Whatever happened to the gay gene? Recently I attended a conference where a geneticist took us through Dean Harmer’s work, both the scientific evidence and the ethical issues raised.
Some uncritically accept the research – usually those who feel that if you can prove a genetic explanation, homosexuality is shown to be ‘natural’ and so opposition to it melts away. (Prejudice against Jews, blacks and the disabled shows this argument is rubbish.) Others have rejected Harmer’s work – they don’t want to believe it on political grounds. But scientists can’t argue that a theory is wrong because we wouldn’t like the consequences if it is proved.
The ethical issues raised are severe, with many homophobes now talking about pre-natal screening and abortion. And enthusiasts for Harmer have argued that male bisexuality doesn’t exist – a specific additional concern for our community.
Jackie Leach Scully showed many of the problems and ambiguities of the scientific arguments – never mind any of the others. Harmer’s research is based on a small sample of forty pairs of gay brothers – all were out, confident, and readers of the right sort of magazines. Notoriously, some genetic surveys are based on such small numbers that a single misdiagnosis can scupper the statistical relevance of the results.
Attempts to define exactly what it is you are studying can be very problematic in such a complex and multi-faceted area as sexuality. I have often wondered why anyone would assume homosexuality is something with a single cause. Is my bisexuality the same as yours?
Harmer’s attempts to survey homosexual relatives were based on such assumptions as a female PE teacher must be a dyke and someone who still lived with his mother ‘was probably gay’. The questionnaire used by Harmer is riddled with stereotypes and misconceptions – I was astonished by quotes from it – and explains why bisexuals were ‘explained out’ of his survey. There are clearly no grounds for arguing against male bisexuality from his research at all.
The outcomes were not desperately statistically strong. Other studies of twins do show that genetically identical individuals (fraternal twins) are indeed more likely to both be gay than brothers who are not genetically identical. More likely, but not invariably. This again shows perhaps a genetic component rather than complete determination by genes. And some genetic pre-disposition to be gay(er) does still not explain away why some people are and some aren’t. Why aren’t all people with the alleged gay gene gay?
Two crucial findings are that Harmer’s latest research is less conclusive than his first experiments, and no other study has repeated his results. That suggests that announcing ‘a gay gene’ was premature. Science stands on repeatable results.
The popular response exaggerates. Genetic influence does not equal complete determinism. It has been known for centuries that there is a hereditary component to height: tall people have tall children. But under the influence of improved medicine and diet, average height has also increased over the last forty years.
Genetic determinism is politically popular because it absolves us of responsibility. If depression is due to maltreatment, unemployment, and the like, we can do something about it – things that might be inconvenient or expensive for us like social change. However, if depression is genetic in origin, then we can walk by on the other side.
Harmer came across as both politically naive and a chancer – a man who chose a controversial area of study to get funding, and who might just be starting to realise the ethical nightmare he could be creating. What really sticks in the craw is that in a world full of genuine problems, why should the study of homosexuality’s origins be a priority? Why not study things which are a genuine problem?
If evidence for some genetic component to homosexuality strengthens, the community will find itself allied with all sorts of other people in preventing authoritarian uses of the information. We rapidly thought of several nasty consequences of a ‘test’ for possible homosexuals. As individuals perhaps we should take this moral issue seriously even if the ‘gay gene’ ends up in the trash-can of failed theories. We also need to ask ourselves why aborting a Downs syndrome foetus is acceptable and aborting a possible bisexual foetus isn’t.
Steve C
