The Court of Justice of the European Union has ruled that by adopting a law which stigmatises and marginalises LGBTI+ people, Hungary has acted in breach of EU law.
The Court for the first time in an action brought against a Member State, declared an infringement of Article 2 TEU, the document which lists the values on which the European Union is founded.
Its summary judgement was that “By ‘Law No LXXIX of 2021 laying down stricter measures in respect of persons convicted of paedophilia and amending certain laws adopted in the interests of the protection of children’, Hungary has amended various national legislative acts with a view to protecting children.
“In essence, those amendments prohibit or restrict access to content, including in the audiovisual or advertising sectors, which portrays or promotes deviation from the self-identity corresponding to the sex assigned at birth, gender reassignment, or homosexuality.
“Following an action for failure to fulfil obligations brought by the European Commission in that regard, the Court of Justice finds that Hungary has acted in breach of EU law on a number of separate levels: the primary and secondary law relating to services in the internal market, the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, Article 2 TEU and the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).”
It notes Hungary’s defence that “those amendments are […] intended to protect minors” but rejected this pretence finding “several of them have the effect, in essence, of prohibiting or restricting access to content having as a defining element the portrayal or promotion of deviation from the self-identity corresponding to the sex assigned at birth, of gender reassignment, or of homosexuality.”
It further found the country’s legal approach “reveals a preference for certain identities and sexual orientations to the detriment of others, which are stigmatised as a result, which is incompatible with the requirements flowing, in a society in which pluralism prevails, from the prohibition on discrimination based on sex or sexual orientation.”
The ruling should overturn laws established by the recently-defeated government of Victor Orban, which was voted out this month after 16 years in power. The opposition coalition took 140 of the 199 seats in Parliament. The change of government to a more European-facing rather than Putin-following stance makes such a change more likely.
