DC adds to the debate on Stephanie Theobold’s “To Bi Or Not To Bi” (Guardian, 30 March 2000) on The Bill actress Joy Brooks’ renunciation of her bisexuality. See also BCN issues 34, 37 and 44.
Theobald is ostensibly out to criticise straight women who ‘play out’ with other women, but in doing so like Stella Duffy inthe same paper last year (see BCN 37) she ends up kicking bisexuals and bisexuality along the way. Having damned straight women as ‘fly-by-night lesbians’, she deftly erases male bisexuality with ‘why should gay men even bother saying they are bisexual when they have had the money to turn gay into a brand name as established and cool as Gucci,Absolut and Sony?’. (Er, because bi men are attracted to women as well as men,Stephanie.)
Where Theobald might have an interesting point is her suggestion that straight women are now going through a similar period of discontent with heterosexuality/men to the 1970s. Even if this were true, it’s scarcely the fault of bisexuals. Theobald’s insistence that such women are ‘fake lesbians’ invented by menfor pleasure and profit suggests that,again like Stella Duffy, Theobald can only see a choice between ‘real’ lesbianism and ‘safe’ heterosexuality.
Her real objection seems not so muchto be Brook’s renunciation of bisexuality (a matter of disappointment to bi’s),or even to Brook’s sexual experimentation (she might actually know what she wants now though I find the ‘committed Christian’ bit rather scary), but that she’s not a gold-star, Kinsey 6 lesbian.
What’s going on here really? Three years ago, the Guardian ran a sympa thetic article on polyamory and stil occasionally writes supportively of bi’s.
But this is the third article in recent times which sideswipes bi’s and bisexuality while supposedly attacking straight women (who never seem to get around to answering back). Why? The paper is also engaged in an ongoing debate about monogamy and the ethics of relationships. In the context of the row about repealing Section 28, one can understand the significance of Joy Brook’s recantation. But being caught in the ‘friendly fire’ of someone else’s sex war is getting really tedious.
