Alfred C Kinsey: a public/private life
by James H. Jones (pub W.W. Norton, 937pp, £28.00) ISBN 0 393 04086 0
Fifty years ago this January Dr Kinsey and his staff published a report which was described as a ‘social atom bomb’. Sexuality in the Human Male, their first publication, blew the lid on American sexual practices. Six years later, Sexuality in the Human Female, whilst partially suppressed was, if anything, even more telling. At a time when McCarthyism was accelerating, Kinsey revealed that over half of the people sampled had indulged in sex which was either considered immoral, or was actually illegal.
James H. Jones has revealed that, far from being the disinterested scientist that he claimed, Kinsey quite deliberately set out to change views and legislation. Jones has also managed to confirm rumours that his subject acted bisexually, indulged in SM sex and took part in group sex on film.
Jones has taken 27 years to research the book and, through diligent reading of correspondence and interviews, has produced a stunningly complete work. With a few notable exceptions the entire book is meticulously referenced and manages to assemble clear evidence on a number of issues which had previously existed only in rumour. Unfortunately he has formed a personal opinion of Kinsey, and has at times let this cloud his judgement. Jones lets his research down by allowing a slightly conservative moral tone creep into an otherwise excellent piece of work. He is an odd mixture of a man who has studied his subject for half his life, but appears to have never heard what he had to say.
One of Kinsey’s main tenets was that sexuality is an issue of variation. He refuted the wisdom that people are either one thing or another – ‘normal’ or ‘abnormal’ in pejorative terms, or perhaps most notably ‘homosexual’ and ‘heterosexual’. Yet Jones is happy to label Kinsey a homosexual. He ignores the long and by all accounts fulfiling sex life he had with his wife, as well as sex he had with other women. Instead he concentrates on the fact that Kinsey had emotional as well as physical relationships with two of his male researchers. Further, in such a complete work it is surprising that Jones did not try to apply one of Kinsey’s most remembered innovations – the ‘Kinsey Scale’ – to the scientist himself. Had he done so he would inevitably have had to concede that Kinsey was bisexual, probably rating around a ‘4’ – slightly more attracted to men than to women.
Other doubts about Jones’ bias build throughout the book. But it is only on the penultimate page that he shows his true colours when he describes sadomasochism as ‘antisocial and problematic’. He clearly has a problem with this side of his subject’s character.
There were undoubtedly unpleasant facets to Kinsey, which Jones reveals with great skill: he was domineering, at times grandiose, and a workaholic who could not relax socially. However, without such personality traits it is difficult to imagine anyone completing the body of work he did, and certainly not in such adverse times. He was investigated by US customs, the Reece committee on tax-exempt foundations, and the FBI’s head, J. Edgar Hoover (ironically now revealed as a cross-dressing homosexual). Jones blames sexual repression for Kinsey’s obsessive nature, but other childhood factors appear just as relevant.
Kinsey also became in private an apologist for paedophilia. He discovered that, once abused, children often invited further sexual attention from adults and concluded that children therefore enjoyed the activity and should not be deprived of it. This is illustrative of much of Kinsey’s work: he was exceptionally good at gathering data, but at times poor at interpreting its meaning.
Jones sheds important light on the greatest criticism of his work that Kinsey was to face: the charge that his sample was not representative of the population. Kinsey was in his previous career an entomological taxonomist, specialising in the identification of variation in gall wasps, and variation was his overriding interest. A collector by nature, he wanted to assemble a spectrum of sexual experience and was willing to go some way to find the more colourful examples, thus influencing some aspects of the reports.
However, at no time did Kinsey claim in print that his samples were quantitatively representative of any group, but those interviewed; in the female volume he made the point explicitly. The aim that the reports achieved was to change perspective; if Kinsey could interview around 2,000 men who had sex with other men, homosexuality simply had to be on a different scale to that perceived by the general public. It is also interesting to observe that, at least for the female volume, no statistician of the day was able to offer significant improvements that were in any way realistic – the random sampling suggested was just not viable.
Whilst flawed in interpretation, A public/private life is an extremely well researched work. Over more than 770 pages of text and 130 of references, Jones presents his findings in detail such that critical readers can draw their own conclusions. Where suspect statements are made it is easy to check the evidence. When Jones claims that Clara Kinsey was pressured into other sexual contacts by her husband, it is telling to note that these are the only two unreferenced pages in the book, whilst contrary assertions are well supported. During such a long read Jones’ writing style can become frustrating. It is somewhat unrefined and notably lacking in vocabulary; a heavy and critical edit could have removed much of the repetition and contradiction.
Jones’ expertise then is in his research, not his interpretation or presentation. A public/private life is an important biography for a committed reader, but at £28, worth a trip to the library or a wait for the paperback edition.
Steve Pointer
Kinsey’s scale of homosexual/heterosexual attraction
0 exclusively heterosexual
1 predominantly heterosexual, only incidentally homosexual
2 predominantly heterosexual but more than incidentally homosexual
3 equally heterosexual and homosexual
4 predominantly homosexual but more than incidentally heterosexual
5 predominantly homosexual, only incidentally heterosexual
6 exclusively homosexual
Key findings from the Kinsey reports
finding males females
have masturbated 90% 62%
have had pre-marital intercourse 85% 50%
have had extramarital intercourse 30-45% 26%
have had at least one homosexual encounter 37% 13%
