four years that diversity data is no longer collected. That will mean that we will not be able to see how the government’s policy of a return to the ‘good old days’ impacts bisexual people and other social minorities.

Which in part is ideal for those pressing such policies: how can you complain about the impact of changes when the means of finding out the impact are deliberately taken away?

A limited amount will come from things like the annual Gallup survey data on sexual orientation, but these will not provide data on a like-for-like basis of the old research and so comparisons will be less solid. But our sympathy with everyone trying to keep doing that research across the USA, and working out how to keep afloat until this passes.