Chasing Amy
(dir. Kevin Smith, USA, 1997)
Chasing Amy, from the director of cult hits Clerks and Mallrats, is a twentysomething take on contemporary sexual politics, its protagonists a group of young cartoonists. (Straight) boy falls for girl, discovers girl is a lesbian but can’t fall out of love with her. Their friendship turns sexual; boy then discovers girl has a wild heterosexual past. Boy cannot handle this and it all ends in tears, though not before the full comic potential of the plot has been exploited.
Aimed at a young, straight audience, Chasing Amy comes across as a kind of ‘queer politics for beginners’. It’s full of well-meaning, lengthy speeches – Alyssa (the heroine) explaining to Holden (the hero) exactly what lesbians do in bed; Holden lecturing his friend Banky on homophobia; black gay cartoonist Hooper patiently educating the white boys about the sexual politics of race. It’s difficult to escape the conclusion that ‘minority’ characters are being used as the mouthpieces for the film’s moral and political lessons while the main focus remains resolutely on the young white men.
chasing amy Ultimately, though, the film has a very simple, liberal message. People should be judged as individuals; stereotyping is a bad thing (a powerful but humorous illustration is the persona Hooper is forced to adopt for his white audience), and straight men need to swot up on their sexual politics or they’ll never have any hope of getting laid. For a mainstream film this is in many ways quite progressive, and anything that might convince a young audience that it’s unhip to be homophobic should no doubt be encouraged. Also, the portrayal of Alyssa (who I didn’t find wholly believable) at least avoided the ‘all dykes really need a man’ interpretation – though if you are looking for any nuggets of wisdom about bisexuality, the nearest you are likely to get is the line from the promotional poster – ‘It’s not who you love. It’s how.’
Claire Parry
I.D.
Polar Theatre, Riverside Arts Studio, London
November 1997
Director: David Leddy
Performers: Beate Fritzsching, David Harradine, Lisa Gornick, Richard Lancaster, Alison Cocks
This play claimed to address ‘the nature of gay identity’ using academic texts, extracts from Boys in the Band and Bound, and dance music. The characters were a gay man, a lesbian, a bisexual woman, a straight woman and a bisexual man. What was surprising was the amount of material on bisexuality and how accurate this was (Bisexual Horizons was one of the texts quoted from); indeed this is the kind of play that could have been produced by the bisexual community – it was often puerile, amateurish and embarrassing, failing as theatre and completely plot-free, but thought-provoking.
The stereotype of bi men and women as sexually rapacious and indiscriminate was parodied, and a typical Jeffrey Weeks-style esoteric academic text discussing the merits of ‘fluid sexuality’ without ever once mentioning bisexuality was ‘translated’: ‘when a bi man and a bi woman have a relationship, it is called a straight relationship, even though there are no straight people in it’. Gay male identity was parodied by a quiz on ‘how gay are you?’ (‘Do you find the idea of sex with women completely repugnant?’; ‘Where do you shop?’; ‘How many men have you had sex with in the last month?’; etc.). The equation of ‘identity politics’ with ‘grammar’ was also interesting.
The mainly gay audience often seemed non-plussed by debates on bi separatism versus integration, and a ‘gay scene rules for bisexuals’ sketch: ‘You should leave an appropriate gap between breaking up with a partner of the same sex and starting a relationship with a partner of the opposite sex’, etc. Despite the ‘this is our first year drama school project’ experimental style, the play was generally effective and had a overall positive line about sexuality becoming rooted in actual experience rather than identity. It could work well at a Bicon, if cut down.
Kevin Lano
Pomosexuals: challenging assumptions about gender and sexuality
Edited by Carol Queen and Lawrence Schimel
(Cleis Press, 1997; ISBN 1 573 44074 4)
Pomosexual, according to the book jacket, is ‘the queer erotic reality beyond the boundaries of gender, separatism and essentialist notions of sexual orientation’.As bisexuals, this particular reality is one we often hope, or claim, to have attained, so it comes as no surprise that a fair number of the contributors to this book are either bisexual or are popular with the bi community. Neither does it come as a surprise that much of the content is muddled, pretentious and strangely familiar to anyone with a rudimentary knowledge of ‘queer theory’. However, it is saved by some thoughtful and intriguing pieces, notably John Weir’s ‘Like a Virgin’, the story of a gay man experimenting with heterosexual sex, and David Harrison’s ‘The Personals’ in which the author, a FtM transsexual, faces communication problems with the men he meets through the personal ads.
Kate Bornstein gets it right when she says in her introduction ‘playfulness is what this book is filled with’. The pieces largely reflect people who are secure enough in their sexual identity to experiment and push the boundaries of those identities – no self-loathing or tortured coming out stories here. It’s a confident, urban, sophisticated kind of book, perfect for reading in your favourite trendy coffee shop or shocking the Daily Mail readers on the tube. All in all, an entertaining read but unlikely to challenge your assumptions unless you’ve been living in a cave for the last ten years.
