Over the summer, Labour unveiled their plans to give some of the rights traditionally reserved for married couples to same-sex couples.

But the Government’s proposals for “civil partnerships” have come under attack from both sides. There has been a predictable decrying from self-styled upholders of family values on the one hand, and on the other hand from Outrage and others who have argued that the restriction of civil partnerships to same-sex couples and marriage to mixed-sex couples perpetuates discrimination.

Below, BCN regular Poppy gives her considered response. And BCN’s VoxBiPops team tell us what they think of it in easy soundbites.

Civil Partnerships
An open letter to the Civil Partnerships and Sexual Orientation Team, Women and Equality Unit, DTI

Dear Civil Partnership team

I agree with the sentiments that have prompted the government to devise this proposal. I agree that it is not acceptable that ordinary loving partnerships are invisible and unrecognised.

The sentiment is right and to be welcomed. However, the whole proposal is founded, it seems to me, on two misconceptions that will come to haunt this process:

1) that gay and bisexual people will be content with this separate-class registration, which will move those wishing to avail themselves of legal recognition into the ghetto walls of a scheme that has yet to be named. Those gay and bisexual people calling for equality will rightly balk at the single, sweeping dismissal in the document that “it is a matter of public record that the government has no plans to introduce same-sex marriage”, and the insistence that this scheme will be confined to same-sex couples. What is presented here is a legal Bantustan that will never be seen to be on a par with marriage. Why has the government set its face against marriage for all couples who seek it? It smacks to me of a contemptible concession to the religious lobby that rejects loving relationships outside certain highly-confined boundaries, despite its “doctrine of love”. What can conceding to the bigotry and hypocrisy of the religious stance be called?
2) that coupledom is the only loving partnership deserving of these rights. It is misconceived to imagine that calls for a broadening of the rights to register can be staved off by this scheme. If society can be strengthened by legally recognised loving partnerships, as your document states, then why confine it to two people in an implicitly sexual union? The logic, and your own credo as stated in the document to “show that we really value the diversity of the society we live in” would surely call for this scheme to be open to any number of people in relationships that it is up to them to determine who wish to live by rules not traditionally sanctioned by Judaeo-Christian religion.

I think that “civil registration” and “registered partner” are hateful terms. I would suggest in all earnestness: “marriage”, and “spouse”. If that is what we mean that is what we should say. If it is not, what is it?

Yours
Poppy

Vox BiPop

BCN asked the bisexual in the street what they thought of civil partnerships…

“if they say yay and it gives same-sex couples all the same rights as hetero couples then yes yes yes yes. If not then it’s just a half arsed token: it’s about who you choose to spend your life with, not what’s between their legs.” Cat, Sheffield

“Whilst there are huge flaws in the scheme, for too long the rights of long term same-sex couples have been brushed under the carpet. It’s not how I’d ideally like it, but it’s definitely better than what we’ve got.” Lanei, London

“It’s a great step in the right direction, but it will never be a church sanctioned event like marriage – and therefore never have real equality with a hetero partnership” Jules, Stockport

“I’m just hoping they’ll have sorted out all that crap and given queers the right to real marriage before I start thinking about getting married myself” Edi, London