The European Court of Human Rights delivered a landmark judgement today in the case of Fedotova and Others v. Russia. The case concerned the Russian authorities’ refusal to ensure legal recognition and protection for the applicants as same-sex couples.
The case involved the interpretation and application of the European Convention on Human Rights, which many countries outside the EU have signed including Russia and the UK.
The ruling will have implications for thousands of bi, gay and lesbian people across Europe, albeit largely in states which comply with international law. It is unlikely to have much impact on Russia for example.
The Court stated that “none of the public-interest grounds put forward by the Government prevails over the applicants’ interest in having their respective relationships adequately recognised and protected by law” and concluded “that [Russia] has overstepped its margin of appreciation and has failed to comply with its positive obligation to secure the applicants’ right to respect for their private and family life.”
In so doing, the Court respectively demonstrated that, under Article 8 of the Convention, all Council of Europe member States, including all the 27 EU Member States, have an obligation to put in place “a specific legal framework” for the recognition of same-sex couples, in the absence of same-sex marriage. This was stated clearly by the Court in the judgement and had been stated in the previous cases of Oliari and Orlandi.
At present six EU Member States do not provide any legal framework for such recognition: Bulgaria, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Romania and Slovakia.
Pierre Karleskind MEP, Vice-President of the European Parliament’s LGBTI Intergroup, commented: “Today, justice is done across the Council of Europe area.
“This Court judgement crystalises what the LGBTIQ community has revindicated for years: that their relationships deserve as much right to legal recognition (and protection) as any other couple.
“With this in mind, we will keep advocating for the remaining EU Member States to make steadfast progress at national level to respect and implement the Court’s interpretation.”
