Research from Ireland suggests bi and gay young people are more likely to volunteer than their straight and asexual peers.
It highlights the gaps in experience of discrimination between straight, gay, bi and asexual young people; not just on the grounds of sexual orientation, but where it might be perceived as being on grounds of age, gender or other protected characteristics.
The survey by academics at Galway University in Ireland has been summarised in a paper, “Connected, Respected, And Contributing To Their World: The Case Of Sexual Minority And Non-Minority Young People In Ireland”. It takes existing data from the Health Behaviour in School-aged Children study and the Central Statistics Office Quartery National Household Survey.
Of 3,354 young people in the resulting data set, 6.3% (200) said they were attracted to people of more than one gender, while a further 3% (94) said they were only attracted to people of the same gender. Slightly fewer (74; 2.6%) declared they did not experience attractions to either.
Discrimination
They were asked to rate how often they experience discrimination from 1 (never) to 5 (very often).
Straight respondents scored their rate of experience of discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation at 1.1; asexuals at 1.2; bis and gays at around 2.1.
On discrimination on grounds of age the bis stand out: rating 2.5 compared to gays 2.1 with straight and ace respondents scoring 1.9.
And over gender, for bis the score was 2.4 while for gays it was 2.1. Straight and ace respondents rated 1.9 on that question.
Straight respondents scored their rate of experience of discrimination on grounds of religion at 1.2; asexuals bis and gays clustered at around 1.4.
There was almost no difference in rating of discrimination on grounds of race, traveller status nor place of birth though in all cases gay and bi respondents scored themselves slightly higher than straight and asexual respondents.
Volunteering
On volunteering the figures suggest 10% of ace, 11.1% of straight, 13.9% of bi and 21% of gay young people get involved in volunteering roles. However the sample sizes here, while statistically significant, are very small – just 8 people volunteer to make up that 10% asexual figure for example.
Friends
In looking at how comfortable people say they are around friends, there seemed to be a clustering of gay and straight, and a clustering of bi and ace teens. 68.5% of straight and 65% of gay teens feel comfortable, but that drops ten points to 56.3% of bi and 55.7% of ace young people.
Bis were least likely to report feeling supported by their families, and by a large gap the least likely to feel valued and respected at just 20.5% of respondents where the other three groups all scored over 30%.
Read more from the paper: pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33513967/
Boys Are Out
More than half of “Generation Z” bi and gay teen boys in America report being out to parents, in a welcome shift from previous generations.
This is according to research published by the American Psychological Association in the Psychology of Sexual Orientation and Gender Diversity. It is based on data collected as part of an HIV prevention study between January 2018 and January 2020. From that data set was extracted the responses of some 1,194 13-to-18-year-old boys, all of whom identified as gay, bisexual or as being attracted to people regardless of gender.
“This study is encouraging in that it shows that many teens, including those under 18 years old, are comfortable with their sexuality,” said lead author David A. Moskowitz, PhD, assistant professor of medical social sciences at Northwestern University’s Institute for Sexual and Gender Minority Health and Wellbeing. “At the same time, we must be cautious, as the data also point to some of the same barriers and discrimination that previous generations have faced. Work still needs to be done.”
Gen Z are the group born from 1998 to 2010.
Participants were asked demographic questions, such as their race and age and social questions such as their religious affiliations and the frequency with which they attended religious events. They were also asked to respond on a scale of 1 to 4, with 1 being strongly agree and 4 being strongly disagree, to a series of statements to gauge their attitudes about their own sexual identities. These statements included, “Sometimes I think that if I were straight, I would be happier” and “If there were a pill to make me straight, I’d take it.” They were also asked a series of questions, such as, “How many times has someone chased you because of your sexuality?”
Researchers found that 66% of those surveyed were out to their mothers or other female parental figures and 49% were out to their fathers or other male parental figures. In the 1990s, in contrast, an estimated 40% of adolescent boys were out to their mothers and less than 30% were out to their fathers, according to the researchers.
The study also found that white participants were more likely than Black participants to be out to a parent or parental figure. Those identifying as gay were more likely to be out to a parent than bisexuals or those unsure of their sexuality. Participants who said they were not religious were more likely to say they were out to a parent than teens who identified as religious. Teens who were not fully accepting of their identity were less likely to come out than those who embraced their identity.
Stigma Still
A new research paper reports that bi men with HIV have worse self-image and wellbeing than their gay counterparts. “Social research with people living with HIV (PLHIV) rarely distinguishes between gay men and bisexual men. However, bisexual men may have unique experiences of HIV-related stigma and distinct support needs,” opens the report in the journal AIDS and Behavior.
It’s based on a survey of 872 people living with HIV in Australia, of which 48 were bisexual men and 681 gay. The bi men report higher levels of concern over public attitudes to HIV, disclosure concerns, negative self-image and personal stigma. Also that they were much less likely to spend no time around other people who they knew to be HIV positive.
The paper notes the history of stigmatisation of bisexuality in men from early HIV/AIDS awareness in the 1980s: “Historically, bisexual men have held a complex position in relation to HIV. When the epidemic first emerged in the 1980s, bisexual men were often demonised in media and public discourse as they were considered to be the source of HIV transmission to women (who at the time were often positioned as “innocent victims” of HIV) and the heterosexual community in general.”
Further that while HIV work has often been centred in spaces that marginalised bis: “there is often limited space created for bisexual people within lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer (LGBTQ) communities.”
“Bisexual men living with HIV are often more isolated from services for PLHIV or less connected to others living with HIV as a result.”
Further: “without a network of peers, many men in this survey may have limited experience of feeling supported as a person with HIV and limited opportunity to let down their guard in a social setting.”
Interestingly the statistics also reflect the lower earnings of bi people found elsewhere. 24.2% of the gay men in the sample earned under Aus$30,000 (£16,000) while 37.5% of the bi men fell into that pay bracket – which reflects how 41.6% of the gay men were in full-time employment but only 25% of the bisexuals.
Read more: link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10461-021-03236-6
