Robert Mapplethorpe, Hayward Gallery

This is one of those exhibitions that finally settles your vague opinion about an artist. It was a round-up of works pieced together from smaller exhibitions across the years. Mapplethorpe, for those of you who haven’t yet heard of him, was a technically brilliant photographer (and druggy SM bisexual of renown).

His determination to press back boundaries made him a hero to many who consider the benchmark of good art to be how far it offends the moral majority. And yes, the infamous picture of Mapplethorpe with a bull-whip up his bottom is in the exhibition.

This was one of the photos which led to funding disputes and Mapplethorpe becoming a cause celebre. But when all is said and done, it’s pretty much how you’d expect a man with a bull-whip up his bum to look. It’s more funny than erotic, and not very much of either. It probably does push back boundaries. To shock nowadays, he’d have had to fit a fire extinguisher up there. Whether it advances Art is another question.

Mostly black and white, these paintings have a hard, cool, masculine, dissecting quality. The pictures of children show an adult mind at work and are disturbing. They don’t show a child’s unconscious sexuality. Bodies are objectified – particularly black men’s bodies.

Mapplethorpe famously said that photographing a flower and a cock were pretty much the same thing, and to him they clearly were. I have always thought his flower pictures the most interesting- the way in which a masculine gay sensibility is brought to bear. There are photographs of two flowers touching that are almost gay porn. The pictures are utterly different from women artists’ work focusing on flowers as symbols of female sexuality and female power. (Contrasting say Georgia O’Keefe whose flower paintings were here a couple of years ago, another bi I believe.)

So admiration for the technical skill, chilled somewhat by what he did with it.

Steve C

‘Bisexuality: the psychology and politics of an invisible minority’
edited by Beth FiresteinSage, 1996. ISBN 0803972741 £19.99 pbk

This book is not aimed at bisexuals. It is aimed at people in the ‘helping professions’, mainly psychologists and social workers.

As many of us have been on the receiving end of ‘help’ meted out by such professionals and have found it often less than helpful (to put it mildly, in some cases) it would seem that this book is sorely needed. However, as in the case of charity pop records, the intention may be laudable but the product itself is often excruciating.

Most of the faults of this book are those common to bisexual anthologies in general, which seem to have followed a pattern set by ‘Bi Any Other Name’ in 1991 and stuck to it.

The first is the overstatement of bisexuality’s allegedly ‘revolutionary potential’, a stance which has often led down a slippery slope to claims of bisexuality being some kind of highly evolved state superior to those boring monosexuals and their narrow little world. This kind of thinking does reflect a stage many bisexuals go through in coming out, a kind of euphoria which usually fades with the realisation that bisexuals are ordinary human beings who are just as capable of being narrow-minded and bigoted as the rest of society. However, none of the contributors to this book seem to acknowledge this or show any sign of exposing it for what it is. Nor is there any acknowledgement that bisexuals might sometimes be genuinely offensive towards lesbians and gay men, or that terms such as ‘monosexual’ are problematic and can be interpreted as insulting. No, the prevailing tone is of us misunderstood little bisexuals being put upon by straight society and those mean lesbians and gays alike. Tellingly, there are index entries for ‘biphobia’ and ‘monosexuality’ but none for ‘bicentrism’ or ‘bisupremacism’.

Related to the above problem is the insular nature of the American bi academic contingent. Nearly all the contributors to this book also had pieces in ‘Bi Any Other Name’ and in some cases seem to be re-hashing their earlier arguments. The effect is of a ‘safe’, self-congratulatory, little circle whose ideas have remained pretty well stagnant for five years. Indeed, the US bias in this collection is even more marked than in previous American anthologies, which will mitigate against its use by mental health and social work professionals in the UK (I suspect its main readership here will be academics).

There is little criticism of previous bisexual writing with the exception of ‘Dual Attraction’, which comes in for a bashing on account of its negative attitude to transsexuals. ‘Dual Attraction’ was unusual among the recent crop of bisexual works in that it did not emerge from the bisexual activist community – so presumably it is seen as a fair target. Nor is there any discussion or criticism of the efficacy of various therapies and counselling techniques, or any contribution from users or ex-users of mental health services.

Maybe it just shows how the difference between North American and British approaches to such issues continues to run deep, encapsulated in the Acknowledgments section, where the Editor thanks her cat ‘for just being my cat’ – with no apparent sense of irony whatsoever. At a time when lesbian, gay and bisexual activists in the UK are doing valuable work on mental health issues (see ‘Therapy on the Couch’, BCN issue 9) this book contributes little to current discussions.

