I am very concerned that a part of our community is openly discriminating against people on the grounds of their sexual orientation.

I have strong views on all discrimination and I think we need to debate whether we want our community, or those who represent it, to go in this direction. I am referring to Bisexual Action on Sexual Health’s policy of positive discrimination in employing the Peer Education Project Worker. Initially, offering a job working with bisexuals to another bisexual might seem like a good idea, but I would like you to consider the following points.

I agree that there is a need to redress previous discrimination and oppression, however I believe that the correct way to do this is by “positive action” – not by further discrimination.

‘Positive Action’ allows redress by giving the discriminated group (bisexuals) the chance to catch up. In practice this works, for example, by interviewing all bisexual applicants, by offering aditional training to a bisexual in recognition of previous difficulty in getting that training (perhaps a lesbian or gay phoneline wouldn’t take bisexuals, so you would acknowledge the difficulty in gaining counselling experience, rather than exluding them from the job).

On the other hand, positive discrimination would include setting quotas (eg operating an apartheid system) or excluding other groups of people purely because they belong to a ‘wrong’ group and not accounting for their ability to do the job.

Curent legislation on race and gender – not sexual orientation, as some gay men’s health projects are implying- allows for ‘genuine occupational qualification’. This allows men to work with men, Black people to work with Black people etc, if it is inherent in the nature of the work.

It was suggested by BASH that, as this was a peer project, then the worker ought to be bisexual. This appears to be based on the assumption that someone who identifies as bisexual will have an affinity with other bisexuals that will give the project or training a credibility that it would otherwise lack.

This is a ridiculous notion: Bicon and many local groups are open to bisexuals, partners, friends and allies, and all these people can (and do) take part in bisexual politics, policy making, community development, workshops and training without having to identify their sexual orientation at all, never mind having to be bisexual !

We have a background of judging ideas on their merit, and of listening to people because of what they say. This openness allows us to draw on the richness and diversity of those connected to our community – do we want to change that now ? Do you want to be part of a community that discriminates ?

BASH assumes that the differences of gender (including life history, sexual experience etc) or of fluid sexuality are less important than sexual identity. They have implied that bisexuality overcomes all other differences. I don’t believe that we have enough in common solely through sexuality: one man may be misogynist and only have relationships with women, while recognising his occasional desire for men; another man may only have relationships with men but identify as bisexual as a political choice. Both are bisexual – but that is all they have in common.

Because the bi community allows such a broad definition of bisexuality, it becomes too broad to be identified as a point of shared experience. Knowing that my educator or trainer is bisexual tells me nothing about them as a person, nor how ‘sound’ their beliefs are – and these are the values that I hold as important. I have no problem with a lesbian or gay man explaining safer sex to me – I will judge them on what they say, not who they are!

What BASH’s policy means in practice is that someone who is the most skilled to do the job but calls themselves “Queer” doesn’t even get an interview – even if they are emotionally and behaviourally bisexual. Is that fair ?

I believe that BASH were asked what would happen if the worker changed their sexual identity and the reply was that it would be dealt with if that situation arose. Given the original employment conditions, to do anything but dismiss the worker would be totally inappropriate. (I also suspect that a Tribunal would find BASH’s employment practice illegal, so the worker would be OK for compensation).

That BASH are unable (or unwilling) to talk explicitly about their policy in public, suggests that it has not been thoroughly thought out, or that they do not believe that they can justify it. I strongly oppose the views of BASH’s management committee, and I would ask ask you all to think about the consequences of accepting discrimination into our community. If you think this is wrong, write and let BASH know. Also, send me your name and address and I will form a petition requesting that BASH adopts a comprehensive Equal Opportunities policy that will not allow discrimination, and is clear about positive action for bisexuals.

Tim Sallis

- -- --- -- -
The way forward for any community is to acknowledge its differences.
So we will offer a right to reply to anyone mentioned in these pages.
When Tim wrote critising an espect of BASH, we felt in was our job to get a reply.
- -- --- -- -

Pride, Not Prejudice

(or Why Tim is Well-Intentioned, But Wrong)
The diversity of the bisexual community is one of its best points. I love the way we don’t ask about people’s sexuality before letting them join in. This response is to show why we were right to ask that question in this one instance.

First, let me say who “we” are. The decisions on the shape of the BASH Peer Education Project (PEP) were taken by three people: myself, Mike Hartley (the person who actually signed the contract with the funders, Red Hot AIDS) and, at the start, Roberta Wedge. Blame or praise should head in our direction, not that of BASH as a whole or the person who was appointed.

From the start, we were agreed that the selection would be on an equal opportunities basis. For one thing, I expected we would already know most of the people who would apply for the job and it was obviously important not to let our pre-existing knowledge get in the way of appointing the best person. The mechanisms we came up with for short-listing, interviewing and selecting were better than any I’ve seen anywhere else, including the ones most ‘equal ops’ organisations use.

