The Council of Europe’s Committee on Anti-Discrimination, Diversity, and Inclusion (CDADI) has brought forward 12 recommendations to member states to counter biphobic, homophobic and transphobic hate crimes.

In recent years, test cases brought to the European Court of Human Rights that have broadened the scope of protections against discrimination.

They propose the 46 national governments who are members of the Council should:

  1. Ensure that legislation and policies provide a standard and accepted definition of hate crime, explicitly listing and defining the terms “sexual orientation”, “gender identity”, “gender expression”, and “sex characteristics” among hate crime grounds, at par with other relevant protected characteristics, such as “race”, religion, gender or disability, and ensure that the intersectional dimension of hate crime victimisation is taken into account in such legislation and policies.
  2. When framing hate crime legislation, ensure that the criminal law provisions opted for are sufficiently precise and operational for the criminal justice system to prosecute and sentence hate crimes based on sexual orientation, gender identity and/or expression and sex characteristics (SOGIESC) and that they send a strong signal to society that hate crimes based on SOGIESC are punishable.
  3. Ensure that there is an inclusive and operational multi-stakeholder institutional set-up for
    co-ordinating the fight against hate crime based on SOGIESC and developing or reviewing related national strategies. Ensure that LGBTI civil society can genuinely participate and contribute to it and support the role and work of the police, the prosecution services, Equality Bodies and National Human Rights Institutions in preventing and combating such crimes.
  4. Ensure that data pertaining to hate crimes is disaggregated based on gender and SOGIESC grounds, and made publicly available. A comprehensive, consistent, and integrated approach to data collection on hate crimes based on SOGIESC should be in place across the criminal justice system. This approach should allow relevant stakeholders to track the follow-up given to all anti-LGBTI hate crimes and incidents, including judicial follow-up.
  5. Allocate attention and resources, including financial support, towards research on hate crimes based on SOGIESC, including victimisation surveys, in a way that allows the gap between reported and actual numbers of cases to be measured and to track developments over time.
  6. Take the necessary measures to ensure that support services for victims of hate crime are sensitive to the specific needs of LGBTI victims. Ensure that specialised and targeted support services are made available to them, and that those services are provided with adequate means to carry out their tasks and are accessible nationwide.
  7. Support civil society organisations that work with LGBTI victims of hate crime by ensuring that they receive sufficient financial support to carry out their tasks, which range from awareness-raising, monitoring and data collection to offering targeted support to victims.
  8. Take the necessary measures to encourage reporting of hate crimes based on SOGIESC by offering alternative pathways to reporting, such as online or anonymous reporting, and by taking measures to build trust in the police and prosecution, notably through educational and monitoring measures. Cases of LGBTI-phobic behaviour by state officials or institutions should be of particular concern and subject to effective independent investigation and sanctions.
  9. Take policy measures to address the specific needs of LGBTI detainees, in particular through the adoption of guidance including on carrying out proper risk assessments and paying due attention to the person’s self-determined gender identity.
  10. Monitor and evaluate the effectiveness of policies and measures aimed at combating hate crimes based on SOGIESC, and regularly review and update them as necessary. This should involve ongoing consultation with LGBTI civil society organisations and other relevant stakeholders.
  11. In order to facilitate the implementation of the preceding recommendations, develop policies that raise awareness amongst the police and the staff of the criminal justice and penitentiary sector as well as victim support services, about the specific concerns of LGBTI people, including those who face intersectional and multiple discrimination, with a focus on unmasking the SOGIESC element of hate crimes. These policies should be underpinned by continuous training programmes.
  12. Conduct research into and take targeted policy measures to address the root causes of hate crimes based on SOGIESC, such as prejudice, stigmatisation and discrimination, and raise awareness among the general public about the impact of such crimes and the importance of preventing and combating them. These preventive measures can include promoting diversity and inclusion in all areas of society, including education, employment, and healthcare, and conducting public education campaigns, social media, and community outreach programmes.

The UK is one of the 46 member states, though some reports suggest that the next General Election may see at least one major party proposing that the UK leave.