Bisexual Characters in Film: from Anais to Zee
Wayne M. Bryant (Harrington Park Press, $17.95)
Even though it weighs in at only 160 pages, this will surely establish itself as the definitive bi film reference book. From little-known silent films of the 1920s, through to concealed bisexual characters or brief bisexual subplots, there is hardly any instance of bisexuality on the big screen that Bryant has not referenced.
Bryant gives us an extremely revealing account of life under censorship (explicit and implicit) in Hollywood, and the ways in which this has forced films dealing with bisexuality either to obscure it, or to render it unwelcome. Just reading his chapter-headings makes a formidable collection of familiar stereotypes: victims, murderers, unfaithful husbands, promiscuous swingers. The book also takes the broadest possible view of what counts as a bisexual element in a film and, in being so comprehensive, it flies through the films at an alarming rate. And that I found incredibly frustrating. A brief paragraph, or less, delivers a plot summary, sometimes followed by a sentence of judgement (‘the allegorical meaning of all this is quite complex’). What I would have liked to have seen was a book which, while recognising this level of prejudice, is willing to discuss how that has been treated by different films. But Bryant seems too devoted to accumulating evidence for his prosecution of Hollywood to think about how diverse and ambivalent a body of material he has accumulated. Hence his silence about the various moves that bisexuals have made to reclaim Basic Instinct as a camp classic with an OTT, but essentially sexy and powerful, bisexual protagonist.
This concern to document injustice leads to the claim that ‘just as the victims of totalitarian oppression, for reasons of self-preservation or self-hatred, have aided in the genocide of their own people’ so too … some bisexual directors have made films with stereotyped bisexual characters. I’m not sure that holocaust analogies are ever a good idea – but if ever there was a misjudged comparison, it is surely this. What makes biphobia interesting to study is precisely the fact that it has not lead to anything that we could call planned genocide – it is a far more invidious and complicated set of attitudes than that kind of analysis suggests. Yes, it is true that cinema has regurgitated an unbearable stream of Bad Bisexuals, but we need to do more than assemble films into a list of the PC and the non-PC. Firstly, this underestimates the extent to which we have made films belong to us, whether they were intentionally bisexual, or positive, or not, and secondly it assumes that we all know what makes a Good Bisexual Film: and I just don’t believe that any of us does.
For instance, it is often unclear what criteria Bryant is using for his judgements. Two films that go out of their way to be bipositive, Savage Nights and Together Alone (which are positive almost to the point of being preachy), get bad marks because their male bisexual characters have unsafe sex. Doesn’t it matter that these films go to such lengths to encourage us to understand why they do so? And to empathize with the difficulties of the process of making that decision? What is sorely missing from Bryant is any sense that bisexual people might disagree about what these films mean – or that we might interpret them in our own ways. Bryant seems to regard Positive Images as those that appeal to conservative middle-America. He can thus lament: ‘we are still waiting for a film with the kind of well-adjusted, openly bisexual couple that one often meets at bisexual conferences’. Leaving aside the fact that so many of the films that he loathes seem to be fairly good depictions of much of the conference crowd, just whose idea of ‘well-adjusted’ is being promoted here?
I certainly don’t want to ignore the value of collecting so much reference material in this way, and this reallly is one of those books that has something of interest in it for every bisexual. But for this bisexual at least, it doesn’t leave me with any clearer sense of the role that film has played in the construction of what bisexuality means than I had when I read through the chapter titles.
Jo Eadie
The Bisexual Imaginary: representation, identity and desire
ed. Bi Academic Intervention, London: Cassell, 1997
ISBN 0 304 33745 5 (pbk)
Have you ever been frustrated by academic writings on sexuality which either ignore bisexuality or relegate it to the odd footnote? The Bisexual Imaginary attempts to fill those telling gaps. The subject matter ranges across several disciplines, including literary theory, psychology and ‘queer studies’. It’s not an easy read, and I would suggest that anyone baffled by academic jargon should start with the editors’ roundtable discussion in Part 4, which picks up on the main themes of the book.
I found that many of the pieces articulated vague thoughts I’d had for a long time but never been able to pin down, particularly Mariam Fraser’s ‘Lose Your Face’ which analyses the way in which the identity of bisexual women is represented as ‘inauthentic’, and Ann Kaloski’s ‘Returning to the Lesbian Bildungsroman’ on the depiction of the bisexual woman in the context of lesbian coming-out fiction. I was less enthralled by the bisexual readings of Shakespeare, Whitman and Ginsberg, but found the ‘Visual Cultures’ section intriguing – just how do you represent bisexuality visually? Is there a ‘bisexual gaze’?
Another concept central to the book is that the meaning of ‘bisexuality’ which has been constructed by the modern-day bisexual community is not the only one – the term ‘bisexuality’ carries a number of different meanings and we have to take into account the historical weight of those meanings in order to develop a bisexual theoretical perspective.
There is a maturity and thoughtfulness in this collection which marks the beginning of a shift away from the defensive position of ‘all the myths about bisexuals are untrue and we’re wonderful people really’ and towards a more critical analysis of some of the bisexual community’s cherished articles of faith, such as the emphasis on ‘diversity’. To me this is a welcome sign that we are starting to look critically at our own assumptions – which is, after all, one of the main aims of the editors’ much-needed ‘intervention’.
Claire Parry
Shopping and Fucking
by Mark Ravenhill
Gielgud Theatre, London
The title is the give-away that this is no run-of-the-mill production for the West End. The play is brutally tough, explicit and disturbing. This, Mark Ravenhill’s first script, is reminiscent of Irvine Welsh – not the tidy and punch-pulled film of Trainspotting, but the uncompromised impact of his books such as Marabou Stork Nightmares.
We discover early on that three of the five characters are in a three-way bisexual relationship, but neither this nor the ever-present drug use are essential themes; rather the play explores the ways in which the characters continue to act out the scripts of their childhoods and endeavour to find some moral context for their actions. Manipulation, self-destruction and reflections of abuse run throughout the play.
Though a little forced in the first few minutes the players settled to each give strong performances. Lloyd Hutchinson’s struggles to understand himself and to avoid slipping over the edge were convincing and provoked a frightening degree of empathy.
As well as the anguish there is also a fair amount of well-played humour – Mark’s famous sexual partners in a game of truth or dare are inspired. But the audience is given little time to enjoy before being caught on another barb.
Shopping and Fucking certainly does not promote bisexuality, in fact very little about the characters comes out in a truly positive light. However their bisexual lifestyle is an indication that our existence is reaching onto other agendas. Ravenhill uses bisexuality to add another layer of complexity to an already intricately woven scenario.
Whilst most in the audience were held by the play, it was apparent that a sizeable minority were uncomfortable. For me the inappropriately timed laughs and occasional looks or remarks of revulsion were not sufficient to detract from the stage; in some ways they became of interest in themselves as people resisted becoming involved.
Unfortunately the production enjoyed only a short run – it is rumoured to have been part of a deal to get the Reduced Shakespeare Company to the theatre. It has since gone on to the Edinburgh Fringe and is then due to tour. If you want to see something genuinely challenging and new, go and see it – if not, there’s always Cats…
Steve Pointer
