Right to Reply
Dear BCN,
Re: the allegation in last BCN regarding my case. The background to the case was that Iwas movingto Australia with the woman concerned last July,having already lived with her for 20 months (we were emigrating as de-facto partners: although there had not been a sexual relationship, we had been intimate friends). Because I wanted to withdraw from this move, she retaliated by accusing me of indecent assault, however there was no allegation of violence or genital contact, and none had in fact occurred, nor had I asked for sex from her. I had simply asked for a hug.
However it appeared that my bisexual activism was likely to be an issue in any trial and to be used against meto argue that Iwas sexually perverse or abnormal,and Iwas advised to accept a plea bargain,which Idid very reluctantly just before the trial. At sentencing the judge concluded on the basis of the prosecution statements alone that “”It’s right at the bottom end of indecent assaulf’ and that ‘here was consenf’. Iwas given a small fine. It should be remembered that the legal system often bears little relation to common morality,with cases of consenting sex such as the Bolton 7 being punished by prison sentences whilst a recent case of rape charges against a policeman who forced his girlfriend to have unsafe sex against her will was dismissed. Sexual offences also carry an additional stigma and penalty perhaps because of the anti-sex ideology of mainstream culture: a man will often get similar sentences for exhibitionism and mugging,for example. The same applies to political offences – I have faced a potential 10 year sentence for allegations of animal rights activity, even though this concerned reporting and encouraging such activity, not carrying it out.
Even the language used legally is archaic and misleading: ‘assault’ does not imply physical force (that is ‘battery’), and ‘indecency’ is defined as ‘what right minded people would consider indecent’! Swearing at someone using obscenities can therefore be an indecent assault.
I’d like to thank the many people in and outside the bicommunity who supported me and were willing to back me in court (and to those who supported me over the previous allegations of animal rights activities).
I also want to reassure everyone in the community that the idea of coercing someone into sex is repellent and disgusting to me; like most people, I want a consenting and genuine relationship. I can understand what it is like to be forced into sex, and the psychological damage this can cause as this has happened to me, in 1990 I was coerced into giving oral sex by a man, and in 1984 a man sexually accosted me on a ferry. Such events ar perhaps not a rarity in the gay world, but the psychological effect has been quite damaging and led me to leave the gay scene.
Kevin
Right to Reply 2
Dear BCN,
It is a while since Ihave written to BCN, but I feel compelled to respond to Sandra Dickson’s letter printed in Issue 43, which offered a critic of the London Bisexual Women’s Group, BiCon and the Bi community in general.
The main points, as Iunderstand them, were that she found the Bi-Women group (in 1996) to be closeted, insular, superficial, limited in its activities and insufficiently political with an over emphasis on sex. Moreover, she felt she and her friend were not made welcome because of their accents (New Zealand and Chilean respectively). These comments were then extended to include Bicon.
Firstly, I am sorry Sandra’s experience of the Bi-Women group at the time was so negative. I was already attending the group myself then and that was not my experience at all. For the sake of any woman reading this who has
never been to the Bi-Women group (and may now be thinking they never want to!) I want to defend the group against each accusation.
1. Closeted. Yes -we do make the point that all mailings are sent in plain envelopes because some of our members may live with people they are not out to. Whenever we discuss “coming out” there are always some people who are totally out and some who feel they couldn’t come out to anyone. We try to show the positive aspects of coming out without putting pressure on anyone who feels they can’t.
2.Insular/limited. We organise a number of events in addition to the group meeting such as a Christmas party,picnics, pride. Some members of Bi-Women get involved with other groups such as SM Bi’s, the London Bi Group and attend BiCon.We always promote events such as the Lesbian & Gay Film Festival. We have sent representatives to speak at other groups and had other groups come to us.
3.Superficial (sex not politics) When we plan, we ask each small group to think of workshops under a number of categories including “political” ‘touchy/ feely” ‘fun & games’ ‘sex’. We have covered a wide range of political and intelligent topics, in the current programme alone we are again discussing “”monogamy/non-monogamy” (the topic Sandra specified she would like to see) as well as ‘the gay gene’ and “Bi and Gay politics/ campaigning” (for full programme see back page of BCN). In the past we have discussed feminism and had speakers from Feminists Against Censorship and Stonewall. We try to achieve a balance and include something for everyone, but I agree the main function of our group is social not political.
