When straight people think we’re straight and gay people assume we’re gay, should we be out on the streets shouting for Bisexual rights?
`Oppression’ became a buzz-word among sexual minority movements as early as the 1960s: the GLF, lesbian feminism, and 1980s identity politics all saw themselves as movements of oppressed people.
Bisexual politics too grappled with the notion of `oppression’ in the 1980s. Bi Monthly was full of agonising over questions of oppression – who was oppressed, how much, by whom, whether bisexuals were doubly or only half oppressed…
Since the 1980s `oppression’ has become an indispensable political accessory, a badge of credibility: as if we can only take ourselves seriously, or expect others to do so, if we can prove we are `oppressed’. Every minority identity becomes an `oppressed’ identity, and every social disadvantage an `oppression’.
So well-fed, white, middle-class bisexuals cry `oppression’ when non-bisexuals assume they must have a partner of each sex. Bisexual men at porn screenings call it `oppression’ when their gay male partners don’t acknowledge their interest in male-female porn scenes. (I haven’t invented these: they come from recent bi publications. You can have hours of fun looking for other examples in all your favourite bi books.) I’m not denying that these and similar experiences are upsetting, unpleasant, inconvenient and may cause real distress. But there’s a difference between being distressed and being oppressed. Not everything bad that happens is oppression.
Before this becomes a `bisexual-politics-is-crap’ tirade let me clarify two things. First, I don’t think this use of `oppression’ is peculiar to bi communities (a straight woman once seriously told me that Christian feminists were oppressed `just as much as lesbians’). Second, this is not how bi politics today conducts itself. Although it’s not uncommon to hear bisexuals using the notion of `oppression’ – particularly when being told by hostile others that not only are we not oppressed but we don’t face any kind of disadvantage at all (and/or don’t exist anyway) – there seems to have been a gradual shift since the 1980s in the way bi communities think about power and how it operates.
From Bi Monthly through Bifrost to BCN, there’s a definite move away from notions of `oppression’ towards a different understanding of power: a view of power not as a simple one-way relationship between `oppressors’ and `oppressed’, but as something more diffuse which permeates our lives.
This is clearest in bi politics’ increasing concern with `visibility’ since the mid-1990s: the recognition of bisexuals as really existing, and of bisexuality as an identity in its own right. `Visibility’ is the commonest theme to appear in Bifrost and BCN, and the regular `media-watch’ columns monitoring bi visibility in gay and straight media in both publications are only the most obvious example of this concern. When BCN was founded, the editorial collective’s own description of its goals (BCN Issue 5) included nothing about `oppression’ – the word didn’t appear – but it did say `we want to be able to increase bisexual visibility’. As one Bifrost contributor put it in 1994 (Bifrost no. 31): `Much is made of bisexual `invisibility’… It’s becoming clear that it’s high time we did a little more to make our presence seen … What’s needed is a bit of visiBIlity’.
Again, I should make it clear that I don’t think this only happens in bi politics. New ways of thinking about power are also coming to the fore in queer politics – especially in queer theory – and the idea that power is all-pervasive and `the personal is political’ is directly inherited from second-wave feminism. But there are particular reasons why this change might be more significant – or more noticeable – in bi politics.
First, bi politics in the UK had its beginnings in anti-sexist men’s politics (the London Bi Group grew out of an anti-sexist men’s group), so right from the outset many bi activists found the idea of distinct groups of `oppressors’ and `oppressed’ problematic, since many anti-sexist men have argued that men as well as women suffer under patriarchy. Second, many bisexuals in the 1980s (and still today) regard themselves as `oppressed’ by other `oppressed’ groups, specifically lesbians and gay men. These two features of early bi politics together produce a sense that few, if any, members of society are not subjected to power somehow: in other words, power is everywhere and affects everybody, even those who are (or appear to be) `the oppressors’.
Obviously I am not suggesting that bi politics is neither interested in nor directly active against `oppressor’ power such as Operation Spanner, the Criminal Justice Act, or rights for same-sex lovers. Nor do I think this new way of thinking about power relations will automatically make bi politics more effective: white bi politics in the 1990s seems no better at tackling racism, for example, than in the 1980s, as the silence over Jackie Hunt’s BCN article last year attests (BCN Issue 7).
I’m much more ambivalent about this shift than I seem. But it does seem to me to have been a change in bi political thinking which hasn’t been discussed.
Where it’ll take us remains to be seen.
Merl Storr
