The anniversary of Section 28 being scrapped came up at my local bi meet the other week. A fistful of older queers suddenly found a room full of people – young and old – asking what even was that?
It’s a fabulous reflection of how far we have come. For me it was entwined so much in the story of coming out at the end of the 80s, let alone the story of so much campaigning and awareness raising in the bi and gay commercial and community scenes.
Cue some education, and reflection on how we have come quite some way and yet there is still so much to do.
Section 28 as it would be best known, Section 2A as it more strictly became once law, and “the clause” in popular parlance at the time it was going through parliament, was an amendment to the 1986 Local Government Act, which said:
Prohibition on promoting homosexuality by teaching or by publishing material.
(1) The following section shall be inserted after section 2 of the Local Government Act 1986 (prohibition of political publicity)—
“2A Prohibition on promoting homosexuality by teaching or by publishing material.
(1) A local authority shall not—
(a) intentionally promote homosexuality or publish material with the intention of promoting homosexuality;
(b) promote the teaching in any maintained school of the acceptability of homosexuality as a pretended family relationship.
(2) Nothing in subsection (1) above shall be taken to prohibit the doing of anything for the purpose of treating or preventing the spread of disease.
(3) In any proceedings in connection with the application of this section a court shall draw such inferences as to the intention of the local authority as may reasonably be drawn from the evidence before it.
(4) In subsection (1)(b) above “maintained school” means,—
(a) in England and Wales, a county school, voluntary school, nursery school or special school, within the meaning of the Education Act 1944; and
(b) in Scotland, a public school, nursery school or special school, within the meaning of the Education (Scotland) Act 1980.”
(2) This section shall come into force at the end of the period of two months beginning with the day on which this Act is passed.
It was a vague law – how exactly do you promote homosexuality? After all, heterosexuality was being promoted in almost every billboard and magazine advert of the time and yet hundreds of thousands of kids were still growing up queer. What is a pretended family relationship and how does it differ from an actual one?
I remember hearing a Conservative parliamentary candidate defend it to an LGBT audience claiming that as it was so poorly worded it didn’t mean anything. Therefore it couldn’t be homophobic in effect and so did no harm. Fair play, if you’re going to lie, make it a big one.
Actually the looseness of the language meant that it could be argued to prevent anything homophobes in positions of power wanted to stop happening. I saw it used to block information for schoolkids who wanted to know their human rights, to bar newspapers appearing in libraries, and to silence those who wanted to support people struggling with their gender or sexuality. Even where there was support for gay people, it was used as an excuse to defend biphobia (along the lines of, “section 28 means we can’t give help or recognition to bi people, as that would encourage straight people to become gay”).
It was law for 12 years in Scotland, until it was abolished as one of the conditions from the Lib Dems for going into a coalition government at Holyrood. It took three more years to be scrapped in England, when eventually an MP was able to slip its repeal into a bill as an amendment. Thus its repeal received Royal Assent on 18 November 2003, in a short clause that simply read:
Repeal of prohibition on promotion of homosexuality
Section 2A of the Local Government Act 1986 (c. 10) (local authorities prohibited from promoting homosexuality) ceases to have effect.
However it cast a long shadow: just as there was scant little support for queer kids prior to its introduction in AIDS-hysteria 80s, the day it was dropped did not bring an immediate change. The curriculum didn’t change, attitudes of LGBTphobic teachers went unchallenged, there was just less chance of legal action for those who wanted to proactively help queer kids.
Being in school as a queer kid in the time of Section 28 was awful and unsupported; since 2003 it’s become more of a postcode lottery, with some schools very inclusive and engaged in tackling biphobia, transphobia and homophobia whilst others earnestly avoid giving that kind of support.
What’s changed outside schools is important too. Back then if you were lucky you might find a copy of Young Gay And Proud in a bookshop: a supportive guide for young queers that nonetheless only mentioned bisexuality fleetingly, explaining: “a bisexual person is someone who is equally attracted to people of either sex”. That balancing on a pinhead definition doesn’t suit many people – the slightest preference reducing you to “gay really” or “straight really”, reinforcing the pressure on bis to deny who they are in the pursuit of an imaginary “normal”. Another coming out guide from a gay youth project in the 1990s explained, “some people are gay, some people are straight, and others are confused about their sexuality and call themselves bisexual while they work out who they are really attracted to”. But now that equivalent search for help is cast so much wider. Tumblr, twitter, facebook, instagram or even proper web pages offer a plethora of information about bisexuality and being bi – and some of it’s pretty accurate. The internet has transformed access to information for all and bi teens pretty much all have it in their pocket.
Yet while Section 28 seems safely dispatched here, at least for now, places like Russia are eagerly working on their own – and blocking information online so people who need support can’t work around the limitations in their own country.
The best comment on the clause I’ve seen this week was Baroness Barker, observing in the House of Lords debate for IDAHOBIT that it was the UK offering a pioneering template of homophobic legislation that other countries were still eagerly taking up and implementing around the world. Because Section 28 was an innovative idea: rather than simply making expressions of same-sex love illegal, the clause sought to extend that to even admitting that such things existed. Eloquently summarised by V for Vendetta writer Alan Moore at the time as a bid to make homosexuality a thought crime, it may be gone in the UK but laws inspired by it are on the rise in many nations and we need to fight them as we fought it, both for the people there and lest these ideas cross back into our own country.
We have won some freedoms: we have to be vigilant if we are not to lose them.
