The Ultimatum: Queer Love. (L to R) Yoly and Mal in Season 2 of The Ultimatum. Cr. Simone Thompson/Netflix © 2023

Girls Girls Girls

Reality dating shows tend to be quite straight bar the odd bi sneaking in (see the Perfect Match writeup) – and two shows are mixing it up with all-queer lineups. First is Netflix’s The Ultimatium: Queer Love. The format is that couples where one wants to get married and the other doesn’t – I’m too young, I’m not sure you’re the one, I’m against marriage as an idea – and so to solve this bump in the road they both go on TV, move in with someone else for three weeks as an alternative choice of partner, and then decide whether to marry their new beau, the one they arrived with, or leave single.

The Ultimatum Queer Love.  Courtesy of Netflix © 2023

I’m sure any therapist would recommend that as the best possible solution. After all, it gets you on TV.

We have five couples and the immediate visual is that queer here looks like four butch-femme couples and one femme-femme couple. One person fleetingly talks about working out issues around their gender; one person passingly mentions being pan. Everyone else… nothing. And no social politics. This is “LBT+” but it’s quite L.

When they pick someone from the other duos that could mix things up and for a moment two of the masc-presenting people talk about what it would be like to date someone who “looks like me”. But when it comes to the crunch… no. The perhaps-enby contestant is terrible at communication and storms off set. Our outspoken pan – Vanessa – is the villain of the piece. She admits she’s not really here to find ‘the one’ and gives every impression that being on the show is three parts boosting her instagram profile, one part a hedonistic chance to sleep with more women. Nothing wrong with that but definitely not what other players have signed up for, and so we all get to hate on the token bi for being untrustworthy. The more things change…

All told the message here is: people who are too different are the drama, steer clear. I’d’ve loved more queer women and enby representation: people articulating their queer experience and story better; how they worked out who they are; people whose journey had taken them through different letters of the queer alphabet and who postively owned that exploration.

It’s just not pretty enough for the camera.

Boys Boys Boys

Meanwhile on the iPlayer, Dannii Minogue has a similar show all about men dating men, I Kissed A Boy. They all arrive as singletons and are put into arbitrary pairs to start – but each day new contestants arrive and anyone who lacks a partner by sundown is on their way out, so the flirting is intense.

There is a lot of kissing. If there isn’t enough boy-on-boy smooch in your TV life this is what you’ve been waiting for. It doesn’t go much beyond that though – the contestants have clearly been given very strict “PG-ish” instructions about what is allowed to happen in the house so we have topless lads grabbing at each other above the waist and no more than topless, but in the dorm room they all share at night there are cute snuggles.

We get a slightly better range of body types than the average dating show too, though this is still within a fairly small range. The lads talk about who is top, bottom or versatile regularly and there is a delicious gay disco soundtrack throughout.

Overall there is less in the way of psychodrama than the women’s show, and more useful exposition about queer experience too as a couple of contestants have struggled with their sexuality over the years and talk about the pressures they felt to not come out. There’s also a wonderfully blokey discussion of testicular cancer.

As a pair of shows, despite the odd bi they feel very lesbian-and-gay a duo. But the ratings seem to have been good – barely were the pixels cold from streaming the boys show when the BBC announced it was to follow up with an I Kissed A Girl season, casting imminent.