As a young fat woman, it was feminist, then lesbian feminist material, then work by American, separatist lesbians, that provided me with the most radical and interesting understanding of what my body meant.

Then, like now, there were so few places where being fat was not a joke or a horror story. Writers like Elana Dykewomon and contributors to journals such as Sinister Wisdom gave me the only alternative to the mainstream. Even now, as I feel a great distance from these ideologies, my interest in fat has more to do with pollitics and identity than just trying to find nice clothes to fit me. That’s thanks to those women.

Aberystwyth Is Hell Misspelt

When I was 18 I spent three years at university in Aberystwyth – geographically and socially isolated. Some of my friends were rural, separatist dykes. I was involved with two overlapping scenes for women and lesbians/gay men, and radical, lesbian feminism was the dominant perspective.

In fact, it was seen as the only perspective. Anyone who disagreed was ostracised and diminished. Although some parts of me (like my big mouth, my interest in politics, being fat and punky) were acceptable in these communities, my bisexuality was always very unwelcome.

The biphobia I experienced through radical, lesbian feminism, separatism, and the people I met at college, impacted on me terribly and it has taken years to deal with the shame of my ‘awkward’ sexuality, my doubts, and feelings of invalidation that were fostered during this time.

For Lesbians Only, For Fun

Given my background, this is what I do for entertainment: I take a trip to my local library and take out ‘For Lesbians Only: A Separatist Anthology’, ed. Sarah Lucia Hoagland and Julia Penelope (1988, London, Onlywomen Press).

Finding peace with myself has meant breaking some old rules without fear. It’s not just their attitudes to bisexuality I like to sneer at, it’s their whole stupid way of looking at the world.

These women see themselves as feisty warriors against the global patriarchy. To me they’re a small pocket of arrogant twits, who reckon that true lesbians are of a higher social order.

Shit, Fear & Guilt

Some contributors are dismayed that: ‘Many lesbians tolerate being lumped together with such people as gay men, fetishists, transvestities, transsexuals, bisexuals, sado-masochists, necrophiliacs, scatologists, pederasts, those who practice bestiality and others.’ (Alice, Gordon, Debbie 8 Mary, p.392)

Some of my best friends are scatologists, but I guess these women aren’t celebrating sexual diversity, they’re just naming their enemies, andit’s like this group are the worst possible deviants they can imagine. Heh, I’m glad I’m amongst them.

Adding paranoia to the mix; Liza Cowan (p.225) who comments:

“‘I have developed a standard way to act with men when I first meet them. I rarely smile, I am on my guard and make sure they are aware that I will not put up with any nonsense’

Now add a sprinkling of guilt, tied up in knots with PC, leading one of the white editors to apologise for her racism because she used the word ‘dark’ in a negative context. Go beat yourself up for it Julia, shame on you!

You might think my idea of fun is a little perverse and nasty. And I admit I do go to town. I even read out some bits to Simon the ultimate betrayal, ‘cos although he’s transgendered an although he could argue the point, to the authors he’s not woman-born-woman, and he could have XY instead of XX chromosomes, yikes!

‘For Lesbians Only’ is so earnest, and it’s funny, like the bitch butch, Valerie Solanas-style anger. Contributors have name like ‘killa man’! Cool! I’m laughing and appaled simultaneously.

It’s like Betty Rose Dudley said on an e-mail list I’m on:

‘If I didn’t laugh I would be propelled off the face of this planet by the force of my own scream.’

It feels deliciously naughty ridiculing this stuff, like an ex Catholic sticking out their tongue at the cross. The power and potency these ideologies had scared me and I’m glad those times have passed.

All The Rage Again

Except they evidently haven’t. With ‘All the Rage: Reasserting Radical Lesbian Feminism’ ed. Lynne Harne and Elaine Mille (1996, London, The Women’s Press) the smile has frozen on my face. What a shame this book was commissioned, what an anachronism. Apparently you can write any old crap and get it published if you package it correctly with footnotes, academic references and further reading lists.

I have misgivings about drawing any attention to this work, hope that if I ignore it then it’ll die away quietly, but I am one pissed-off woman and I’m not going to shut up.

Judging by the way this anthology deals with SM, it appears that radical lesbian feminists have not lost their old ways.

