Fossils still walking…

Panorama (BBC1, 27 October)

Panorama looked at the attitudes towards gay people now that Labour are in power. I could almost predict what was coming from the opening sentences about how attitudes towards gay people had changed. I could imagine the programme-makers saying to each other, ‘Look, the gay thing is current now, everyone seems accepting and happy. It can’t really be like that – let’s go and make a programme which shows the other side’. And they did.

The programme took a ‘balanced’ view (that is, gave the same credence to homophobes as to gay-positive people) and tried to give a picture while staying as far away from gay people as possible. No mention of bi people and, once again, lesbian issues barely got a look-in.

We got the vox pops from the walking fossils (you know, the string ’em up crowd), and then we got vox pops from Stephen Fry (not a good example of a politically aware and sorted out gay/bi man I would have thought). We had the ‘new’ Labour voices telling us how queer-friendly they are: this remains to be seen – at least they have two out ministers, Chris Smith and Angela Eagle.

The surveys looked at those old favourites: the armed forces, Section 28, partnership and adoption. Some surprises: most thought having serving queers in the armed forces was fine. Most had problems with issues around children such as sex education, Section 28 and adoption. Most people were all for same-sex couples having some rights through partnership laws but they weren’t happy for same sex couples to marry.

On the whole, not very good; the same thing could have been done in the 70s.

The In-betweenies

On 17 November, London freebie magazine Midweek ran a feature entitled ‘Don’t mess with Mister In-Between’ about, you guessed it, bisexuality. The usual famous names (James Dean, Marlene Dietrich, Michael Stipe) crop up, along with a few cringeworthy references to being ‘AC/DC’ and ‘swinging both ways’, but once you get past this, the article is quite positive in places as well as being hopelessly stereotyped in others.

marlene dietrich The author, Simon Brooke, appears to have done his homework (although he seems to think that Peter Tatchell wrote Bisexual Horizons) and quotes from the likes of Marjorie Garber as well as from ‘greedy bisexual’ Felicity Diamond of recent Seven Sins fame. There is rather too much emphasis on indiscriminate shagging – ‘bisexuals, by their very nature, inevitably find monogamy difficult’ claims Brooke; elsewhere he proclaims, taking his cue no doubt from Ms Diamond, that ‘promiscuity is very much part of the “greedy creed”‘. (Now does anyone, apart from some bright spark at Channel 4, really use ‘greedy’ as a synonym for ‘bisexual’?)

There’s an interesting little snippet from James Collard, editor of gay magazine Attitude, who talks approvingly of the breaking down of gay/straight boundaries and claims that he himself once had ‘three days of bisexuality’ and doesn’t regret it. Now that would have made for a much more interesting article – though probably not one that would be appreciated by the weary commuters at whom this throwaway piece is aimed.

george melly Am-bi-dextrous

London Evening Standard (4 November)

The Standard did a profile of George Melly, and very flattering it was too. They called him London’s most civilised man and ‘abidingly ambidextrous’. George explained, ‘Now I am about 15% gay; time was when it was 75%’. He was married to Diana and was monogamous for the first eight years. He says that after eight years ‘…I had reached the limits of monogamy’. He pushed his wife into taking a lover ‘…and then I was off the hook. I carried on like a maniac’. His relationship with his wife has gone down, then up, and he says ‘Now… we are very happy, happier than we’ve ever been.’

The Oscar thing

Omnibus (BBC1, 12 October)

Omnibus, sometimes accused of being nothing but a plug programme for forthcoming books or films, did a programme on Oscar Wilde introduced by Michael Bracewell.

This was obviously a programme which was looking for a different angle on the Oscar thing. His trial has been covered several times, his plays performed on TV many times and now there is the film starring Stephen Fry. How could the programme makers get their budget approved? The angle proved to be casting him as the first superstar of the 20th century. To this end they had all sorts of pop stars like Neil Tennant from the Pet Shop Boys to give quotes and opinions of Oscar’s rise and fall from the vantage point of someone who really knows what it is like to be a mega-celeb.

The result was a mixture of really annoying stuff – trying to squeeze a man from the end of the 19th century into modern sensibilities – and some fascinating insights into his life.

Oscar Wilde appeals to all sorts of different people for different reasons. For Ulick O’Connor (an Irish playwright), he is an Irishman who was cruelly persecuted by the British Imperialist regime. For Tom Stoppard (an English playwright), he is the man who created The Importance of Being Earnest. For 60/70s rockers like Mick Jagger and David Bowie, he is a counter-cultural icon who consciously stood outside the mainstream. For the gay community, he is a gay icon. For us, he is an historical bi figure who should be reclaimed from the gay community.

As you all know, Wilde was married with children and did not start to explore his homosexual side until his early thirties. Once he started to explore, he was very attracted to younger men with a destructive streak. His self-destructive relationship with Lord Douglas has been endlessly rehashed and this programme did not contribute anything new. He was the first artist of the modern era to take the idea ‘art for art’s sake’ to its conclusion. He made appreciation of beauty of ‘minor’ objects as a lifestyle choice (here the programme made dubious comparisons between his appreciation of blue china and white lilies with Andy Warhol’s pictures of Campbell’s Soup cans – stretching it more than a bit, I think).

The programme looked at his influence on pop artists. Here, Michael Bracewell showed us an image of Michael Jackson, the man who stays eternally young while only his image gets older in the plastic surgeon’s files. Pop artists, according to Bracewell, are the modern Dorian Greys.

The programme explored his decision to stay in London even though he knew that he would be arrested and imprisoned. Neil Tenant’s theory was that he made a conscious choice to stay in order to become a superstar martyr. According to his theory, Wilde would not have become a legend if he had only written good plays and not been arrested and tried for gross indecency. This is debatable. For Ulick O’Connor, the choice to stay was a result of his mother writing hi a note to the effect that if he ran away she would disown him.

It did bring out the ambiguity in Wilde’s personality: on the whole, a reasonable programme.

Kevin Saunders