Tim’s objection is that one of the required elements was that the person be able to say, in response to being asked, “I’m bisexual”. This is an issue all three of us agreed on from the start. Having decided that, not being upfront about it would have been dishonest, as well as wasting time and resources of applicants (and us!) in making applications that would never have been successful. So we put it in the “person specification”, the list of qualities we were looking for, and in the ads that went to Bifrost, all the bi groups and The Pink Paper. (For cost reasons, the ad in The Guardian was too short to include it.)

The reasons behind the decision come down to ownership and practicality. This is explictly a project aimed at self-identified bisexual people. (It’s one of the reasons we got the money – no-one else is doing this!) Yes, it would be possible to find someone who wasn’t bisexual and train them in the issues that affect us, but we didn’t have the time or money to do that. In any case, the evidence shows that it wouldn’t work. The experience of similar projects working with, eg gay men and the visible minority communities, shows this categorically. Positively Women (the organisation for HIV+ women) doesn’t need to justify to its target group its policy of appointing women to certain posts, to give just one example. They know that people listen to people like them: their peers.

Just think of another great health issue, smoking. (Smoking kills more bisexuals than AIDS!) It’s clear that young people start smoking, despite knowing the dangers, because their friends do. Attempts to preach at them to stop doesn’t work, as the advice is seen as coming from “outside” their lives.

Equally, there are dozens of gay men’s projects littering the country with leaflets and other information on HIV. How many bisexual groups have actually used them? From what I can see, just one or two at most. Why is this? Is it because bisexuals don’t care about HIV? Or is it because such projects typically only mention topics like bisexuality on their funding applications, not on their materials, and because their coverage of issues such as sex with women is at best minimal?

it needs to be a visibly bisexual project
So, practically, if the project is to have a chance of succeeding, it needs to be a visibly bisexual project. It’s a small project, the first of its kind within our community. The lone project worker is the public face of the project to the community and the rest of the world, so they need, we believe, to be bisexual.

It was also a political decision. An outsider might ask why should the bisexual community need a newsletter like this. Isn’t the existence of the Pink, which believes it has ever so comprehensive news and listing columns, enough? No, it isn’t. The community needs the newsletter because we need a paper owned by and for bisexuals. We know the newsletter isn’t going to leave out the “b-word” at every opportunity. In short, we know we can trust the newsletter in the way we can’t trust the Pink. In fact, the newsletter is a sign to us and the outside world that here is a community – one with the ability to establish and support an information resource.

If you look elsewhere in this issue you’ll see that Tim wants to promote a specifically bisexual body within Outright Scotland. Why? It already does excellent political work on issues around sexual orientation. Could it be because Tim thinks that a group whose decisions are “owned” by bisexuals would be more attractive to other bisexual people as well as being an important statement that we’re here, we’re queer – and we’re capable?

Organisations within the community, like the phone lines, are not treated as ‘serious’ by others working in the field. (This translates as: we don’t have the same level of funding, the reason for that being we’re not ‘serious’- Catch-22.) Had a non-bisexual been appointed, the same people would have pooh-poohed the community even more: “They can’t even find someone bisexual to organise it”. Instead, the BASH Peer Education Project has had an effect within the HIV field way beyond its size and budget. It’s helped make bisexuality visible and is helping make it respected. So another reason behind the decision was to make a statement about the abilities of the bisexual community and our capability to do important work.

I feel Tim is in a small minority here and recent history suggests we were right. A few years ago, Lisa Power addressed two Bicons as a “keynote speaker”. Now, Lisa is a wonderful person and a great friend of the community, but some people complained at her being invited to speak in such a way, because she insists on identifying as a lesbian. “Couldn’t the organisers find a bisexual?” they asked. How would the same people have responded if we gave the first significant grant money the community has ever received to a gay man, a lesbian or a straight person?

It is not true to say that BASH is unable or unwilling to talk about this issue. I ran a workshop at Bicon 13 explicitly on this and the other points raised by the history of the project. Unfortunately Tim couldn’t attend, but we did meet for a brief time to talk about his concerns. (Incidentally, no-one who was at the workshop shared his views.)

He asked the question about what we would do if the worker decided to change their sexual identity midway through the year. It’s an interesting philosophical point. But, just as we did not insist on them “proving” their bisexuality by sleeping with a woman and a man in front of the interview panel, we trust that if the worker thought that they could not do the job as specified, they would resign. In any case, I’m assured that the likelihood of it happening is nil.

Of course if we were appointing, say, a typist (if only we had the money!) then we would not specify that they be bisexual. Had there been no suitable bisexual applicants for the Project Worker job, we would have (a) been very surprised and (b) reconsidered the entire project, not just this decision.

BASH is helping make bisexuality visible and respected
As far as the legality of this goes, alas, it is absolutely legal to discriminate on the basis of sexual orientation. (I speak as someone who’s suffered from this.) In fact, the crucial case established that it was legally ok to say, “I’m not prejudiced, but other people might be, so you’re fired”! If you don’t like this – and I’d be surprised if any readers do – then complain to your MP. Yet even if this were changed tomorrow, there would be some exceptions and I expect that this job would probably fall within one.

Personally, I’m much more concerned that we gave The Pink Paper money for an ad, given their appalling record on reporting bisexuals, bisexuality or the community.

Ian Walters