American stock exchange indexing monitor the Nasdaq (a historic name that once meant “National Association of Securities Dealers Automated Quotations”) has been rebuffed in a bid to inform investors about the diversity of company boards.
The proposal would have meant firms listed on the Nasdaq’s index providing basic stats on their boards’ balance of race, gender and sexual orientation, and encouraged – though not compelled – them to do better if there was none.
This does open up questions particular for bi and other LGBT people in senior positions in firms – but moreso about their employers and industries as to whether being out is career-limiting. Research has shown bi people are on average less well-paid than their straight and gay colleagues.
However an appeals court yesterday ruled publishing such statistics to be a step too far, arguing it is “not unethical for a company to decline to disclose information about the racial, gender, and LGTBQ+ characteristics of its directors“.The ruling added that the proposal “saddles companies with an obligation to explain why their boards do not meet Nasdaq’s preferred diversity criteria”.
The decision was by a narrow 9 votes to 8 margin in a Republican-controlled court.
The Securities and Exchange Commission said it will review the policy following the ruling. Nasdaq said they would not appeal the ruling, but that they “maintain that the rule simplified and standardised disclosure requirements to the benefit of both corporates and investors”.
The ruling may seem peculiar as no change in practice would have been forced on any of the companies involved. Any which lacked even a tokenistic level of diversity on their boards would merely have to come up with an explanation as to why.
The proposal was neutral on what is mislabelled “wokeness” by proponents of a return to 1930s values: it was perfectly plausible that in action it might show firms with non-diverse boards to perform better on the stock market than the rest.
However that level of exposure was deemed too embarassing and the effort of coming up with a couple of lines of text outlining the culture of a corporation too taxing.
