Steve Pointer presents a personal opinion on a possible Bisexual agenda.
Whilst I’ve been well aware that there were several different views amongst bisexuals as to campaigning strategies, I felt confident that we all agreed roughly what needed to change. That was until I was challenged in an interview to demonstrate this belief. Where had it been written in recent times? How did I know others agreed with my view? How did the agenda fit in with recent events? Did others even want an agenda for change?
Discussion with a number of bisexuals both within and outside the established community have made me question my assumption further. I was surprised to find doubt as to the content of our agenda. And frankly I was amazed that many had not considered that we should be trying to influence the world at large. In a subjective analysis these views were more prevalent amongst, though not entirely confined to, behavioural bisexuals who are not part of the existing ‘community’.
To make any progress a common agenda is essential, and it must surely aim to influence society. It may be comforting to concentrate on the continued existence of our community (the local groups, Bicon, BCN, etc) in its current state. We have created an environment to which we can retreat which is both familiar and safe. However, over the last few years, the bisexual community has existed in a state of dynamic equilibrium; whilst people come into the community, they are balanced by those leaving. In terms of activity the community is essentially stagnant.
In some respects this is a comfortable position – a community where it is safe to be bi, where many faces are familiar, and where it is easy to become a big fish in a small pond. However, we should surely strive for more. Leaving aside altruism, in purely selfish terms, we still have to spend most of our time out there in ‘the real world’. Unless we influence that world’s perceptions and understanding we will have no more than a safe, but essentially two-dimensional, haven.
To me, the approximate content of our agenda appears obvious. Whilst improvements have been made there still exists a strong bi-polar opposition in the minds of many people – both straight-identified and lesbian/gay-identified. Straights, in particular, still tend to identify anyone who has any same-gender experience as ‘gay’. There are also still many lesbians and gays who perceive anyone who has any opposite gender experience as essentially belonging to the ‘straight’ camp. We are therefore left with a situation where people are expected to come down on one side or the other of the perceived fence.
I believe we should aim to influence society in two essential, but interrelated, areas.
Firstly we need to introduce the concepts of fluidity, variance and experimentation into the public understanding of sexuality. As an end-objective we should aim not to establish a bi identity to rival lesbians, gays and straights, but to change the playing field altogether. We need to change beliefs so that experimentation is seen as positive; ‘I tried it but it wasn’t my thing’ is the kind of statement that people should be able to make freely. Probably the most important effect would be on the whole concept of coming-out. If the stigma of experimentation is removed, the feeling of taking a giant leap into the unknown, never to return, would be greatly reduced. This is obviously important to bis but its value should also be recognised by gays and lesbians – if coming out is made less challenging, more people would do so.
Secondly, we must strive to educate the public that same-gender relationships are equally acceptable, worthwhile and valuable as opposite-gender relationships. If we concentrate only on convincing people that fluidity of sexual identity exists, we will not necessarily convince them that it is right.
Both of these objectives are shared to a greater or lesser extent by other activists, most notably those seeking lesbian and gay equality. In her essay ‘Toward a gender agenda’1 American Bi activist Jill Neagle argues that the fights against sexism, genderism, homophobia and biphobia are inter-related, and there would be synergy in activists combining to fight as one. Neagle suggests convincingly that if genderism, the belief that all people divide neatly into two completely divergent groups, was removed the other three forms of discrimination would disappear.
However, I feel we should stick to one question at a time. It is important that we define our agenda first before considering who we should look towards as potential allies. Bisexual activists can then decide for themselves who they want to work with.
Once we agree and, just as importantly, publicise an agenda for change, we can start to be effective in taking action. At present I think we’re in danger of giving out many different messages, or of not communicating at all.
Steve Pointer
