In the early hours of the morning of August 7th 2020, I read a tweet that was life changing. It was from Dr Charlotte, a senior lecturer in Psychology at a UK University, the tweet said “I actually hesitated on posting this today. I never explicitly talk about my own sexuality, due to prior bad experience and erasure but representation and visibility are so important” It also had the hashtag #beautifullybisexual.
I didn’t know Charlotte, I only saw the tweet because it had been liked by a colleague of mine at Manchester Metropolitan University (Mcr Met), but something about it was like a light switch turning on in my brain, here was another Psychologist who was brave enough to tweet about being ‘beautifully bisexual’, meanwhile I had only told a couple of colleagues and it had taken me nearly ten years of working here to do that.
Something about the words “representation and visibility” cut through me, I was struck both by how brave she was and also how much I wanted to do the same. It came at a time when I was feeling particularly burdened by my own feelings of invisibility in the heteronormative spaces I was inhabiting. I was desperately wanting to find a way to break through that barrier but I hadn’t quite worked out how, or if I would be able to deal with the likely ripple effect it would cause.
I decided to send her a private message. It said “Good morning Charlotte, thanks for being visible. I am not as brave as you, although I have told a couple of colleagues, I am bi recently and am slowly trying to come out of the closet. I couldn’t sleep last night, seeing your message was just what I needed.”
She replied, and was so lovely, in her reply one phrase really stood out, she said “I am known for being outspoken, and stand up for my students a lot”. That made me laugh, as any of my colleagues will attest to I am exactly the same, I replied to Charlotte with the words “literally me” and I thought this a sign that I need to start being honest about who I am, both with myself and others around me.
In part the motivation for this was authenticity, whilst I had been ‘out’ in certain safe spaces at various points of my life, I had for over a decade remained as firmly in the back of the closet as the tight jeans that I no longer fit into. In part this was a feeling that I wasn’t being an advocate for LGBTQIA people out of fear of outing myself. I really hated this, since I am so passionate about LGBTQIA rights (as well as the rights of other marginalised groups) and whilst I do take on board that coming out is a personal journey (and a repeated revelation at that), and I certainly would not expect anyone else from the community to take an advocacy role, it still bothered me that I wasn’t liking or retweeting certain things that I wanted to.
A few weeks after the tweet from Charlotte I was speaking to a colleague, Dr Leanne who told me that due to the Covid-19 pandemic the Psychology Pride group would be taking place online and that the students on the online programme that I co-run at Mcr Met would be welcome to join. I was absolutely elated by this (and simultaneously chastised myself for not providing an online space for a Pride group in the past). Over the next few days I very tentatively tested the water with Leanne, first asking if I could attend the group, to which she assumed I meant as an ally, and then a couple of days later telling her that I actually meant as a member of the LGBTQIA community, and that I was bisexual. Telling Leanne was so hard, my whole body reacted with a feeling that I can’t quite describe, yet I am sure is a feeling that resonates with so many people reading this. She was of course completely lovely and supportive and welcoming, and as a result I came out to another colleague who was also just as lovely. With the support from my colleagues and a newfound “life is too short to not live your truth” mentality, I joined the Psychology Pride group at work, and I also joined the BiPhoria group. Between these two wonderfully welcoming spaces and incredible friends and colleagues (who have supported me in a number of different ways) I have finally let go of the shame I have been holding onto for such a long time.
STUDENT EXPERIENCE:
“As a bisexual, I have never until this academic year felt like there was a place for me. Within heteronormative and LGBT+ groups alike there can be such a stigma about what being bisexual means, and this can lead to isolation and feeling like a satellite that doesn’t quite fit anywhere. Carly being out and open about her own bisexuality holds a positive implication for bisexuals and the wider LGBTQ+ community, because as an educational professional one is basically leading the next generation (regardless of age) forwards by example.
“This is allowing those of us on the outside to now feel like there can be a seat at the table for us, to see that we can belong without having to straighten ourselves. To know that one day we can go to work ourselves and mention our other halves without having to consider the potential controversy this might cause.” – Beckie
I am extremely privileged to work for an organisation that is supportive of the LGBTQIA staff and students and am so eternally grateful for the support that other members of the LGBTQIA community have given me in my journey.
One colleague in particular that stands out is Dr Neil, we have had many conversations as he has listened to me confront, consider and finally accept who I am, he said “Carly takes all her fabulousness with in her journey of further self-discovery as she explores and expands a more authentic way of being in and of the world. It’s been a gift, a complete pleasure to stand by her side as she uncovers yet more layers of fabulousness in inhabiting her bisexuality”.
