Bisexuality and Celibacy – BiCon Workshop Report
If you’re thinking ‘celibacy? what does that have to do with bisexuality?’, then you’re probably not the only one. When we decided to run a workshop at BiCon ’96 on the subject of bisexuality and celibacy, the general reactions ranged from derisive laughter to gentle incomprehension.
BiCon is a space where bisexuals in all sorts of relationships can enjoy those relationships freely and openly, and that’s extremely important for obvious reasons. However, there’s not much space or sympathy given over to those in the community who (for whatever reason) are currently choosing not to be sexual with other people.
Previous BiCons had this space, so we decided to set it up this year for the benefit of celibate people who wanted it, and for anyone who thought that a discussion of the issues surrounding celibacy might illuminate other topics relating to bisexuality in general.
Different Celibacies
We spent quite a long time debating the various different definitions of celibacy – whether it refers to no genital contact, no sexual contact, or something else – and reminding ourselves that celibacy doesn’t mean a negative attitude to sex or that one doesn’t relate to people in a number of other ways.
People can be celibate between relationships, after periods of intense casual sex, within relationships when the partner is sick or absent, or for reasons best defined loosely as ‘spiritual’, such as a desire to conserve and redirect sexual energy into other forms of creativity, or for religious reasons.
Bisexual Boundaries
The issue of ‘boundaries’ was an important one, perhaps particularly for bisexuals, as it transpired that some people have different sexual limits for men and women: for example, permitting genital contact with women but not with men, or a married bi man living with his wife who also has anonymous sex with other men.
During the workshop we developed a grid which proved to be useful in understanding the issues raised later in the workshop. In the grid (illustrated on this page) sexual activity is placed along one axis, and relationship activity along the other.
One could be, for example, in the bottom left part of the grid, having relationships with other people but not having sex with them. People can position themselves all over this ‘map’ of sexual behaviour, and also be in different places for different people – or different sexes.
It’s perhaps this idea of ‘degrees of celibacy’ which ties in so closely with bi identity, and many other issues of particular relevance to bisexuals.
Some participants in the workshop talked of the difficulties of establishing comfortable sexual limits with other people, and the usefulness of deciding upon a greater or lesser degree of celibacy. Identities can change, and the decision to be celibate whether selectively or not need not be a permanent one, but can be a useful ‘breathing space’ when needed.
Similarly, celibacy can help people maintain polyamorous relationships, through being celibate to a greater or lesser extent and knowing that their partners’ sexual needs can be met by others.
‘Emotional Celibacy’
It was pointed out by a workshop participant that some people who enjoy lots of casual or anonymous sex without emotional involvement could be said to be ’emotionally celibate’: similarly, some people describe themselves as celibate whilst enjoying a lot of physical contact with various partners.
Clearly celibacy is not as simple a choice as it at first appears. It’s sometimes seen by non-celibates – or, indeed, by some celibate people themselves – as a ‘cop out’, a way of avoiding the nasty delicate issues surrounding finding and keeping a sexual partner. This is one of the many valid reasons why some people choose to be celibate – particularly after an important relationship has ended.
Celibacy Subverts
Celibacy is not, as is often assumed, an attempt to put a brave face on the fact that nobody wants to sleep with you: it’s not an indication that one is asexual or incapable of relating to other people. It’s a valid choice whether for life or for a week, and it’s a potentially subversive one at that.
In different ways from polyamory or bisexuality itself, it challenges the social norm that everyone needs to be partnered with a member of the opposite sex and sexually active to be a valuable member of society.
Unfortunately some members of the bi community don’t understand the reasons why some others choose to be celibate, and so celibate bis can find themselves within another closet – or tiresomely pursued by those who feel they ‘just need a good seeing to’. Unattainability is, after all, a potent aphrodisiac!
Sexual freedom, and the chance to be sexual with male and female partners out of every closet, is definitely a goal for the bisexual community to work towards. However, at the end of the workshop, all were agreed that the community also needs to take into account people who are not having sex. It would be unfortunate if we were to inadvertently oppress some members of our own community in the journey towards liberation.
Dianne Millen & Nick Smith
Celibacy Workshop Facilitators
