In the 1990s a dubious piece of research made headlines that the genetic ’cause’ of homosexuality had been found. Now someone else thinks they’ve found it too.
In 1993, Dean Hamer’s research suggested it was tied to the Xq28 gene, and that a variation of this was passed to male children from their mother and if you got it, you’d grow up to be a gay man.
This led to two reactions: in the hate-mills of the tabloid press headlines promised finding the “gay gene” would allow prospective parents to have their child tested in the womb and aborted to avoid the shame of a gay child. At the comedic rather than grisly end of things, to teeshirts reading “Xq28 – thanks mum, love the genes” that were popular at Prides for a summer.
It only applied to homosexuality in men – one of the things that raised suspicions about the validity of the claim at the time. For bi activists it also reflected a weird sexuality binarism that just doesn’t exist in the natural world. However while a couple of other studies mildly concurred with Hamer’s findings other research contradicted it, so “Xq28 makes you gay” died the death of the unsubstantiated theory. By 2019 bigger research projects showed a host of genetic factors with Xq28 not especially influential.
Now a study in The Journal of Sexual Medicine from Andrea S. Camperio Ciani of the University of Padova proposes to answer what he terms the “Darwinian paradox of homosexuality”.
As so often, somehow women are to blame.
Andrea’s theory is that the same combination of genes raises female fecundity as raises the chance of same-sex attraction – sorry, homosexuality – in male offspring.
There’s a fascinating statistical finding that “mothers and maternal aunts of homosexual men (i) had fewer gynecological disorders; (ii) had fewer complicated pregnancies; (iii) had less interest in having children; (iv) placed less emphasis on romantic love within couples; (v) placed less importance on their social life; (vi) showed reduced family stability; (vii) were more extraverted; and (viii) had divorced or separated from their spouses more frequently.”
If only we could put the chicken before the egg, deliberately having a gay kid would clearly make the whole pregnancy experience a lot less stressful. Apart from the divorce papers.
The sample size in his data set is tiny though so the usual “more research is required” applies. If that bears it out we have a possibility that homosexuality in men doesn’t die out as a simplistic understanding would suggest because the gay kids would happen in larger families whose DNA quirks would thus survive generation to generation. That feels like it hangs together as a hypothesis, but let’s not start believing in it just yet.
I’m left wondering if this study starts in a universe where people and animals are heterosexual unless something ‘goes wrong’ and asking whether only male orientation matters. In practice with so many species now exhibiting a range of orientation bi, gay and straight alike, it’s time we stopped imagining heterosexuality to be a default from which individual creatures vary for some reason. As Derek Jarman said many years ago: heterosexuality isn’t normal, it’s just common.
