You can hardly open a paper this month without being faced with a review of Marjorie Garber’s new book on bisexuality, Vice Versa. For our own view, see the bisexual book review special, but for a quick round up of what others think of it, let’s start with George Melly in The Guardian. He loves Garber, calling bi-invisibility a “calumny” which “places an artificial limit on our erotic choice”. Ten out of ten – but a pity he didn’t notice that it’s bisexual, not bi-sexual.
The Evening Standard’s Syrie Johnson is largely pro-bisexual too, although quick to point out that she disagrees with Garber’s clam that “adult fantasies” reveal bisexual components in the otherwise het or homo. Why ? It still seems as if “the bisexual” is safe as long as s/he is a separate species , but rather less welcome when it starts to get closer to home.
Roger Clarke in The Independent ? Another approver, but one who remains puzzled: “what people have always found baffling about bisexuality is that there appears to be no disgust in it; the sexual organs of each sex are equally attractive”. I can’t actually see what is particularly baffling about that. It’s rather more baffling that anyone should think they aren’t. I’m a little disturbed though by Clarke’s implication that for bisexuals the sexual organs of anyone of any sex are equally attractive – why don’t you and your baffled frinds come round to my house and drop your trousers sometime Roger, and I’ll show you some bisexual disgust.
A more thoughtful dissenting voice was Roz Kaveney in New Statesman and Society. Taking issue with Garber’s casual assumption that anyone who has sex with both men and women is a fully fledged bisexual, Kaveney calls her “enough of a innocent to think that no-one ever felt compelled to grit their teeth – for the sake of survival or cash – and go through with acts they did not desire”. Although this looks like the start of a more rigorous analysis of what bisexuality is and isn’t, Kaveney is quick to leap to make excuses to cover up the prejudices of lesbians and gay men, criticising Garber for “equating ‘biphobia’ with the homophobia of a society that, unlike that of lesbians and gay men, can make its bigotry stick.” I’m glad to hear that lesbians and gay men can’t make bigotry stick – I guess it means that when Unison’s lesbian and gay group officially threw us out last month, we just need to ignore it and it will disappear.
It’s also been the month for Sex Surveys. The News of the World tells us that “a quarter of girls have loving relationships with other girls”. As one bi woman has it: “I reach orgasm quicker with girls and it’s great to have a chat at the same time”. And bisexual men ? Strangely absent from the whole discussion. It couldn’t be that the whole thing is just a staged turn on for heterosexual male readers could it ? The very thought ….
Over in The Independent on Sunday the news is rather less exciting (no big surprises there). Their “sexual outlaw rating” gives bisexuality “6/10 and falling” , noting that “bisexuals themselves proudly assert a distinct identity” making this category “one to watch”. As for the statistics, well “only 1 per cent of our respondents defined themselves as bisexual; but then 13 per cent didn’t define themselves as anything.” Is that meant to suggest that the two are synonymous ?
Jo Eadie
