Bi-sex and the law
Recent events have brought Parliamentary queerness into the public eye. Tony N. looks at the way our laws affect us.
How we live our lives is often dictated by the laws of the land. Attempts to legislate our sexual behaviour cause many problems, especially for those whose sexualities deviate from the norm of the majority. Of course laws in books cannot change the ways that people behave, but they are indicative of society’s attitudes.
There are no specific anti-bisexual laws, but there are oppressive laws concerning gay sex. Since the new Labour government took power just over a year ago there has been a great deal more interest in changing the laws which compromise our lives, and things are beginning to move. Many gay and bisexual people hope to see an end to discriminatory laws which make same sex relationships a poor cousin of opposite sex relationships, and impose limitations on our sex lives.
The major legal issue of the last year concerning bisexual men is the age of consent. We are all still reeling from shock at the House of Lords decision to reject equality even though on 22 June the democratically elected House of Commons backed MP Ann Keen’s proposal to amend the Crime and Disorder Bill to bring the age of consent for gay sex between men in line with the age for straight and lesbian sex, voting in favour by a huge majority of 207.
Nevertheless, as a result the government have promised a reduction to sixteen, and many people believe it is pretty much inevitable. This is partly because the European Court has told us that we have to change it, seeing as Britain is the only European country to have deliberately introduced a discriminatory age of consent in modern times. Every other country (except Austria) has brought in equal ages, applying to all people. The ridiculous situation means that gay sex is legal at sixteen if you are a woman, but eighteen if you are a man. Also, the famous Wolfenden report of 1957 that led to the decriminalisation of gay sex was interestingly in favour of sixteen. The report says:
“Our medical witnesses were unanimously of the view that the main sexual pattern is laid down in the early years of life and the majority of them held that it was usually fixed in the main outline by the age of sixteen. Many held that it was fixed much earlier.”
The reason that twenty-one was originally chosen as the gay age of consent instead of sixteen is that it was in line with the age of majority of the time.
The law is supposed to protect us, but in reality many young gay and bisexual men needed protecting from these laws. They not only make criminals of men who would not have been breaking the law with women of the same age, but also of the younger partners who would be seen as victims if they were underage women.
If you stop to consider the implications of our age of consent laws for a young, bisexual man it is worrying. He can legally have sex with a woman, but not with a man. At this formative stage of his life he is being given a message that the gay side of his sexuality is somehow not as good, or in fact is dangerous and something he needs to be shielded from. This is not a recipe for balanced people who are happy with their own sexual identity. There is a confused mythology that a bisexual can make a choice between gay and straight and this lead to confused young bisexuals who try to deny their ‘unacceptable’ gay side. What young people really need is to learn how to be happy and confident about who they are. Changing the law is only one step.
Of course an unequal age of consent means that a man over eighteen having sex with a man aged sixteen or seventeen is liable to prosecution, when there is nothing illegal about the heterosexual equivalent. This was one of the key grounds for prosecution in the case of the Bolton 7, one of whom was seventeen and a half. This high profile case which came to a head earlier this year is particularly relevant to the bisexual community, as at least three of the men charged are bisexual. Ł500,000 was wasted on this ‘victimless crime’, which many believe should never have been pursued. There was great public outrage from the local community in Bolton, the UK as a whole and many other countries. There was much press attention, most of it in sympathy with the seven men; The Observer organised a special campaign. Amnesty International also became involved and vowed to take on the case if the men were imprisoned. MPs spoke out, saying that the law needed to be changed and the church also became involved; the bishops of Edinburgh and Worcester wrote to the judge assigned to the trial asking him not to send the men to prison.
In spite of the outcry, the way that the judge, Michael Lever QC, behaved is more than worrying. When it came to the bisexual men he showed a serious lack of understanding of their sexuality which actually seemed to count against them as they were subjected to moral judgements. Judge Lever quite obviously frowned upon their sexuality and wanted to take punitive measures against it. While orgies are not illegal per se, the Bolton 7’s was, because it involved gay sex which was not ‘in private’ (i.e. only two people). He described the group sex that the seven had had as ‘morally repugnant’ and the young bisexual men were called ‘very immature young people, not very intelligent, virtually all from deprived backgrounds’ and ‘little more than smutty-minded schoolboys tipsily experimenting with sex.’ All the comments are very telling, as Judge Lever seems to equate their actions with immaturity; perhaps that phase which we are all supposed to grow out of… As for the rest of the comments they are thinly disguised insult, especially the reference to their working class status, which is really irrelevant. But that was not the worst, he went on to comment on the significance of the fact that three of the men now had girlfriends. This made things worse as his conclusion was that this meant they could not be really gay and therefore certainly had no place to have sex with other men. In other words, it wasn’t as though they couldn’t help themselves. It is horrifying to think that the judge has so little understanding of human sexuality as to not be able to entertain the thought that some of these men are bisexual.
Anne Keen said: ‘The purpose of the criminal law should not be to put police into bedrooms, nor to coerce men to be heterosexual.’ We will not be free to have the sex lives we choose until more MPs come round to her way of thinking. A nanny state that dictates what people may do in bed will always lead to problems as one group tries to enforce its agenda onto another. It is important that the legal system realises the damage that these discriminatory laws do to society. Vast sums of money are wasted on pointless prosecutions. There is a blatant inequality in the way that people are prosecuted, with a gay element meaning that sentences are longer. As bisexuals the law discourages us from having gay and lesbian sex, and ultimately from embracing our own identities and becoming comfortable with ourselves. However, the journey towards the end of all discriminatory anti-gay laws is well on the way. Not only is society changing to be more accepting, but also queer people are changing to be more assertive in their demands for equality, privacy and the right to have sex with whoever they want.
Tony N
