If you’re one of the 937 bi women who contributed to the 2007 Stonewall Women’s Health Survey, the world now knows the truth about your mental health data. The bi women completing this survey reported much worse mental health than the lesbian survey respondents1 – a previously suppressed fact – and this news has gone global and received a huge response. Here’s how it happened.

I was able to get my hands on the Stonewall Women’s Health Survey data because I was doing an MSc dissertation and my supervisor’s research organisation (Sigma Research, part of London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine (LSHTM)) had done the original survey analysis. I wanted to compare mental health in bi women versus lesbian women. Stonewall didn’t want me to do it – they refused permission to access the data, but luckily Sigma talked them round on my behalf. I’d been angry when Stonewall’s original report of the survey data lumped bi women in with lesbian women during analysis, and then referred to the combined group as ‘lesbian women’ when reporting results – so here was my chance to improve things.
When my analysis was finished, my supervisor, Dr Ford Hickson (surely the world’s most bi-supportive gay man), saw the importance of the findings and encouraged me to publish, offered to be senior author, and patiently supported me through endless rewrites. We submitted to four journals, and finally got lucky when the UK-based Journal of Public Health accepted our paper for publication.

We wanted to wring every ounce of bi-positive publicity out of the paper, so we asked LSHTM’s media office to put out a press release – wonderfully, they agreed.

Well. The paper was published on 14th January 2015.2 And the response was pretty staggering.

The press release got 123 million hits3, via more than 50 news websites across the UK, USA, Canada, Australia, France, Sweden, India, Indonesia and Hong Kong. I couldn’t calculate total hits on the journal article itself, but according to Altmetric (which monitors online activity for academic research) the paper had the most online activity of any article ever published in the Journal of Public Health, and was in the top 1% of all academic papers they’d ever monitored4 for online activity. Lots of hits on the actual paper itself was especially good news because, amazingly, the journal publishers had agreed to make the paper ‘open access’ for free (meaning anyone could download the full content of the paper, not just the abstract; normally authors pay a lot for this); this meant that everyone could access important background research about bi people’s mental health and community activism, facts which were included in the body of the paper but couldn’t fit into the abstract.

And our paper got on TV! The US talk show host Rosie O’Donnell mentioned it on her show, whilst interviewing Glee actress Naya Rivera, who responded to news of poor mental health in bi women by saying “perhaps that’s why I’m so crazy”, which prompted a flurry of online ‘did she just come out as bi?’ type comments. Fame at last!

Publication wasn’t without its down-sides, the worst being the *expletive* Daily Mail’s initial online story, which contained not one but two horrendous, biphobic misquotes. I was able to get the first one changed (no, bisexual women do not have worse mental health than “women in same-sex relationships”!), but tricky semantics meant that the second misquote (implying that bi women were to blame for their poor mental health as they often don’t disclose their sexuality) couldn’t be tackled in time. (I’d run the press release past a few seasoned bi activists, pre-publication, who warned about the possibility of biphobic media responses if low rates of identity disclosure were mentioned – I’d thought a wording tweak would sort things out – it didn’t. Should’ve scrapped that bit.)

Since publication, I’ve had several great opportunities to formally present the research – at BiReCon, at LSHTM’s LGBT research seminar, to colleagues at two Local Authorities, within LGBT History Month (two attendees – poo!), at the 2015 Faculty of Public Health conference (on the main stage of the Newcastle Sage Gateshead – yay!), at the London Bi Visibility Day event and (as a poster) at the inaugural Public Health England LGBT health conference. It’s been good to get the word out about poor mental health amongst bi women – and (probably more importantly) just to present bi women as real people who are worth respect, support and appropriate health care.

It was also great to have the press release covered in Bi Community News, with a salient critique of how this kind of research could progress.

So, if you yourself have a chance to do bi-supportive research, go for it! If there’s outside expertise available, use it. But also make the most of the huge amount of research and advocacy experience in the UK bi community. I was so lucky to receive feedback from more experienced bi activists, whose input was invaluable (you know who you are – thank you, you lovely people). Thanks too to Stonewall for doing the original survey and (eventually) allowing me to analyse their data.

But the biggest thanks of all has to go to all the people who took time to respond to the original 2007 survey, to report often distressing stuff – they are the real heroes of this story. Their voices and painful experiences need to be heard and acted on.

Lisa Colledge

Footnotes
1 The 937 bisexual-identified women responding to the survey were two-thirds (64%) more likely to report eating disorders, one-third (37%) more likely to report self-harm, one-quarter (26%) more likely to report depressed feelings and one-fifth (20%) more likely to report anxiety, compared with the 4769 lesbian-identified respondents (after adjusting for relevant confounding differences between the two groups).
2 Poorer mental health in UK bisexual women than lesbians: evidence from the UK 2007 Stonewall Women’s Health Survey. Lisa Colledge, Ford Hickson, David Reid, Peter Weatherburn. Journal of Public Health 2015; doi: 10.1093/pubmed/fdu105.
http://jpubhealth.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/reprint/fdu105?ijkey=WVf8BccNSfrln9M&keytype=ref
3 The initial media report counted 195 million hits in total, but closer inspection revealed that the Daily Mail seems to double-count its hits just the teensiest bit.
4 Altmetric had been operating for 3 years in January 2015.