Finding Your Root
One of the well worn stereotypes about gay men is they have ‘overbearing mothers and distant fathers’. There are also notions that the relative lengths of your fingers reveal your sexual orientation, or that it’s all about how much estrogen and testosterone you are exposed to in the womb.
“Parental Income and the Sexual Behavior (sic) of Their Adult Children” (Manning, Fink & Trivers) in the journal Evolutionary Psychology tried to look at this beyond the well-worn cliche. It takes the findings of a BBC survey from 2005 and looks at sexuality in relation to parental income.
And it finds a small pattern, but a pattern. Splitting up some 255,116 responses to a survey into income quartiles of parents, children of parents with higher incomes are marginally less likely to be bisexual, or gay / lesbian.
So it would look like the reason someone is queer is less about their parent’s child-raising behaviours, and more about their parents’ employers’ decisions about who to give that raise and who to skip over for promotion. It’s not your fault I’m queer, mum, it’s the fault of your area manager.
There are a couple of obvious problems with this research.
First, the sample – self-selecting and across a variety of countries, mostly the UK and USA, without being broken down to look at individual national profiles or how respondents compare to the demographics of their country.
Second, it’s from 2005. The past two decades have seen significant social change – mostly for the better – on bi and gay rights, representation and social acceptance. In 2005 as the survey was being run the third and fourth countries to do so were in the middle of legalising same-sex marriage (Spain and Canada). Today with 34 countries having same-sex marriage, and those including the two biggest sources of respondents for the survey, things may well have changed.
It’s not just about who we are, it’s who we think we might be allowed to be. And that has changed.
Counts and Frequencies of Male and Female Participants’
Sexual Orientation from Parents of by income groupParental Income Lowest 25% Low 25% Higher 25% Top 25%
Heterosexual Males 10,686 (88.8%) 36,778 (89.8%) 49,332 (90.8%) 8762 (90.6%)
Females 8021 (87.6%) 31,991 (89.9%) 41,905 (91.2%) 4705 (89.6%)
Homosexual Males 731 (6.1%) 2306 (5.6%) 2669 (4.9%) 510 (5.3%)
Females 306 (3.3%) 1068 (3.0%) 1176 (2.6%) 154 (2.9%)
Bisexual Males 615 (5.1%) 1865 (4.5%) 2270 (4.2%) 399 (4.1%)
Females 834 (9.1%) 2522 (7.1%) 2895 (6.3%) 395 (7.5%)
Total
Males 12,032 40,940 54,261 9671
Females 9161 45,581 45,976 5254
Investor Bias
We’ve known for some time about the LGBT pay gap – by which bisexual people earn significantly less than their lesbian, gay and straight colleagues.
It looks like it extends even to the stock market, from a report in the October edition of Research in International Business and Finance.
Researchers Shanaev, Skorochodova and Vasenin find that the stock markets under-value shares in companies led by LGBT CEOs.
They look at 26 firms publicly listed with out LGBT bosses – and find their company valuations run at about 0.7% to 1% below where they would be expected to sit.
The report opens with its aim “to address (a) literature gap and investigates the performance of an exhaustive sample of United States and global stocks led by openly gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender chief executives in 2000–2021.”
Immediately it hits a problem with statistics here: “there has only been 26 of such firms to date”.
USA: the 26 openly LGBT CEOs by business area
Sector Observed Expected
Communication Services 5 1.19
Consumer Discretionary 7 3.60
Consumer Staples 1 1.99
Energy 1 1.00
Financials 1 3.77
Health Care 6 2.02
Industrials 1 4.39
Information Technology 2 2.72
Materials 1 3.39
Real Estate 1 1.37
Utilities 0 0.55
Suggesting an investment “rainbow cliff” they go on to propose an LGBT stocks portfolio: “As the number of LGBT CEO stocks globally has been close or above ten since at least 2014, it suggests that an ethical fund investing exclusively in such companies is in principle implementable and would even be satisfactorily diversified.”
As the report was concluded in August for publication in October, there is perhaps already just such a portfolio to buy into by now.One fascinating chart (above) looks at where those 26 firms lie by business sector.
It feels like an interim report as the authors reflect that while they have found a small statistical gap, “the fundamental performance of LGBT CEO firms can be studied when a larger sample becomes available.” With more LGBT CEOs the regional and country-by-country variations in such bias might be seen. For now, there just aren’t enough of them to know more.
Underemployed
In 2021, 3.5% of the population reported being unemployed on census day. That included 3.3% of respondents who identified as straight, and 4.9% of gays and lesbians.
But among bis that figure is 7.8%
For ‘other’ labels – pansexual, asexual etc – 7.1% report being unemployed.
Some of this is likely due to the age variations in unemployment, given people from younger age groups are much more likely to report identifying as bi.
