LGBT representation in video games is something I had never thought about, despite trying to get all my Sims to make out! I was curious to see it as a topic in upcoming LGBT History Month talks, and got in touch with Sacha Coward to find out more.
How did you get into it as a topic?
I am a museum worker, escape room designer and queer historian. I got into museum work because as a nerdy kid who loved museums I never felt they loved me back: there were never notable people quite like me. As I grew up, I realised that there weren’t representations of the kinds of relationships I wanted to have on display. So I made it my life’s work to try and tell the stories that exist in the gaps in history, the missing links and the unsung queer voices. This has lead me to many weird places, I have become quite the boffin on mermaid folklore and cemeteries… but that’s another story!
As a kid I grew up playing videogames, just like museums they were a world I was inherently drawn to and still am. But like museums, I realised that they were never designed with me in mind. Any LGBTQ+ gamer will have a similar experience. Games are designed largely with a white cis male perspective and you see this in the protagonists, they character development and marketing of nearly all mainstream games. Also the community and vocal fanbase can become an echo changer of largely cis heterosexual voices and can be an incredibly homophobic, transphobic and racist environment.
But I still love this world, as do millions of queer videogame players and it for those people that I chose to explore this topic for LGBT History Month 2020. Videogames are an art form, every bit as much as a painting or a piece of music, it’s high time we start celebrating the stories of the queer characters, games and game makers in the story of videogames.
Where does LGBT representation in games begin?
Well many argue where the story of where queer video games begin but I will be starting my story with the Super Mario Brothers 2 character of Birdo in 1986. This bright pink dinosaur character is an enemy and could easily be overlooked but is a great way to start talking about the often highly problematic way gender identity and sexuality has been treated in videogames. In the Japanese manual for the game Birdo is a character who ‘thinks he is a girl’. The trans identity of this character is purely for comedic effect, to make a ridiculous sounding enemy. When this was localised in the West even this gender fluidity was erased and Birdo was created as a cis female character who is in a heterosexual relationship with Yoshi! (In my job I find myself discussing the gender identity of fictional dinosaurs with surprising passion)
As ridiculous as this all may be it sets the tone for early LGBTQ+ representations in games as whole: they were usually the bad guys/girls, usually clownish and even then the ‘queer’ nature of characters would often be watered down depending on where the game would be released. Birdo is now, for some, reclaimed as a trans icon.
We have come a long way in a short time, but still the Birdo trope still exists in games today!
What does bi+ representation look like particularly? Where and when did that start?
Bisexual and pansexual videogame characters exist on a number of platforms. Going all the way back to 1986 the game Moonmist had a character called Vivien Pentreath who is described as ‘a female artist who is also a criminal was jealous about her girlfriend marrying a man’ her identity as a lesbian or bisexual is never otherwise mentioned and she is also a villain. The role of bisexual women in games in the 80’s and 90’s can largely be seen to fall into two categories: Overtly sexualised objects designed for a straight male gaze and/or psychopathic and evil villanesses with a ‘kink’.
This reflects many of the beliefs at the time about queer people in society. Bisexuality, rather than being truly explored, was often used to pander to male heterosexuality resulting in shallow and ill-defined caricatures. Male bisexuality is much more rarely explored until later on in games, apparently to appease a presumed straight male audience.
Around the mid to late 90’s games where you could create your own protagonist and make choices began to develop. The likes of The Sims, Fable and Mass Effect franchises would use a model where your character’s sexuality and gender was up to you, making all protagonists potentially pansexual. That being said, this was based on the player’s choices and not directly written or platformed by the game creators, although the options for these relationships were intentionally left open.
It is not really until the late 90’s and early 2000’s that we starts seeing fully fleshed out bisexual and pan characters, particularly in RPG titles such as the likes of Dragon Age Inquisition, Fallout and Skyrim which have arguably led the way with queer characters.
Are there platforms or game types that especially pioneered LGBT inclusion and bi representation?
RPG’s, aka Roleplaying Games have been at the forefront of queer representation in videogames. Partly because they have an opportunity to tell deep and lengthy stories. RPG’s also are known for having a more diverse and queer audience. That being said the Horror and Suspense genre such as ‘The Last Of Us’ have some fantastic queer lead characters and fighting games have some of the earliest example of Trans characters (Although some of these were to get around the fear of encouraging violence against women, making them trans to make it ‘ok’, so how empowering this is really varies from game to game!)
Has this prompted the kind of LGBTphobic backlash we sadly see in the real world? How have gamers and games companies responded to that?
One incredibly successful gaming franchise with a queer lead character is ‘The Last Of Us’, a survival horror game with a Gay or Bisexual main character, Ellie. Her story has been well fleshed out, with a same sex kiss as part of a moving and powerful backstory. That being said whilst the majority laud this series and its well written characters there has been backlash: Some straight players have even taken to writing about how Ellie is in fact straight but confused, or complained about the kiss being unnecessary or vulgar. This is exactly the same kind of erasure that you see in museums, art galleries and history lectures but happening in videogame internet forums!
Also as with school corridors online gaming can be littered with homophobic, transphobic and mysogynistic language. Gaming online is still largely policed and ‘owned’ by straight men.
As with representations of women and people of colour, the increasing presence of queer characters in games is seen by a small (but highly vocal) minority of straight male and largely white western gamers as a devolution of their world and an incursion on worlds and franchises that they see as their territory. That being said, many of the most loved games of all time ‘Ocarina Of Time’ and ‘Final Fantasy’ all feature incidental characters with queer leanings who are loved by many fans of all backgrounds.
It’s also worth being positive and looking at the future of gaming and young people’s evolving understanding of gender and sexuality. The transgender youth support charity Mermaids UK recently received an incredible amount of support from the youtuber and Twitch gamer Hbomberguy raising $160,000 from his young gamer fanbase for them whilst playing Donkey Kong on a livestream!
If someone were starting out gaming now, what games would you recommend for seeing ourselves as bi and queer people in current videogames?
A great start is a classic, ‘Zelda Ocarina Of Time’. I would particularly focus on the character of Princess Zelda who has an awesome androgynous alter-ego. I would then suggest ‘The Last Of Us’, with the characters of Ellie and Bill who are well rounded and complex characters with queer identities. For a great trans character I would seek out Dragon Age inquisition with the character of Krem who is a trans man; whilst this is explored in his story it is also an incidental trait and not defining of his character.
Away from mainstream blockbusters I would google and explore indie queer games of which there are many, for example ‘Dream Daddy’ and ‘Life Is Strange’ both of which have since reached cult status!
Sacha’s talk is on at the Bolton, Liverpool, Bedford and Brighton LGBT History Month hubs.
This article originally appeared in the February 2020 edition of Bi Community News (issue 159).
You can read more from that edition of the magazine here.
To get the latest BCN content subscribe to have it delivered direct to your door all through the year.
