The UK’s blood donation rules have been revised again and it’s mostly good news… but not all!

For the last three years, men who have sex with men, and their female partners (it’s a very binary coded set of rules, sorry folx) have been barred from donating blood if they have had sex in the last three months.
That time limit is set to be abolished… well, for some people anyway. It’s a rule change across England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland which will come into effect in summer 2021.
The Department of Health and Social Care explains: “donors who have had one sexual partner and who have been with their sexual partner for more than 3 months, will be eligible to donate regardless of their gender, the gender of their partner, or the type of sex they have.”
In a welcome change that reflects how it is behaviour not orientation that is at the nub of risk, they add: ” under the new selection process, all donors will complete the same donor health check prior to donation, regardless of gender or sexuality, recognising that all donors, including heterosexual men and women, have potential to carry infections.”
There are rules around some sexual experiences that may be indirectly discriminatory on account of being more popular with some gender and sexual orientation groups:
“New donor criteria will also defer those who have engaged in chem sex, defined as a drug taken immediately before or during sex to enhance sexual interaction, in the last 3 months or been treated for syphilis in the last 12 months.”
But so far so good. No gender bias, tick. No inequality on the basis of sexual orientation, tick. All about behaviour, which is what has been pressed for by campaigners over many years.
However the next part of the announcement suggests a problem:
“Anyone who has had the same sexual partner in the last 3 months will be eligible to donate and men who have sex with men will no longer be asked to declare if they have had sex with another man or their sexuality, making blood donation gender neutral and more inclusive.”
Because having “the same sexual partner” is not the same thing as “the same sexual partners” or to perhaps put it more clearly: “only one partner in the past three months – and no new sexual partners”.
It suggests only one person – so for people who are in for example a stable three-way sexual relationship with two other people, they might well never get past the three month rule.
And where three people are in a relationship where one is dating both of the others but those two do not have sex with one another – then the person in the middle can’t donate blood because theirs is deemed risky, whilst both of their partners are considered safe to donate.
If this is indeed how the rule will be interpreted, while we have opened up the possibility of donating blood for a lot of bi and gay men, and their partners… we have probably removed a lot of other people from being allowed to donate.
Instead of stigmatising male bisexuality and homosexuality and having a guilt-by-association clause in there, it looks like the new policy is championing monogamy over polyamory, even where those relationships are equally consistent in partners being fluid-bonded or otherwise not exposing anyone in the relationship to a new potential STI risk.
Which would be not so much a step forward as three steps sideways and spin.

How We Got Here

Until 2011 men who have sex with men, and their female partners were banned from donating blood for life. It was a rule brought in when HIV/AIDS first hit public consciousness in the 1980s and made sense at the time when detection, treatment and transmission of HIV was so much less understood than today.
People seeking to change this argued that once we had efficient detection methods, it was sensible to move to a policy of testing blood when donated and allowing people to donate based not on who they had sex with but how they had sex.
Much campaigning through the noughties was unsuccessful but 2011 saw a change to a twelve-month ban on blood donation – a huge leap forward but one that perhaps mainly opened up blood donation for men who were bi or gay but either celibate or having a rotten time romantically.
It was followed in 2017 by a reduction to a 3 month ban – men could not donate if they had had sex with another man in the previous thirteen weeks. This change also removed a quirk of the 12 month rule that meant the female partners of bi men faced more stringent rules on donating than their the people they were having sex with did.