Claire Parry
Here, we review some books that some of us (Steve C, Claire Parry and Jo Eadie) have been reading lately. Maybe they’re not all that relevant to bisexuality, but hopefully some of you are interested in gender and race issues too, and they could provide ideas for Christmas presents if you’re stuck for ideas!
From Queer to Eternity: spirituality in the lives of lesbian, gay and bisexual people
Peter Sweasey (Cassells)
Spirituality is ‘about what it means to be human, what it is to be alive, what it is to be a part of creation. It’s to do with a sense of community, of humanity, something that’s much bigger than all of us, that isn’t above us but which is more like a source of life – the “ground of our being” that supports us, that works through us, that we’re in partnership with. All of that is not something I’ve read in a book… it’s come out of my own experience.’ [Rabbi Elizabeth Sarah]
There are some pretty dreadful books about sexuality and religion – scholarly, long winded, abstract and defensive books justifying sexual difference to a sceptical religious establishment. This work is far more interesting than that.
It starts with the lives of lesbian, gay and bisexual people who feel that they need some spiritual dimension, and who seek that in a dazzling variety of paths and traditions. The backbone of the book is a host of detailed interviews, or written submissions. Contributors’ value as people, and the acceptability of their sexuality, is taken for granted.
This book seeks more to explain to the gay mainstream, whatever that is, why many out proud queers see nothing wrong with going to church, synagogue or meditation class – why some even stay within a broadly hostile tradition to fight from within. But even this it does from an assertive position, that the so-called gay community has no right to dictate to individuals what view of things they should take. It is a confident, multi-faceted, thought-provoking book – as full of nuggets and flavours as a good Christmas cake.
Unlike some books, this does not assume Christianity to be the norm – Pagans, Buddhists, Jews, New Agers and seekers on other paths have equal say – nor are the voices confined to men, to priests or to theologians. Bisexuality is affirmed, and monogamy is not assumed or given particular status.
Sweasey’s argument develops – and any decent book is difficult to summarise in a few paragraphs. Certainly one point which came across strongly to me was that making your sexuality the centre of your being, or your spirituality, suggests a problem of maturity. Sex and sexual identity matter – my sexuality affects me every day of the year – but they are not the be-all and end-all of existence. We’re called to be something much more interesting, and complex, and important, than ‘queers’ or ‘proud bisexuals’ – we’re called to be human beings. Sweasey suggests that our carefully constructed sexual identity may just end up being another piece of baggage we need to move on from. Amen.
SC
Transgender Warriors: making history from Joan of Arc to Dennis Rodman
Leslie Feinberg (Beacon Press, Boston, 1996)
Yes, there has been a glut of books on transgender issues recently, some better than others, but this one is a social history which analyses the links between capitalism and the oppression of transgendered people. However, Feinberg’s impassioned writing, and the inclusion of a ‘portrait gallery’ reflecting the lives and experiences of people across the transgender spectrum, give the book a warmth which prevents it coming across as dry and academic. CP
The Good Ship Venus: the erotic voyages of the Olympia Press
John de St. Jorre (Pimlico, London, 1994)
Fascinating story of the trials and tribulations of the groundbreaking Paris publishing house which introduced Henry Miller and William Burroughs to the world. Want to know who really wrote The Story of O? The answer’s here, along with lots of other intriguing anecdotes.
CP
The Black Dahlia; The Big Nowhere; L.A. Confidential; White Jazz
James Ellroy (Arrow Books)
If you’ve seen the film of L.A. Confidential currently on release, you’ll know what the books on which it was based are about: a corrupt L.A. police force in the 1950s, making a city safe for big business by breaking heads and intimidating suspects. But while it’s a fine film, it barely begins to do justice to Ellroy’s books. They are about people maintaining what they think of as honour while surrounded by deceit and violence – and almost always failing to be any better than their opponents (whether serial killers, gangsters, or their own corrupt employers). They also have a very strong evocation of the illegal homosexual underground of the time – easily subject to blackmail, and routinely harrassed by the police. Above all, they are written in a unique prose style in which sentences are compressed down to telegrams, capturing all the urgency and incoherence of men obsessed by their jobs, their desires, or their guilty consciences. Irredeemably cynical and a great antidote to Christmas cheer.
JE
Colored People
Henry Louyis Gates (Penguin)
When white people write the history of racism, they are usually only too keen to celebrate the end of the segregation of white and black communities: they are smug about the fact that they think they opened their arms to embrace people that they had once crossed the street to avoid, and it always seems as if they expect gratitude as a result.
Gates’s autobiographical novel takes a very diffferent view of events – a black view of segregation in the USA. While he documents the damage done by the economic ostracisation of black communities by rich whites, he is more concerned with the losses that black people suffered as a resut of integration: the collapse of communities that lived by their own rules on the borders of white culture; the intrusion of white values into a world that had managed to resist them; and the obligation to see oneself in relation to white folk, rather than in relation to black folk.
Gates moves quickly through the incidents and personalities of his upbringing in 50s/60s America, describing a childhhod world whose loss he feels strongly. A lesson in how to write the history and life of a community, from which queer folk might have a lot to learn.
JE