Claire Parry


‘Bisexualities and Aids: International Perspectives’
edited by Peter AggletonTaylor & Francis, 1996

The thirteen essays in this collection consider the different ways in which, in thirteen different countries, Aids is affecting the lives of men (and its focus does intentionally exclude women) who are sexually active with both men and women.

With its cross-cultural focus, it impressively demolishes the idea that ‘heterosexuality’ and ‘homosexuality’ are anything other than one amongst many ways of conceptualising human desire. The book also resists applying the idea of ‘bisexuality’ to the different varieties of simultaneous/consecutive male-oriented and female-oriented desire across the world.

‘Bisexuality’ is not a meaningful term, for instance, for men for whom sex with effeminate men is no different from straight sex, but is simply another form of ‘stronger fucks weaker’.

Sadly, having argued that separate ‘heterosexual’ and ‘homosexual’ worlds don’t exist, too many of these essays then fall back into recreating those worlds and asking whether bisexuals are responsible from carrying HIV from one to the other.

It seems that no amount of education about the practical slipperiness of the real world can dislodge certain strongly held opinions about the connection between bisexuality and HIV.

All the papers end with the inevitable call to devise local and specific safer-sex campaigns, to avoid imposing Western models of sexual identity, and to listen to how people talk about themselves. But what does this mean?

What strategies might usefully attract peer educators from the different communities in which bisexual practice occurs?

If for so many men, same-sex activity is an acceptable part of a straight, macho identity, should more work be done to recruit heterosexual safer sex workers?

The noticeable lack of discussion about how this might in fact operate in practice, and what concrete changes in policy are called for, suggests that the details of how these might be relevant to bisexual behaviour has yet to be addressed.

Jo Eadie

‘Anti-Gay’ edited by Mark SimpsonFreedom Editions (Cassell) 1996

Quotes From The Preface.

‘What is this thing called “gay”? And is it any good?’

‘People are leaving gay because they no longer believe its claims to interpret the world or make it a better place.’

‘This collection of malodorous essays by various disgruntled non-heterosexuals does not promise a new manifesto or movement that puts the Children of Sodom back on course for the Promised Land.

‘Actually it doesn’t promise anything other than the merciless operation of critical faculties where gay demands they be suspended, censored, or diverted into fighting “homophobia”.’

This book’s fault is that: it offers a bucket of spleen, but cannot offer solutions. However, it can be useful and entertaining to rail against the orthodoxy, particularly one which offers so many juicy targets for a kicking. And if the essays contradict themselves – very well, they contradict themselves.

What are the faults of gay? I’ve tried to be systematic.

Cheerleaderism – the need to give a boost to anything gay, however awful it is.

Consumerism – the myth that buying from gay and pseudo-gay businesses is in any way liberating; the chase after consumption; mindless hedonism as a replacement to political activism (or any meaningful activity).

Victimism – we’re nice, they’re horrid, everything is their fault, not our fault.

Mark Simpson dips a pen in acid to write about victimism in his essay ‘Isn’t it fabby to be gay?’: [For out gays] ‘Any unhappiness is clearly the result of straight oppression, self-oppression, or your dealer not having the right contacts.’

Conformism; everything from the belief that gay people must like gay films, to the thought police who try to exclude bisexuals, SM, and heaven knows what else from increasingly tight definitions.

Bi Community News’ own Jo Eadie, among others, highlights the twistings and turnings needed to fit the reality of our sexual lives into a gay straitjacket of theory.

Small ‘c’ conservative politics – the way that the gay political agenda appears hell-bent on defining us as a small, biologically-determined, homogeneous group that is entitled to its rights (but without struggling for anyone elses).

Which leaves other people’s struggles, any attempt to liberate other people, any interest in crossing boundaries or widening freedom out in the cold. These must all be excluded as distractions from the central cause – ‘gay’ rights (but only for the gay).

Peter Tatchell, among others, argues that what started off as an attempt to save the world has changed. Now we want equal rights in an unjust society we’re not interested in changing.

Indeed Tatchell argues that sexual liberation will abolish the current sexual identities (arguing correctly that these are products of relatively recent history). Bisexual possibility will become the usual orientation (well, he thinks so, and who am I to contradict him).

Lisa Power’s piece could perhaps have been chosen to close. While summing up the frustrations of being bounced by around by others’ definitions, Power does not lose hope, that by hanging on in and refusing to be tidied away, a wider understanding will come.

Those of us deeply frustrated by gay orthodoxy should perhaps consider whether we devote our energies enough to working for change.

And as for assumptions and myths, how many of the above complaints might be levelled, in their own way, against the bi world? Time for ‘Anti-Bisexual’, anyone?

Steve C