In the House of Lords, Lord Scriven challenged the government yesterday to outline “what progress they have made in implementing the recommendations of the Independent Chief Inspector of Borders and Immigration in the report, An investigation into the Home Office’s Handling of Asylum Claims Made on the Grounds of Sexual Orientation, March to June 2014.”

For the government, Baroness Williams declared that, “the UK is a world leader in handling asylum claims based on sexual orientation. In its response, the Government accepted all eight recommendations from the independent chief inspector’s report, either entirely—seven—or partially—one. They have since implemented them all accordingly as part of their drive to continually improve.”

Scriven focused in, asking “The UK is the only country in the EU that detains indefinitely those seeking asylum on sexual orientation grounds. Therefore, will the Government commit to implementing the Yogyakarta principle plus 10, on the application of international human rights law in relation to sexual orientation and gender identity, with particular reference to ending the detention of LGBTI asylum seekers?”

The minister argued that, “I can make it absolutely clear here today that we do not detain asylum seekers indefinitely.” Indefinitely is perhaps a malleable word here. At some point, efforts are usually made to either permit asylum seekers to remain here or they are deported.

Lord Kennedy interjected, noting “Can I ask the noble Baroness about the Home Office guidance issued in 2017? I have seen reports suggesting that gay asylum seekers could be returned to Afghanistan if they pretended they were straight. Surely this cannot be the case. We must work to a much higher standard, and the question of personal safety should be paramount in decisions given by the authorities.”

Reports suggest that this goes even moreso for those who identify as bisexual.

Baroness Barker moved the discussion on and highlighted a recent embarassment for the government on asylum numbers: “oes the Minister understand that some of us are greatly concerned when her department has to ask charities and voluntary organisations to tell it how many LGBT people it has in detention? Could her department commit to producing better statistics on these people, who, after all, are often detained with the very people from whom they are fleeing persecution?”

The minister admitted that, “we would like to get to a stage where the statistics we produce are robust.”