In the bi community we tend to pride ourselves on our attitude to safer sex, and dismiss stories about bis spreading disease as prejudiced stereotyping. So we were concerned to receive an ABC News press release titled “Bisexual women acting as a bridge spreading sexually-transmitted infections to lesbian partners”, mentioning their “drug-injecting risky behaviour…”. True? Or exaggerated to make science into big news?
The original paper was published in Sexually Transmitted Diseases, studying women attending a Sydney STI clinic from 1991-98. Every woman admitting having ever had sex with a woman (WSW) was analysed. This is the largest ever study of WSWs, and avoids problems of similar studies which relied on women self-identifying as lesbian. However it has limitations: the researchers only analysed clinic records and never met the women, so we don’t know why they went to that clinic rather than a GP, or whether they identified as lesbian, bi or straight.
About 15% of attendees had had sex with a woman, giving 14000 WSWs to study. Ideally researchers would study women who had never had sex with a man, to look at whether certain diseases can be transmitted from woman to woman. This paper shows why they don’t: only 7% of WSWs had never had sex with a man, i.e. only 100 ‘true’ lesbians from nearly 10 years of data. Instead they defined ‘exclusive’ WSWs as women who had not had sex with a man for at least a year, a quarter of WSWs. Unsurprisingly, results for ‘exclusive’ WSWs were similar to WSWs.
Dykes and Disease
So how did WSWs compare to non-WSWs? More WSWs had bacterial vaginosis (an often symptomless, curable infection that can lead to infertility) and a history of genital warts, but rates of chlamydia, hepatitis C and HIV were similar to non-WSWs. WSWs had had sex with more men on average than non-WSWs (12 v 6) and were more likely to have had sex with over 50 men, been involved in sex work, injected drugs or had sex with a man who had, and to have had sex with “a homosexual or bisexual man”. These are considered ‘risky’ behaviors and are what the press release were referring to. But given the similar infection rates, it looks like WSWs are practising safer sex better than the exclusively heterosexual women or exclusive WSWs, if they can get away with more sex but no more disease.
The survey doesn’t ask about safe sex practice. We also don’t know about other problems such as mental health, although there was data on smoking and drinking: WSWs and non-WSWs were similar, but ‘exclusive’ WSWs were more likely to be heavy (more than 20 a day) smokers.
The STI editorial by Jeanne Marrazzo discussed this article, referring to almost all the other papers on the subject.. Of WSW “in San Francisco, 40% reported unprotected vaginal or anal sex with men during the past 3 years, including men who had sex with men and male IDU.” She doesn’t say how many heterosexual women have unsafe sex. It is women who already have HIV, not necessarily bisexuals, who she calls a “bridge” to other women. We still don’t know which comes first: are bisexuals more likely to inject drugs (and indulge in other risky behaviour) or are drug users more likely to have sex with other women? Without studying why these women have sex with women we can’t answer this. Mazarro also mentions other health issues relating to WSWs – “WSW probably do not receive Papanicolaou smear screening according to recommended guidelines; whether this relates to erroneous beliefs about about personal risk for HPV and cervical cancer, or because providers do not appropriately screen WSW, is not known.”, and points out what bis have known all along – just because women identify as lesbian does not mean they don’t have sex with men or are at lower risk of disease.
Conclusions
For the first time, BV has been seen to be passed on by woman-woman contact. Studies on WSW sex practices are needed to show how. Sexual health of WSWs is fairly similar to non-WSWs, but more studies on mental health would be appreciated. Like all STI studies, it boils down to the obvious: have sex with someone and you run the risk of catching something. Even if they aren’t either a Bad Bisexual or a Dyke in Denial, however truthful they think they are, infections don’t care.
Hester Tidcombe
1. Fethers K, Marks C, Mindel A, et al. Sexually transmitted infections and risk behaviours in women who have sex with women. Sex Transm Inf 2000;76:345-9.
2. Marrazzo JM, Handsfield HH. Characteristics of female sexually transmitted disease clinic clients reporting same-sex behavior, 1993-1997 Int J STD AIDS (in press)
Condoms News
A study at City University has cast doubt on the advice to use only ‘extra strong’ condoms for anal sex. Nearly three hundred male couples were randomly given either nine ordinary or nine extra strong condoms and asked to report back on breakages and other problems. It found absolutely no difference between the two sorts.
The study, condemned by bigot Baroness Young in the House of Lords as ‘enticing innocent young men in sodimitical practices’, discovered that lubrication is far more important. Condoms were eight times more likely to break if no additional lube was used. Even using oil-based lube, which weakens rubber, was better than none at all or saliva alone. Using any lube inside the condom made it more likely to slip off.
Another study, this time based in Africa, has found that using nonoxynol-9 significantly increased the chances of HIV transmission, probably because of the irritation it can cause.
So if you’re having safer anal sex, use a BS kitemarked condom without spermicide, use lots of water-based lube, both on the outside of the condom and in and around their anus. If it’s a long fuck — the research talks about more than 45 minutes — have a pause and use a new condom with more lube.
Have fun…
Ian Watters
