Section 28 is still on the statute books.
Tony N. examines the campaign to have it repealed.
Some bisexual and gay people at this year’s festival-less Pride March were wearing school uniforms. Don’t be fooled into thinking that it was the LGB St TrinianŐs fan club, or a confused school outing to London. The reason was, of course, the queer community’s campaign for the repeal of Section 28.
This is perhaps the most worrying law in Britain for bisexuals, as it actively discriminates against relationships which fall outside of the supposed heterosexual ideal. It is a major priority for groups such as Stonewall and Outrage because its consequences for young and vulnerable bisexuals are very serious. For those of you who might be unsure as to exactly what it is here is the offending section of the 1988 Local Government Act in full:
A local authority shall not:
a)intentionally promote homosexuality or publish material with the intention of promoting homosexuality;
b)promote the teaching in any maintained school of the acceptability of homosexuality as a pretend family relationship.
You may read this and think, but what does it really mean? Its slight vagueness means that there has been some confusion about it. Many people have erred on the side of caution. This means that young people discovering for the first time that they are bisexual or gay, often while they are at school, don’t get the support and information they need, and at the time they need it. Sex education classes can save people’s lives, and boys having gay sex for the first time are part of the group most at risk of serious STDs such as AIDS. Many teachers will not cover safer sex in a gay context because of Section 28. It may sound dramatic to talk about Section 28 in terms of life and death, but this really is true, and nothing serves to highlight it more than teenage suicide rates. Gay and bisexual teenagers are three times more likely to kill themselves than their peers. In fact 19% attempt suicide and roughly a third experience verbal abuse and isolation at school. What is really needed, instead of laws which clamp down on homosexuality, is policies against biphobia and homophobia in all schools.
Section 28 is a particular concern to bisexuals because it has been suggested on more than one occasion, including by Angela Mason and Douglas Slater of Outrage, that one of the underlying principles behind its creation is biphobia. They say that “it may have been intended to ensure that all those who might be bisexual expressed themselves exclusively heterosexually”. If this is the case then the thinking behind Section 28 does show a real lack of comprehension about what makes a bisexual person tick. It is also rather ominous to think that young people would be effectively encouraged to adopt a false identity.
So what is the future for Section 28? Let’s hope that it will be a short one. It is now a full decade since the Tory MP Dame Jill Knight tabled the amendment, provoking an unprecedented level of protest from the queer community, and some say spurring us on to become more politically aware and active. The odious section’s tenth anniversary may be its last. The government is considering plans to scrap the 1988 Act, replacing it with new clearer legislation. The likelihood is that this will mean the end of Section 28 as there are no plans to continue its ideology. David Blunkett, the education secretary, has raised hopes by stating: “I have no problem with the repeal of Section 28. In fact I have committed myself to joining with Cabinet colleagues on ensuring that we do remove this.”
Whilst we all hold our breaths in anticipation we should remember that the repeal of Section 28 is only one step (albeit a pretty big one) in the right direction. The attitudes of those people in authority must be changed to realise that bisexuality and homosexuality are not problems which need controlling. The real problem is prejudice and hostility against bi and gay people, especially in schools and colleges where young people are forming their ideas about themselves and the world. No responsible government can condone a system which deliberately creates a two tier society. There are solutions being put into practise; anti-homophobic bullying policies, positive discussion about queer people in classes, and LGB homework clubs etc. But these are embryonic and need encouraging and promoting. Equality is the current watchword for bi and gay rights; but those young people most damaged by Section 28 often don’t have the capacity or resources to be vociferous about their own equality. Let’s hope that the future will see a situation where their interests can be safeguarded without anyone having to worry about recriminations.
Tony N