Sarah writes off a whole community by asserting arrogantly:

‘They [women SMers] weren’t offering anything interesting or radical but were just doing what the men were doing. It was the same old shit.’ (Sarah, quoted by Lynne Harne, p.238) neither has their paranoia been tempered. Helen refers to the pro-sex media conspiracy:

‘The media, including the gay media, is controlled by money and the people who’ve got money are the ones who are pro SM and pro porn so it’s a complete stitch-up.’ (Helen, quoted by Lynne Harne, p.234)

Well, living on the dole doesn’t stop this queer girl from being kinky and smutty, and hasn’t Helen ever read one of those ubiquitous ‘£10 Dungeon’ articles?

I’m also relieved that radical lesbian feminists have not relinquished their grip on ignorance:

‘Of course feminists object to SM because it is offensive to Jewish people and Black people in its use of master/slave routines and Nazi regalia. But we also object to all SM because it is a mockery of violence against women.’ (Sandra McNeill, p. 56-57)

These arguments are so cliched they read like a script. Have the authors read anything written by SMers? Have they done any research? Have they spoken to anyone who might throw light on their perspective by having a different opinion? If not, why not? Is it that they choose to ignore what they can’t engage with?

Simon wanted to read what they said about transgender stuff, but this was completely absent, something we found bizarre considering debates about gender have serious implications for radical lesbian feminists. What is the value of suppressing what you don’t want to understand? No fucking value at all.

Humour? No Thanks

Before I depress you with the biphobic content in ‘All the Rage’, let me tell you about the anthology’s highlights. Like the unintentional humour that runs through it like an old friend.

When I lived under the reign of the radical, feminist separatists, I swore I would never betray them by suggesting they were humourless. But it’s true, the critics are right, they are. Check out this critique of the character Mo in ‘Dykes To Watch Out For’, it’s like the writer is describing herself:

‘She is presented as a very unsympathetic character, who “whines”, is self-obsessed, and lectures and rants all the time.

She is also unfashionable, confused in her politics, unable to get a lover or keep one for very long (the implication being that it is because of her “negative politics”), humourless, uptight and prudish.’ (Elaine Hutton, p. 156)

Also, reading this book, I found myself cheering the people the contributors have quoted negatively, like Camille Paglia:

‘You [don’t] understand the degree to which this absolutely sex-phobic, crazed, Moonie feminism has taken over the women studies programs. I’m so happy I do not have any of these amateurish, incompetent, resentful, angry women trifling with my brain.’ (Sue Wilkinson, p. 76)

But the best part of ‘All the Rage’ was the little quiz where extracts from some of Serious Pleasure’s girl-on-girl porn — sorry, erotica — were juxtaposed with extracts from Penthouse.

Welcome relief, I jerked off to the excellent smut selected by Carol Reeves (founder member of Lesbians Against Sado- Masochism) and Rachel Wingfield (ex-coordinator of the Campaign Against Pornography). And even though I wasn’t supposed to be able to do so, because they’re all part of the same misogynist plot, I could tell the difference between them.

(Hint: I’m sure they exist, but I’ve just never met a woman who calls her clitoris ‘clitty’ except in straight porn).

Bisexuals Are Bastards, Apparently

I am amazed at how this book actively promotes misinformation, and Sue Wilkinson’s article ‘Bisexuality as Backlash’ will be of particular interest to BCN readers. This is easily the worst piece of bi-hating shite I’ve ever read, and it’s not like I’ve been sheltered from it. Just about all the stereotypes are here:

Bisexuality is a media fad generated by articles about lipstick lesbianism; Bi women don’t exist, we are just ri.terosex al, weekend lesbians, or bad-girl lesbians who fuck men because we hate women and — gasp — objectify the phallus! (Given a choice, I’d rather worship some penis than promote lies and ignorance any day.) Oh, and when lesbians have sex with men, there can be no other connection apart from getting off.

But wait, that’s not all: Bisexuality is hedonistic and irresponsible; lesbians are not at risk of exposure to HIV/AIDS; and bi women make treacherous lovers.

Wilkinson is a university lecturer and author of several books — she’s someone who should know better and it horrifies me that her crap could be taken seriously by anyone.

This is a vile piece of work, the last gasp of a dying, hate-filled ideological empire.

i’m not afraid of the ignorant, arrogant paranoiacs of radical lesbian feminism, and I’m not going to be deferent to them any more. I’ve spotted who’s wearing the Emperor’s New Clothes, and I’m not alone.

Charlotte Cooper