Dear BCN,
We are writing as representatives of the London Bisexual Women’s Group. We have recently had discussions within the group regarding male to female transsexuals attending and have had to formulate policy on this. As part of the bisexual community, we wanted to write to BCN to explain the decisions which we have made and the reasoning behind them. It also seemed like an opportune moment to try and open up some debate on this subject before Bicon, as the literature being sent out about Bicon states that a policy on transsexuals has not yet been decided upon.

The issue as to whether pre-operative transsexuals should attend our group arose over the last few weeks, due to an increased number of transsexuals attending and was something that as a group we were unable to agree on. About half the group felt that we should have an open door policy which permitted anybody who self-defined as a woman to attend, whilst the other half of the group felt that there should be some restrictions as to who should be allowed to attend the group, as it is a women-only space. For example, excluding people who seemed obviously male in appearance and behaviour. However, this is obviously subjective and would be impossible to implement in a sensitive non-discriminatory way.

Unable to agree, we approached the management of the London Women’s Centre (The Wheel) where we meet, to give us their policy. They wrote us a letter back which stated that their policy is that only biological women and post-operative transsexuals can attend groups in women-only spaces within the centre. The room where we meet is one of these women-only spaces and is the only room in the centre large enough to accommodate our group. In addition to this, we receive a subsidy on room hire for being an unfunded women’s group. If we admitted pre-operative transsexuals to the group, we would lose this and be charged double the rate, which is not financially viable.

We therefore decided to accept the Wheel’s policy. However, a suggestion was made that another bisexual women’s group should be established for pre-operative transsexuals and their supporters to meet monthly an hour before our group in a smaller room within the women’s centre which is not a women-only space. Pre-operative transsexuals will, of course, be welcome to attend social events which we organise away from the centre and to join us in First Out which we always go to after the group.

The Wheel’s policy will be read out at the beginning of each group as part of our general introduction to the group which explains what we do, how often we meet etc.

It has been argued that allowing the management of the Wheel to make our decision for us was a weak solution. However, it was the only thing we could do. We could not come to an agreement within ourselves and if we had been forced to do so, it would probably have split the group acrimoniously in half. For those of who have been long term members of the group and invested a lot in it, this was an awful prospect. Going to the Wheel was a pragmatic and practical solution and was done as a last resort.

We are aware that at least one member of the group has left because of the decision we have made and we regret this, but we feel that more people would have left it we had not acted. We believe that we acted in the only way that we could to hold together a group that has been going since 1984 and that many of us passionately believe in. We are also aware that drawing a line between pre- and post-operative transsexuals is a crude line to draw and not necessarily appropriate. For example, someone informed us that the Charing Cross Hospital will not allow male to female transsexuals who identify as lesbian or bisexual to undergo surgery. This obviously means that many people cannot become post-operative transsexuals without lying about their sexual orientation. However, as mentioned before, this is the line drawn by the Wheel, who we approached as a practical measure to resolve this difficult situation.

We hope that this clarifies our position and we apologise to those people who have been caught in the middle of this. We hope the second group proposed is a success and that pre-operative transsexuals continue to feel part of our community.

Mary Tinsley and Fiona Venner

London Bisexual Women’s Group

Bye Community News?
As it approaches its third birthday, BCN is still produced by many of the original collective. Whilst we have enjoyed our time, several of us are now moving on – to new challenges – or simply to spend more time with our social lives.

This will leave the collective that produces BCN very short-staffed. In particular, the jobs of Editor, Secretary and Distributor will be vacant. A number of collective members intend to continue and there has been some interest shown by others who contribute to BCN. However, we have not yet managed to get a full, viable collective together to produce the next issue.

To be viable, a collective needs to not only have sufficient skills and resources, but must also be able to work together as a unit. Given the electronic nature of publishing, geography is the one thing that is unlikely to be a factor.

We remain hopeful, but if by the end of Bicon a collective is not in position to take on publication, we will have to take the responsible decision and wind-up BCN.

We would like people to come to Bicon ready to discuss the future. Is BCN still wanted? Or would it be better to start a new publication with a different remit and/or different style?

Can you realistically commit to helping – and meet that commitment? (There’s nothing worse than someone who says they will do something and then does nothing.)

If you’ve got views on these, or other relevant matters, talk to us at Bicon, come to our workshop or contact us by email or post.

Steve Pointer, Editor

SM Bisexuals Elections
SM bisexuals are holding their AGM on 13 September at the Central Station pub in north London. They will vote on a constitution as well as electing a committee for the next year. Applications for postal votes have already closed, but candidates for the committee can be nominated at any time up until the meeting starts. Contact SM Bis’ usual address (see listings) for more details.