4. Xenophobia. Irefute this utterly. The group has always had significant numbers of people from other countries, many with strong accents,who have become regulars actively involved with the group,including running workshops . The facilitators make everyone welcome and introduce new people to each other and to the regulars, but usually friendships are forged between people once the group ends during the social inthe bar!
Inconclusion,no group can hope to please all of the people all of the time,but as the only Biwomen group in London our aim is to be as inclusive as possible and to cater for many different tastes and interests. Because we run as a collective, rather than by elected committee, and one group a quarter is a planning meeting,the onus is on the membership to come up with the topics we discuss, suggest activities and move the group in new directions. Our group is very popular, with an typical attendance of over 30 women a week, but we always need new, dynamic women with energy to put into the group to allow it to continue to thrive.
May I suggest to Sandra she comes back and gives us another go and then comes to the planning meeting to make any positive suggestions she has. We even meet opposite First Out which serves very good hot chocolate and cake!
Yours sincerely,
Mary Tinsley
The ‘Robinson Shift’
Dear BCN,
A few days ago, Ifound my self humming “Glad To Be Gay”. And being in a rather strange mood, Istart to think about the lyrics; in particular the couplet “For 21 years now, I’ve fought for the right For man and for women to love who they like”. Ideally, I know, a couplet should rhyme. But this was not what caught my attention. After all, by the standards of “Glad To Be Gay”, “right” and “like” do rhyme. What set me thinking was the implications if Tom Robinson should succeed.
If we love who we like, do we like those we can’t be bothered with? And do we nod politely to those we really can’t stand? This “Robinson shift” would undoubted solve many of the problems of prejudice. But I can’t help thinking it would make the world a duller place.
Richard L
(Co-founder and acting vice-president of the Society For Starting Sentences With Conjunctions)
Yet more trouble with the Bi Scene
Dear BCN
You get out what you put in. The bi community, scene, or bunch-of-people hanging-out-together (a disparate group of people, very few of whom draw a salary for bi-related activity) are not there to give you what you want, but to do their own thing. If your thing is different, try organising something yourself. If you think any group is too sex-obsessed and needs more direct action / theoretical discussion / therapy sessions or whatever,offer to organise things yourself. I can’t speak for the London Bi Women’s group, for obvious reasons, but I imagine most groups would be desperately happy if you turned up and said “I want to organise stuff -how can I help?”
Complaining rather than trying to improve matters is lazy, and complaining to the organisers of BiCon 2000 (who are probably getting very little sleep at the moment,and who don’t get paid) that they’re not offering what you want, and are therefore doing it all wrong, is just rude.
Some people simply are more interested in sex, pulling and “shallow” fun than discussion and campaigning- I know I am. This is not because I’m too thick to express myself but because I already know how I want to live – polyamory isn’t something I discuss, it’s something I do – and because my chosen method of campaigning is to live as an out bisexual polyamorous SMer, in the office and on the tube, and quietly get mainstream people used to us like that. This is just a personal choice, but I wouldn’t complain about other people behaving differently and insist that they do what I want them to do. This is supposed to be about freedom,after all.”
People also mentioned the problem of feeling intimidated by being with a large group of people who already know one another. This can be a problem, but it is not insurmountable- how do you think all those people who know each other got to know each other? I came to London 18 months ago and knew no-one, but I now have a large number of friends and a few lovers, most of whom I’ve met in bi places. Still not occupied any film festivals though.
I feel that anyone who feels that the bi community has failed them, and that they should look elsewhere , can either give up, or stay and sort it out. Giving up just means that when the next community fails to meet your standards, you will have to move on again and again. Staying and sorting it out may be more effort in the short term, but will be well worth it when you have the community, scene, or bunch-of mates-in-a-pub you deserve.”
Simon MacMullen