I have also been touched by the support I have received from colleagues who are not part of the LGBTQIA community, of particular note are Dr Jenny and Dr Geoff (my co-programme lead) whose genuine support and acceptance of me has allowed me to flourish as bisexual in heteronormative spaces as well.
STUDENT EXPERIENCE:
“I had no gay role models growing up; references to homosexuality in the culture were sparce and generally negative (bisexuality was mentioned even less, to the point where it was practically invisible, and its validity was usually questioned: “they just haven’t made up their mind” or “they must really be gay though”).
Even though I have always been surrounded by wonderfully loving and supportive family members and friends, heteronormativity is powerful, and I did not feel comfortable “coming out” until I was 22. Even then I was only out to certain people and in certain situations because, for instance, at the time I could have been fired for being gay. The cultural landscape has certainly improved in many ways over the years in regard to visibility of, tolerance toward, and legal rights for non-heterosexuals but stigma, stereotypes, and negativity still abound and I have always felt the need to continue to carefully manage that part of my identity. Each new environment requires thoughtful navigation and testing of the water before knowing whether it’s safe to jump in and, for example, say “wife” rather than the generic “partner” in conversation.
The effort required for this can be both frustrating and exhausting which is why it is SO helpful to enter an environment where there are clear signs that it will be a safe place. Carly’s openness regarding her sexuality was a clear sign for me that my new university environment would be a safe place. I am a reasonably confident woman in my late thirties, my wife and I have been together for well over a decade, and I’m fortunate to be at a very settled point in my life so knowing how helpful it was for me to see someone in a position of power be open about and comfortable with their sexuality, I can only imagine how impactful this must be for any student who is closeted or questioning.
We cannot be what we cannot see is a relevant sentiment here; the more non-heterosexual people we see, in all professions and across all areas of life, who are simply living their lives, the less alone we in the community feel and the more normal it becomes for everyone.
Carly is a very open person in general and this helps to foster a more open and welcoming space for everyone; she comes across as authentically her and this gives students permission to bring their full, authentic selves to the course.” – Sara
Finally coming out at work has meant that I have now been able to support people from the LGBTQIA community in the way I have always wanted to, I have ensured that my students include their pronouns on their e-mail sign off, I joined the LGBTQIA staff forum, as part of my involvement here I alerted the forum to non-inclusive recruitment materials and as a result of me raising this all the recruitment materials have now be updated to be inclusive to all genders.
The chair of the forum Dr Andrew, said of my involvement, ‘It’s been great having Carly Jim join our Forum – another great voice actively helping us all to get an overview of how equality, diversity and inclusion operate across the university, and pointing to aspects where we can do better.’
Another forum member Dr Jayne also said the following “Visibility is critical – oppression operates through silencing and shutting down marginalised people’s experiences and so bi-visibility is an essential tool in addressing this.
Within LGBT+ communities as well as non-LGBT+ communities, biphobia is present and so it has been brilliant to have Carly challenging this so beautifully by being part of the Forum. I am sure that most people learn to address their own prejudices and misunderstandings through knowing people and understanding their experiences, so we really need LGBT+ people (and others of course) to be visible and be themselves – you never know how powerful that might be or the impact that it might have on others.”
Since the start of this academic year Charlotte’s tweet about ‘visibility’ has been at the forefront of my mind and I have actively sort out opportunities to be visible with my students. I have actively elected to supervise students studying LGBTQIA topics.
At one of the meetings of BiPhoria, when I described my journey with work, one of the people at the meeting said how important it was for me to be visible as it shows other bisexual people that it is possible to be bisexual and get a PhD. Honestly this had never occurred to me before, but I realised in that moment just how important my visibility was to my students, and how I never had any bisexual role models when I was at University.
As Dr Leanne says, “for me, representation and visibility are important to foster a sense of belonging and feel connected. Feedback from students has been really positive, that our openness as staff has given them space and confidence to be there authentic selves. Witnessing the relief, gratitude and mixture of emotion that students experience when they realise / learn there are LGBTQIA staff reinforces the importance”.
If there was even the tiniest shred of lingering doubt in my mind as to whether I made the right decision to be openly bisexual with my students this academic year, these two testimonials from students absolutely attest to the fact that it was the right decision, and I am not embarrassed to say I was rather emotional reading them.
Dr Carly Jim (she/her) is a Senior Lecturer in Psychology at Manchester Metropolitan University, she is co-programme lead of the MSC/PGDip Psychology (Conversion) programme.
