With most of the media in full swing as regards the general election, we wondered what we stand to gain by voting, or not voting.

Why I vote

As a socialist, I don’t believe that real progressive change can come through parliament: but I’m sure that anyone with any sense must want to get the Tories out of government, even if they don’t particularly want anyone else in.

In the last eighteen years the Tories, the party of Family Life and Law and Order, have instigated laws which have helped to tear families apart by putting thousands of people out of work, slashing benefits and throwing immigrants out of the country. They have encouraged hatred of gays, lesbians and bisexuals by bringing in Section 28 of the Local Government Act and turned a blind eye to queer and racist murders, while at the same time indulging in as much extra-marital sex as they can get away with while still keeping their `respectable’ image.

Don’t get me wrong: I don’t believe that anything will change if Labour – or anyone else – gets into power. But at least Labour has a history of being a democratic people’s party, and many people still have illusions that they can really change things through Labour.

In abstract, a good case can be made for not voting – it’s a very limited form of democracy that relies on you making one choice every five years. However, abstaining from this process is not progressive. Not voting doesn’t make the system go away. Participating in the process gives you the opportunity to use the heightened period of political consciousness to argue for real change. Of course, if it came to a choice of voting for a Tory or a fascist, I wouldn’t vote for either of them. But while there is someone who even vaguely resembles a democratic choice, I will vote for them, but at the same time fight for radical change in the social system.

Jude

Why I don’t vote

I can safely say that I’m sick to the teeth of all this fuss over a tick (or is it a cross?) in a box every five years. We give these politician types more attention than their pathetic attempts at `governing’ deserve. And I ain’t interested in what they think of bisexuality, especially since they probably won’t be telling the truth anyway!

Real government would involve us in being able to give our opinion on a variety of issues in a way that differentiated between the different issues.

For example, I might feel that one penny in the pound devoted to education is a good thing (and opinion polls purport to show that a majority of the population agree), but that constitutional reform of the House of Lords is not. At present, the former point would move me to vote Lib Dem, but that would mean the latter might happen against my wishes.

All the media space given over to the sleazy besuited `governors’ of ours trying to convince us that there is a genuine difference between them could truly be devoted to exploring the issues, then we could spend fifteen minutes down at the polling booth filling in a multiple choice type questionnaire where we indicated our opinion on all the different issues. An organisation called Practical Alternatives, which I belive still exists, has put forward a model along these lines.

Krayg