LGBT and Christianity are not easy bedfellows and bisexuality and Christianity even more so. The stereotype of the sexually voracious bisexual does not sit well within a largely erotophobic Christian Church, obsessed with monosexual monogamy and preserving its (frequently misguided) status as a preserver of moral integrity.

Yet even the most affirming of LGBT Churches for some reason struggle to acknowledge, let alone address, the issue of bisexuality within teaching and pastoral resources. This is curious, since a GLAAD study of 2015 showed that over half (52%) of the LGB community identified as bi, three times as many as identified as lesbian (17%) and about a third more than identified as gay (31%). What is it about bisexuality that makes it so difficult to talk about in a church that increasingly engages, however positively, with same sex marriage and transgender issues? It is almost as if there is a kind of conspiracy of silence around the orientation. And this silence can be deadly, as I discovered in my body of research on the bisexual Christian intersectional identity.

There is a good reason for this ‘bi-lence’ – why bisexuality and Christianity remain almost invisible, however queer-affirming the institution. As in the secular world, this silence is largely due to the twin aspects of biphobia and bi-erasure, concepts with which BCN readers will be familiar and don’t require further explanation. But there are other aspects peculiar to religious environments which exacerbate the silence on bisexuality, particularly when the church purports to be an affirming setting.Bi erasure via cultural appropriation takes place in queer theology and affirming church life, as in the secular world. A number of well-known works of gay theology promote King David and his close buddy Jonathan as gay icons. Yet David sees a naked woman sunbathing in 2 Samuel in the Old Testament and is overcome by lust – hardly the act of a gay man. Therefore, David is either heterosexual with an intense friendship with Jonathan, or, more likely, bisexual, but certainly not homosexual.

In a similar way, Ruth in the Old Testament is either portrayed as loyal friend to Naomi or lesbian lover of Naomi, while the notion that she could be attracted to Boaz and Naomi is rarely entertained. And then there is Jesus and the Beloved Disciple, Jesus and his close friend Lazarus, yet also Jesus and Mary Magdalene. Clearly we don’t really know for sure about the sexual orientation of any of these figures from Scripture, and it is arguably anachronistic to attempt to do so. But if we are going to ascribe sexual orientations to such figures, let us at least do so with integrity and an open mind, and accept that David, Ruth and Jesus might just be bisexual.

Queer theologians are particularly guilty of bi erasure, either through the aforementioned cultural appropriation of potentially bisexual role models, or by ignoring the subject altogether. Most affirming LGBT Christian living books I have encountered usually do little more than include ‘B’ nominally in the title. There is almost never any content on bisexuality.

Sexual identity politics also play a role in stigmatisation and erasure of bisexual Christians. Many gay and lesbian Christians have fought hard to have their rights recognised, culminating in the achievement of marriage equality in many countries of the world, including the UK. Bisexual people are seen to be flies in the ointment of sexual identity politics as they are perceived as diluting what I call the Lady Gaga argument, that ‘I was born that way’ i.e. born lesbian or gay. Bisexuality indicates an element of choice, which is not part of the lesbian and gay politic.

In addition, bisexuality carries the stigma of promiscuity, which is even more taboo within Church circles. Lesbian and gay Christians do not want their image tainted by ‘dirty bisexuals’ when they are trying to achieve moral parity with heterosexual Christians. As with their heterosexual counterparts, it is the result of ignorance of the bisexual orientation and the true lived experiences of bisexual Christians. There are many more reasons why bisexuality is erased and stigmatised, and I refer you to my body of work on the subject if you want to find out more.

The sad reality, which I must highlight here though, is that bisexual people suffer from extremely poor mental health, on a par with transgender people. This is magnified several times over in the church, where attitudes are even more judgemental and less informed than in secular society. A Canadian Health Survey from 2010 showed that bisexual people are six times more likely to attempt suicide than straight people, and twice as likely as their lesbian and gay counterparts. And these are secular figures. In my own research in the UK and US, I found an 88% overall rate of depression and suicide ideation among bisexual Christians. It is hardly surprising, though, when bisexual people face prejudice from both the straight and LGBT communities. These figures are horrifying and should alone galvanise pastors and supporters of LGBT folk into action.

You can find further details of Carol Shepherd’s body of work on bisexuality at Non Fiction (carolshepherdbooks.info) You can also give to Carol’s JustGiving page, aimed at sending works of affirming LGBT theology to churches and faith schools around the UK: Crowdfunding to Send a book to churches, schools and other faith organisations in the UK on JustGiving


Dr Carol Shepherd is a global expert on bisexual Christians identities.
An academic researcher, writer, speaker and Sociology lecturer, Carol is the author of ‘The Damage of Silence: Bisexuality in the Western Christian Church’ (Palgrave, 2018) and ‘Bi: the Way, Pastoring Bisexual Christians in Europe’ (EYP, 2020).