The LGBT+ groups of the SNP, Liberal Democrats, Alliance Party, SDLP and Greens have published a joint letter to the Prime Minister, calling on him to intervene in the decision taken by Secretary of State Alister Jack and allow the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill to be sent for Royal Assent.

The decision could have implications beyond the current debate on gender recognition and affect other equality and human rights issues – such as the long-anticipated outlawing of “conversion therapy”, which

The main Westminster parties missing from the collaboration are the Conservatives – whose LGBT+ group may not feel able to speak out against their government’s transphobia – and the Labour Party, whose LGBT+ group are similarly put in a difficult position given Kier Starmer’s recent pronouncements on young transgender people’s bodily autonomy. Plaid Cymru are also missing.

The letter reads as below:

Rt Hon Rishi Sunak MP
10 Downing Street
London
SW1A 2AA

17th January 2023

Dear Prime Minister,

We, the undersigned, as the LGBTQ+ affiliates of our respective political parties, urge you to intervene in the decision taken by your Secretary of State Alister Jack and allow the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill to be sent for Royal Assent.

This bill was passed democratically by two-thirds majority of the Scottish Parliament, including votes from every political party in the parliament: The SNP, Scottish Tories, Scottish Labour, Scottish Greens and Scottish Liberal Democrats. This shows that this bill, passed across party lines, has wide support in the democratically elected Scottish Parliament. It is also the most consulted-upon piece of legislation in the history of devolution.

Contrary to Mr Jack’s statement, this bill does not affect ‘GB-wide equalities matters’ – a reference to the Equality Act (2010). A Gender Recognition Certificate (GRC) does not govern access to single-sex spaces and the exemptions under the Equality Act can still apply to those with a GRC. Prisons already make decisions on trans prisoners on a case-by-case basis in Scotland and this will not change. This legislation does not change the effect of a GRC and merely simplifies the process of obtaining one.

While this was not raised in Mr Jack’s statement to the media, there has also been significant discussion of the creation of different legal rights for 16 and 17 year olds in Scotland in comparison with the rest of the UK. It is a fact that pre-dates devolution that Scots obtain many rights of adulthood at age 16 – such as to marry, to leave school without condition, and to vote in local and Scottish elections – that English young people do not. This has not previously been seen as a condition for interfering in Scotland’s democratic processes.

The effect of a GRC – which is unchanged by this legislation – is to allow a trans person to change their birth certificate to their correct gender. The effect of this legislation is to allow them to do this in a shorter time with fewer administrative burdens. Birth certificates are not used as identification in day to day life and there are already easier processes available to change a passport or driving licence. The main use of a birth certificate is to allow marriage and death certificates to be recorded in the correct gender, ensuring the human dignity of trans people’s lives being accurately recorded. Why should we not afford them that dignity?

We urge you and your government to reconsider this move, in order to both respect trans people and the democracy of Scotland.

Signed:

Cllr Micky Murray
Chair, Alliance LGBTQ+

Dylan Lewis-Creser and Cade Hatton
Co-Chairs, LGBTIQA+ Greens of England and Wales

Beth Douglas
Co-Convenor, Rainbow Greens (Scotland)

Charley Hasted
Chair, LGBT+ Lib Dems

Oisín Donnelly
Chair, SDLP LGBT+

Michael Gibbons and Erin Lux
Co-Convenors, Out for Independence

LGBT+ Associations Speak Up Too

Meanwhile outside party politics, a host of LGBT+ groups based in or whose area of work includes Scotland have signed a joint statement on the matter.

Bi Community News is among the signatories. It reads:

In December 2022, the Scottish Government passed its Gender Recognition Reform (GRR) with overwhelming cross-party support from Members of the Scottish Parliament after many years of consultation, review and discussion.

The UK Government is now considering challenging the Scottish Government’s mandate to implement this bill by ending reciprocal recognition of Gender Recognition Certificates (GRCs) from all countries that support trans people changing their legal gender using a self-determination mode – including Canada, Australia and New Zealand – after the UK has accepted them for years.

Seeking to end this system is an extraordinary move that is not based on any evidence or experience.

It sends a clear message that the UK Government does not feel trans people are worthy of respect in our society; instead, they are a threat to contain.

These moves also directly oppose the inclusive values that characterise modern Britain and will actively harm the UK’s international reputation as an open, diverse and dynamic society – an important reason why global corporations who proudly support LGBTQ+ rights are attracted to doing business in the UK.

We implore the Prime Minister to stop this unnecessary and damaging action immediately and instead recognise the significant positive contribution of trans people across the UK.