Gallup have done some fresh research on the numbers of LGBT people in the USA. They’ve gone beyond the traditional “one in ten” type numbers to give some fascinating breakdown by when people were born.
The resulting generational numbers are fascinating reflections of the impact of attitudes in the wider world as each generation came of age.
For the pre-Boomer population, the numbers are very low. But then people who came of age around or following the Stonewall riot and arrival in the American public eye of the gay rights movement in 1969 show a tripling in the levels of gay and lesbian identity.
Curiously though, this has no equivalent impact on bi numbers.
Generation X, who came of age around the time Nirvana were hitting the charts, are where the bis start to catch up.
Thereafter, for the generations that grew up with the access to the internet that has helped challenge both bi isolation and the “pick a side” narratives – it’s a bi landslide, with the bis outnumbering gay and lesbian people of ohe order of three to one.
When we also look at how much people have felt able to own trans or other binary-busting gender identities, that internet generation again sees a huge breakthrough.
In the space of thirty years trans numbers leap from 0.2% to 1.8% of Americans. With L, G, B and T in turn we see the impact of awareness and freedom to own your identity. Once the information and the freedom to find support and advice is out there, everything changes.
And so we get to see the iterative story of what some fear as a “sudden onset” of change as the world has leapt from black-and-white to full colour in waves, acknowledging in turn the LG, the B and then the T.
Gallup’s polling shows LGBT self-identity is growing – and bis are growing in number especially fast – but not that there are any more of us than before.
But it also puts the lie to the myth being spread by the anti-LGBT “Alliance” online that lesbians are becoming extinct. Numbers of gay and lesbian people aren’t falling away, it’s just there is faster growth in the proportion identifying as B and T than there is growth of L and G. Going from 0.2% to 1.4% is no ‘extinction’.
The majority of people responding to the survey identify as bi – and amongst young people the figures are especially interesting.
Curiously the number of void responses has also grown. Are these people consciously identifying instead as pan or asexual perhaps? Or are more people now averse to answering this question?
LGBT Straight No opinion
% % %
Generation Z (born 97-2002) 15.9 78.9 5.2
Millennials (b 1981-1996) 9.1 82.7 8.1
Generation X (b 1965-1980) 3.8 88.6 7.6
Baby boomers (b 1946-1964) 2.0 91.1 6.9
Traditionalists (b pre 1946) 1.3 89.9 8.9
It’s good to see how bisexuals are the largest group: the previous best figures we had from the USA were from the Williamson Institute which found 52% of LGB people were bi; this survey shows a figure 2.4% higher.
More than half of LGBT adults (54.6%) in this report identify as bisexual. About a quarter (24.5%) say they are gay, with 11.7% identifying as lesbian and 11.3% as transgender. It would be good to have a bi gender breakdown.
3.3% volunteer another non-heterosexual preference or term to describe their sexual orientation, such as queer or same-gender-loving. Respondents can give multiple responses when describing their sexual identification; thus, the totals exceed 100%.
Gallup note: “The vast majority of Generation Z adults who identify as LGBT — 72% — say they are bisexual. Thus, 11.5% of all Gen Z adults in the U.S. say they are bisexual, with about 2% each identifying as gay, lesbian or transgender.
“About half of millennials (those aged 24 to 39 in 2020) who identify as LGBT say they are bisexual. In older age groups, expressed bisexual preference is not significantly more common than expressed gay or lesbian preference.”
Americans’ Self-Identified Sexual Orientation, by generation
Label Bi Gay Lesbian Trans Other Generation Z 11.5 2.1 1.4 1.8 0.4 Millennials 5.1 2.0 0.8 1.2 0.4 Generation X 1.8 1.2 0.7 0.2 0.1 Baby boomers 0.3 1.2 0.4 0.2 0.0 Traditionalists 0.3 0.3 0.2 0.3 0.1
The second table’s opening figure of 11.5% is one in nine of all young people – as it covers bis of many genders we should measure it against the combined gay and lesbian tally of 3.5% which is closer to one in thirty.
The last substantial equivalent numbers from a polling company in the UK are now more than five years old and it looks like the situation is fast changing as young people come of age – we want an update!
In the latest Journal of Homosexuality, “Mental Health of Lesbian, Bisexual, and Other-Identified Parents and Non-Parents from a Population-Based Study” presents findings where Assink, Rothblum et al looked at the experiences of “sexual minority” women with and without children.
Those with children are more likely to be bi and in relationships with men – which figures. On average, kids just happen more easily that way.
More interestingly the bi women show higher levels of psychological distress than the lesbians, and lower rates of feeling happy or satisfied with their lives.
This couples with a lesser sense of connection to the LGBT community for the bi respondents. It looks like we are internalising the biphobia and homophobia from both sides and living with the effects of exclusion from queer communities over past decades. It makes sense; it’s just good to have some research showing it.
A little nugget of Dutch research next: after 20 years of same-sex marriage there, Statistics Netherlands looked at marriage and divorce rates.
In that time 19,000 men and 21,000 women have married someone of the same sex. After a short surge in the first couple of years during which there were noticeably more men marrying than women, it has stabilised at a rate of about 650 weddings of men, and 700 of women, per year.
However the rates of divorce in that time have been much more uneven – the rates of divorce within the first decade of marriage seem to be:
M-M: 14%
F-M: 16%
F-F 26%
They don’t look at why that should be but it’s a fascinating skew.
Over to the Journal of Bisexuality, and “Outness, Discrimination, and Depressive Symptoms Among Bi + Women: The Roles of Partner Gender and Sexual Identity” from Hall, Feinstein and colleagues. This looked at the impact on bi women of who they are dating and that person’s sexual orientation. This looked at 608 people in the US and analysed by “outness” and experience of discrimination.
Interestingly gender and sexuality mattered – those dating lesbians were more likely to be out than those dating other bi women. Single women were less likely to be out than either – but more likely than those dating men. Dating a bi man improved your chances of being out.
On the flip side as well as being more likely to be out there was a similar pattern of experiencing discrimination. Dating lesbians seems to do more to alleviate depression; it’s surprising dating other bis does not have as strong an effect but perhaps both wrestling biphobia has impacts through a lack of support in society or from organisations. Clearly further research required!
