In case most of us haven’t been indoors enough this year, the Christmas films are here and building on last year’s Let It Snow there is a smattering of queer fayre. Some minor spoilers ahead so if you prefer your films unsullied, just pick out the titles in bold and read this later.
Netflix offers A New York Christmas Wedding and it’s a bisexual centring tale. Sliding Doors meets A Wonderful Life as a bi woman filled with doubts on the verge of her wedding to a man is taken by an angel to a parallel world where she pursued her budding relationship with a woman twenty years before. What if she hadn’t turned her back on her gay friend?
As well as the capricious angel, there is a tale interwoven about being queer and Catholic including a priest wrestling with the question of how to rightly show love to his congregation. This is unusually heartening, if perhaps a little wishful thinking. We deserve some wishful thinking in a Christmas film, doubly so in 2020.
As a film that “what if…” set up means it faces a tricky binary: after her 48 hours of living her “other life” will our heroine choose to marry a man or a woman. Either way you will be widely read as saying bis are really gay or are actually straight.
It’s not an even choice though (spoilers!) as if she picks the girl, both of the great loves of her life live and are happy with the added bonus that her father remains alive. If she picks the guy, two people will die. No pressure! Little wonder she lets her potential husband wind up in the other possible timeline with a different loving wife. We get to see both of her loves as genuine and mattering to her even within being bi and monogamous, a rare trick in visual storytelling.
Happiest Season also feels like a first: a queer-centring Christmas film from a mainstream studio with all the reach implications that has. It wears its queerness boldly but without feeling that it is doing it for ‘shock value’… and while it’s a story about two lesbians, one of them is played by bi star Kristen Stewart.
Abby (Stewart) gets taken to the family home for Christmas by her girlfriend Harper, after an argument about whether Christmas is fun or abominable. Halfway there Harper admits that she isn’t out to her folks and wants Abby to pretend to be a good but tragically orphaned friend. The car screeches to the roadside and the plot swerves with it.
If you’ve got a Hallmark Holiday Bingo card you’re in no time ticking the boxes for shenanigans, dead parents, “a family tradition” games that no one ever explains the rules to, and a couple with love/hate Christmas tensions.
There are things about this one that made me unsure: it has great bi representation in its actors with Kristen Stewart and Aubrey Plaza in central roles, and there is an interpretation of Harper’s behaviour that involves being bisexual – indeed perhaps she’s not the only one – yet never is bisexuality voiced as a possibility.
And so at a level, the story is still one of coming out, the most basic story of queers we tell. The advertising had hyped me up to expect something more. It is still beautifully made and rewatching knowing what to expect does reward with things I’d not picked up the first time around.
Dashing In December (talked about as a film of “gay cowboys” in the blurb – Jingle Brokebell Mountain?) is most definitely about gay men with nary a hint of bisexuality. Visually it suffers that problem of a Christmas film that seems to have been made in high summer with a brightness to the light that feels wrong, and our central boy-boy dynamic feels implausibly forced. Spoiler: this isn’t really a gay romance, it’s more about how middle-aged gay men pair off their lonely straight parents. How Andie MacDowell is sitting on the shelf in a small town is just one of those willing-suspension-of-disbelief things. Top marks to Caroline Harris who manages to appear in both this and Happiest Season – the belle of the queer chrimbo film ball.
The Christmas Setup is a Christmas-romance-by-numbers that just happens to be about two men. Ben Lewis and Blake Lee are cute and a couple in real life which helps with the plausible chemistry on screen. Drink as much as you feel appropriate, you’ll know how it is going to go from about three minutes in, but there’s nothing wrong with that for a cosy seasonal feelgood flick.
Fifth but not least we come to The Christmas House. This is Hallmark’s first gay-centring such movie, with two gay men who are happily coupled up all the way through and whose plotline is instead about whether they will get to adopt a child. They may only manage one kiss but hey, the story isn’t about them coming out or being hated. It’s Hallmark, so just as with Lifetime’s The Christmas Setup the action may not be raunchy but compared to where we have been before, this is a queer win.
All told I think this raft of films is in part a reflection of the times and public mood but also a reflection of the success of same-sex marriage. Five or ten years ago British and American audiences might have struggled with equivalents to these films more, but now it’s plausible to have a story of two men or two women who love each other either getting married or already being married and that just being an everyday part of life. Being unmarried is no longer a sign of that terrible euphemism the “confirmed bachelor” and a wedding ring still leaves every possibility open.
