This month we’re feeling suspicious of the lgBt news we read. Take the headlines in the Telegraph about how Scottish civil servants are more likely to be promoted if they are LGB. It says so in the Scottish government’s annual Civil Service People Survey for 2023. Which also finds they are over-represented in the workforce.
Could it be true? Is there a cushy number for every bisexual in the civil service, or do we somehow make extra-good civil servants? We had to look into the report.
And yes: “Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual or any other sexual orientation not including straight/heterosexual staff make up 10.0% of the Scottish Government workforce, compared to 5.2% of the Scottish population aged 16 to 64.” Though we know from other research that the rates of sexuality identity vary with who asks the question, where and how – so there is always a bit of variation from one survey to the next. Perhaps civil servants in 2023 just felt more trusting of the questioner than people filling in the 2021 census did.
And sure enough “LGB+ staff are more likely to have been promoted in the last year than heterosexual staff,” the report finds.
But here come the kickers. The proportion of LGB+ people recruited is in line with the proportion applying – so no favouritism in recruitment leading to the over representation. But the LGB+ skew of the employee base is “especially true among staff working at lower pay bands”… who are more likely to be promoted because there’s more places to be promoted to.
No secret LGB cabal. Just a lot of low-paid youngish people building their careers.
The Telegraph didn’t pick up on the section noting “bisexual staff felt less included and experienced higher levels of discrimination and bullying & harassment than heterosexual staff” (and indeed lesbian and gay workers). Funny they didn’t mention that.
In “it’s not really research news” news, the Daily Mail ran a frothingly excited piece in the “everyone’s bisexual really” vein. A scare headline observed that if we extrapolate from research into our nearest relatives like the bonobo, bisexuality is the most common pattern of sexual behaviour, and so for some definitions of the label, you’d expect most people to be bi.
“I predict that most people should actually be bisexual,” Dr Jason Hodson of Anglia Ruskin told the DM. “The genes that influence same sex sexual behaviour are probably just genes that influence general sociality, and people in the middle of the range of variation are probably better at all social relationships.”
To debunk this idea the DM contrasted this with the most recent ONS statistics – 1.8% of people identifying as bi which is double the proportion as recently as 2018.
In a wording that won’t surprise many the reporter manages to quote the debunked “Gay, Straight Or Lying” 2005 report in a bid to reassure readers that men probably aren’t bisexual, while saying it’s debunked.
That 1.8% figure tied in with another research report though – researcher Willi Zhang writing for The Conversation about how his research in Stockholm had showed a doubling in the city’s bisexual population since 2010 (from 1.6% to 3.1%).
On its own, that makes you wonder what Stockholm’s secret is. But the wider picture, as the DM’s attempt to debunk Hodson’s work shows, is that this significant uptick seems to have happened everywhere LGBT rights have advanced. Stockholm is just one of the places it has become more safe for people to own who they are.